Instigator / Pro
7
1470
rating
50
debates
40.0%
won
Topic
#1951

Zelda is hotter than Peach

Status
Finished

The debate is finished. The distribution of the voting points and the winner are presented below.

Winner & statistics
Better arguments
3
0
Better sources
2
2
Better legibility
1
1
Better conduct
1
1

After 1 vote and with 3 points ahead, the winner is...

User_2006
Tags
Parameters
Publication date
Last updated date
Type
Standard
Number of rounds
2
Time for argument
Two weeks
Max argument characters
6,666
Voting period
Two weeks
Point system
Multiple criterions
Voting system
Open
Contender / Con
4
1596
rating
42
debates
63.1%
won
Description

This debate is a continuation of "https://www.debateart.com/debates/1348/is-peach-or-zelda-hottest-greater-dddddd". The opponent can search this "Link" up as thoroughly as they possibly need to.
Both persons argue from Odyssey and BotW on the Switch as canon. Older games are not used as canon as that they are outdated lore.

-->
@User_2006

No.

-->
@Alec

Do you know about Zelda?

-->
@User_2006

I honestly don't know too much about the Mario games to begin with.

I just revisited this place and found out how Alec could easily win this debate:

1. State that Gerudo Desert is as cold in the night as it is hot in the day
2. Inquire the evidence that Malice creates heat since no concrete evidence is there
3. Inquire if Peach even cheat in Canon
4. Give another criterion for hot women that makes Peach hotter than Zelda, consider there is no proof of mine is better than his.
5. State that Zelda, for 100 years, does not take human form until Ganon is dead and this form, made out of pure magic, could withstand everything, including heat

Sadly, Alec did none of those and I won.

-->
@User_2006

ofc better, we didn't even finish. the original debate is this one:
https://www.debateart.com/debates/1107/is-peach-or-zelda-hotest-greater-ddddddd

That's the og.

-->
@Crocodile

Is this good, or better than yours?

-->
@User_2006

Hey that's my debate!
I'm gatorade btw

May drop a vote on this

"Peach cheated, but the people who tend to cheat on their spouses tend to be attractive because if you’re unattractive, no one would want to cheat on you, therefore you don’t end up cheating. Not all attractive people cheat, but all people who cheat have to be somewhat attractive, otherwise, they can’t cheat, to begin with. Therefore, Peach’s cheating experience is evidence that she is hotter."

What kind of reasoning is that? First off, attractiveness is subjective, whereas body temperature isn't. The example of how many times a person is cheated on doesnt show attraction, it show commitment. There are many faithful wives that are attractive and never have been cheated on or cheated with others. Idk what kind of reality you live in, but its a false one.

-->
@Alec

"In their respective environments, they tend to have about the same temperature. However, put them in the same environment, and the one who is more adapted to less warm temperatures (Peach) ends up being hotter."

First off, they never were put in an environment in which they have the same temperature. We agreed to use BoTW and Odyssey as Canon information, and Peach never went to a place as hot as Zelda did. Remember that Zelda has been fighting in the castle, tirelessly or tired, suffering through the hotness of the malice(which burns as painful as the lava) and the monsters(who have fire and bomb arrows). We never specified that we are talking about the inside temperature. We are talking in general. If Zelda has a cod heart but a layer of skin almost burnt off, then Zelda has an overall higher temperature consider the castle is MUCH higher in temperature that would be enough to bring up the temperature.

"Since they are cartoon characters, the brighter they are, the more light they give off. Darker objects tend to be hotter only when no light is given off. When light is given off, the opposite is true. This is why white stars are the hottest type of star and the darker the star in color, the less hot it is."

First off, Peach and Zelda are people, not stars. Peach has more of a white skin than Zelda, plus that Peach wears clothes that are less dull, she would absorb less heat and refract them from her body. Before you ask that that is the same as arguing that Peach is hotter in the guts(which I agree), that is NOT. The heat just reflects off her, meaning that the heat is outside her. Meanwhile, Zelda's heat has been at least on her skin, plus that the heat of the lava/malice is MUCH hotter than one reflected off a pink dress, thus Zelda is still hotter.

"I can’t access the link. Sorry."

Then you'd miss at least 1 point of why Peach is less hot, made by me.

"Peach cheated, but the people who tend to cheat on their spouses tend to be attractive because if you’re unattractive, no one would want to cheat on you, therefore you don’t end up cheating. Not all attractive people cheat, but all people who cheat have to be somewhat attractive, otherwise, they can’t cheat, to begin with. Therefore, Peach’s cheating experience is evidence that she is hotter."

Keep in mind the canon of this debate is BotW and Odyssey. Peach cheated in Sunshine, which was about 15 years ago. Peach before cheating could be hot, but the fact that she DID cheat in the PAST means that Peach is deducted her hotness by just cheating. I have proven Zelda is hotter (attractive) in my 2nd round, and also, comparing a woman who was loyal to the very end(Zelda) versus a spoiled girl who just wanders around and gets assaulted by an evil turtle(Peach), I think the former would prevail in how attractive it is.

You have failed to prove why Zelda was less hot than Peach, and because Zelda is stronger and more independent, it means that Zelda is even hotter than Peach.

-->
@User_2006

True, but I'm rusty, and I've been getting tired more than usual, so that might make things even.

-->
@User_2006

Rosalina is hotter than peach and zelda

-->
@skittlez09

Alec is MUCH more experienced than you are, so shut yourself and see us debate.

-->
@Alec

indeed

-->
@User_2006

This is going to be fun I think.

-->
@User_2006

ill pm you somethin that'll shut you up

-->
@skittlez09

Am I wrong? Truth sometimes hurts.

-->
@User_2006

noooooo

-->
@skittlez09

Ok, that is false. Rosalina lives in the comet observatory, which acts as a fictional ISS. Inside the comet observatory, it is as comfortable as back on earth.

The comet observatory is about 22-28 degrees celsius, which means Rosalina is not as hot as Peach and Zelda with boiling conditions at one point or another.

-->
@skittlez09

Rosalina lives in outer space, which is very cold, so she is out of the question. There is no way you are saying that Rosalina is even as hot as any of the two.

-->
@User_2006

naw man Rosalina shits on both of these side hoes

-->
@Alec

say no more

-->
@User_2006

Make the time for arguing 2 weeks and I might accept.