Instigator / Pro
7
1377
rating
62
debates
25.81%
won
Topic
#1032

prescription medication is poison

Status
Finished

The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.

Winner & statistics
Better arguments
0
6
Better sources
4
4
Better legibility
1
2
Better conduct
2
0

After 2 votes and with 5 points ahead, the winner is...

Speedrace
Parameters
Publication date
Last updated date
Type
Standard
Number of rounds
3
Time for argument
Two weeks
Max argument characters
10,000
Voting period
One week
Point system
Multiple criterions
Voting system
Open
Contender / Con
12
1641
rating
63
debates
65.08%
won
Description

we will discuss pharmakeai and pharmakon

-->
@Barney

Thanks, I appreciated the comedy lol

Pro please format these better. Here’s a guide: https://tiny.cc/DebateArt

---RFD---
Gist:
Technically the right poisons in low doses heal, which pro misses is the opposite of harm... Anyway, if pro ever met his BoP, he hid such inside the Gish Gallop.

1. “Evil Definitions”
Yes, words are derived from other words. So very evil indeed.
Con asserts that they are named after it for the similar field, instead of the intent to harm (missed the basic evolution of words, but pro never proved the intent was harm so assertion meet assertion).

2. “pharmaceutical industry is a drug cartel”
15 part Gish Gallop.
Con engages in a Gish reply.
Pro complains that he thinks irrelevant things are relevant.

3. Side Effects
Atenolol indeed has side effects, and if you believe sales fear factics employed by water filtration companies (or homeopathic practitioners... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvuzpeAIm24) diluting it into large bodies of water would magically make it stronger (implied and required for threat to be valid, but not directly stated.
Con points out that you need a prescription to avoid taking too much of it to then be poisoned.
Pro insists they prescribe intentionally dangerous amounts.
Con counters that such would make them less money (which would prevent them from being an effective drug cartel).

4. Doctors Are Secretly Greek Cultists and/or Sorcerers
They do have recognizable symbols, so there’s that. And they take evil oaths to do no harm...
Con compares these symbols to the branding on Jaguar cars, completely overlooking how many people those cars literally envelope every year!

5. CIA Surgical Conspiracies
Unsure what this has to do with the resolution...

---

Arguments: Con
See above review of key points. Sorry if anyone is confused by the dusting of comedy mixed in. Basically con wins or ties every relevant contention.

Sources: Tied
Gish Galloped sources do not win the point.

Conduct: Pro
Forfeited round.

-->
@crossed
@Speedrace

Someone remind me tomorrow morning and I'll vote (maybe even tonight depending on how late my social plans go).

pls vote

Jeez

if people are just going to ignore my stuff on other medical evils. Perhaps i should say pharmaceuticals are poison instead of prescription drugs

-->
@King_8

Thanks didn't realize. I knew he didn't know what he was talking about now I am sure of it.

A conspiracy theorist made a more convincing argument than a person who used what was scientifically agreed upon?

I'll add conspiracy theorist to the list of Athias being an anarchist, Religious and generally a person who makes bad arguments.

-->
@TheRealNihilist

Athias has said something about you

DUDE I SUBMITTED MY THING WHAT IS THIS

Well someone's going to have an easy victory.

-->
@Speedrace

I just looked at his previous argument on the very subject. And the voting for it is at best questionable, and borderline lazy. Despite his forfeit, he provided a much better argument than omar2345. Good luck to you, too, Speedrace. Given his thorough list in the previous debate, it'll be difficult to argue against.

-->
@Athias

Look at his previous debates

-->
@Barney

Right XD

-->
@crossed

I agree with you. Good luck in your debate. And I hope you provide a very convincing argument.

I wish I can take it I have 3 debates on though so I cant take more knowing my limit

This will be an easy win for someone...