Instigator / Con
1
1460
rating
5
debates
10.0%
won
Topic

is MURDER...in the name of "GOD" valid ?

Status
Finished

All stages have been completed. The voting points distribution and the result are presented below.

Voting points
1
6

With 6 votes and 5 points ahead, the winner is ...

RationalMadman
Parameters
More details
Publication date
Last update date
Category
Religion
Time for argument
One day
Voting system
Open voting
Voting period
One week
Point system
Winner selection
Rating mode
Rated
Characters per argument
30,000
Required rating
2
Contender / Pro
6
1627
rating
333
debates
65.92%
won
Description
~ 3,864 / 5,000

Did JESUS order the torture-beating-slashing-eye gouging-cut out tongue-smash hands-beheading-hanging-burning alive +++ countless other atrocities against.... humanity-animals-environment ? a simple YES or NO will do...

So why did the Roman Catholic Church do this ? for JESUS ? does JESUS approve the CHURCH MURDERING ?

How about JESUS neighbor GOD invention...ALLAH...600 years after the JEWS demanded ROME exterminate the FAKE JEWISH BOY MESSIAH ? in which ROME gladly complied in grand spectacle..how Roman of them !

Makes sense since the last days of JESUS were during the reign of TIBERIUS ...who himself was murdered by a relative....CALIGULA ! wow ...the CHRISTIANS must of had a field day when CALIGULA showed up..they learned well from his total PSYCHOTIC SEX and MURDER episodes....eventually leading to the creation of the ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH ! got to hand it to the ROMANS..they understand POWER and CONTROL strategy..

It's a PERFECT MATCH made in HEAVEN for the ROMAN CATHOLIC PSYCHOPATH CHURCH VAMPIRES !
the lamb = JESUS...condemned by his own people as a FAKE MESSIAH...and demand his execution ! well ROME loves spectacle and what better show than to have the FAKE MESSIAH JEW BOY totally humiliated-whipped-beaten and nailed to a cross along with hundreds of others condemned as CRIMINALS crucified along the road to JESUS final spot to ROT.

and like something out of a Comic Book series...the JESUS BOY FAKE MSSIAH ...VANISHES ! but comes back as some phantom with messages for a select few to create a resurrection farce and elevate him to a GOD status !
Like the kid couldn't do it HIMSELF...let some lowly peasant clowns run around and spread the word !

To further kick the JEWS in the "GOD" ? crotch a NEW TESTAMENT was fabricated for the new boy GOD ! along with lots of totally PSYCHOTIC DOGMA to OBEY or be PUNISHED by ! better yet EXECUTED ! so ROMAN !...

Well after ROME murdered the fake JEW MESSIAH BOY...he was declared a "GOD" another kick in the JEW GOD
monotheistic play they did with their Moses GOD ! Emperor Constantine said so...he declared JESUS to be the only GOD ! wow...do these ROMANS ever give up on POWER ? no FCKG WAY ! 100 years after Constantine
some Church clown invents the word "GOD" from an Eastern Germanic language (now extinct !) while translating the Hebrew Bible and New testament into GOTHIC ! Comic Book Heaven for the CHURCH CLOWNS ! who were
obsessed with assimilating all of humanity into the CHURCH CULT...and did it with HORRIFIC..FEAR-INTIMIDATION
and VIOLENCE...all in JESUS name....

JUST LIKE JESUS WOULD DO if he was around to do it...NO WAY jesus said after he was murdered 400 years earlier..i'm getting the fck of this nightmare planet with these pathetic human mutation disasters...all they do is murder
each other over GODS !

Then 200 years after the Romans came up with the word "GOD" this Muhammad illiterate Arab guy meets his "GOD" in Moses like fashion...(another kick in the JEW crotch) and ALLAH is the new GOD in town ! and he also
got his own Comic Book VOMIT to assimilate and murder all who do not accept him...The KORAN ! ...

So now the Middle East as of the year 600 AD has 3 GODS..each with his own Comic Book to use as a tool to assimilate and enslave weak minded peasants into some PSYCHOTIC GOD CULT ! great just great...

All 3 GODS are guilty of ACCEPT ME or DIE....the psychotic hypnotized sheeple drones that serve these so called CLOWN GOD PLAYING PREACHERS actually do all the MURDER and DESTRUCTION...where is GOD ?

Point = no human EVER needs to be approved and validated to exist and DIE by some GOD playing Preacher clown in a Halloween Glory Gown...until some GOD actually shows up...the CHURCH-MOSQUE-TEMPLE followers are

GUILTY OF MURDER.....and using some invented GOD hoax is no EXCUSE...EVER...

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

Con's argument does seems to be a madman's thought. In the Bible's teaching, there had never been any word of God commanded killing. The only time he brought sword and fire upon Jerusalem was because of the sins they have committed. Of course, like everyone else before me, I will say that con's argument have no real meaning and isn't logical. It is a simple decision as con based nearly all of his argument upon personal interpretation, instead of a solid evidence.

Pro didn't actually provide an opinion of his own, only arguing the pro have no real case to be supported. Despite without any opinion, this debate is a easy pick for the pro side.

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

Con's argument meandered mostly incomprehensibly to a point that doesn't appear to directly answer the resolution he posed. It seems like he had about half a dozen half-formed arguments placed in his posts, each of which is made all the more difficult to understand by strange phrasing and regular use of caps lock.

Pro doesn't really argue his side of the resolution, only arguing that Con hasn't really done his job supporting his side. As Con did not do much to address the resolution in the first place, Pro has an easy time convincing me.

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

I cannot in any way, shape or form justify to myself that this was a genuine attempt at an argument, or a debate on the part of con. His opening round was nonsensical and rambling, being less of an argument and more of a incomprehensible rant.

Given this, pros argument - short though his one - must win, due to lack of genuine and good faith competition.

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

To be clear, this was not a debate. This was the mentally deranged rambling of a person who clearly needs to be medicated if not lobotomized, and a set of sentences posted after that which approximated coherency. The set of sentences which approximated coherency wins.

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

WisdomofAges, what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.

Seriously though...what the heck was this debate even supposed to be about? Some definitions would be nice. It would have been nice to be able to understand what the resolution is about and what valid/invalid means in the context of the debate. It would also have been nice to have an idea of what "killing in the name of God" actually entails. Please actually define your terms clearly in the debate.

To make matters worse - this is a 1 round debate with no chance for rebuttals/defense. Further con's language style and formatting was so incomprehensible that I had to read it 10 times just to get a basic idea of what the heck he's saying. I also had to read pro's argument a few times to comprehend what he is saying, but at least it's somewhat comprehensible.

In the end I see absolutely no real argumentation between the two. I see no clear resolution, no clear burden, and no clear arguments. For this I have to leave the vote a tie.

Added:
Criterion
Con
Tie
Pro
Points
Winner
1 point(s)
Reason:

I had to read CON's argument multiple times to get it and I think he's saying that God (or G.O.D.) and the main big 3 religions are just big conspiracies concocted to oppress, control, and murder people. PRO's argument is that CON's argument is a non sequitur since the vile deeds that CON harps on and on and on about could just as easily be conditions to appease "God" and thus get into heaven. I find CON's argument persuasive to the extent that it questions the flaw in PRO's reasoning. Religion = Evil doesn't get us to the conclusion that it's all a scam. No equal B.O.P. was specified in the description. If there had been, I probably would have made this a tie. As one was never established and PRO presented persuasive grounds to deny CON's case, I vote PRO! To CON, I would recommend to not make one-round debates in the future. Make them at least two so you can actually defend your positions!