Mikal's thoughts feel really close to my own right now, and given that I know my perspective on claims is coming from a town place, I also feel like he's playing in a pretty pro-town way. Him, Savant, and Casey are probs my strongest townreads right now, don't see myself being easily wrong on one of them.
Game Show Mafia DP1
Posts
Hot
Read-only
Total:
920
-->
@ILikePie5
Looks like I'm outnumbered. I'm willing to hop on whatever claim wagon people eventually decide on, but of the two that have three votes, I guess Mhar would be preferable?
-->
@Savant
Why were you fervently going after me and even voted me if, you think I am more likely to be town?
-->
@Earth
Why were you fervently going after me and even voted me if, you think I am more likely to be town?
Because everyone is more likely to be town right now. The starting odds of anyone being town is 70%. Hard to have < 50% odds of being town in just the first day. That said, it's still better to lynch on day 1 than not.
-->
@AustinL0926
I don't really support a whiteflame claim, I don't see what he's done that's scummy and getting a claim just for the sake of getting claims feels pointless.
3 people scumread him right now. It’s not “getting a claim just for the sake of getting claims.”
Claims are meant to be a situational tool for the rest of the game to improve their read on the player who's claiming, not as something that's arbitrarily applied to players who aren't being townread.
I’m confused as to what you mean by this
-->
@AustinL0926
Claims are meant to be a situational tool for the rest of the game to improve their read on the player who's claiming
Wouldn't all claims be given by a player who isn't claiming yet? Like, by definition? I want to lynch WF, so we may as well give him a chance to claim first.
-->
@AustinL0926
Mikal's thoughts feel really close to my own right now, and given that I know my perspective on claims is coming from a town place, I also feel like he's playing in a pretty pro-town way. Him, Savant, and Casey are probs my strongest townreads right now, don't see myself being easily wrong on one of them.
Savant wants WF to claim and Casey wants Mharman to claim. Do you have no reads among the 3 named?
Official Vote Count:
Mharman- 2/6- Casey, whiteflame
Earth- 2/6- Mikal, wylted
Whiteflame- 3/6- Banana, pie, savant
12 hours remain
-->
@ILikePie5
Savant wants WF to claim and Casey wants Mharman to claim. Do you have no reads among the 3 named?
Who's the third besides WF and Mharman?
-->
@Savant
Who's the third besides WF and Mharman?
Wylted
-->
@Savant
I love the effort but can you just link to a Google doc bro
-->
@WyIted
Do you scumread Mharman and/or Whiteflame? Why or why not?
-->
@Lunatic
@WyIted
I love the effort but can you just link to a Google doc bro
Are we allowed to link to Google Docs? I feel like it's kind of against the spirit of the game.
-->
@Savant
I dont care, go ahead
-->
@Savant
personally i would not link a google doc. speaking from experience.
-->
@Lunatic
@Savant
keep in mind google docs can be edited
-->
@Mharman
Do you scumread Wylted and/or WF. Why or why not?
-->
@Mharman
keep in mind google docs can be edited
I'm not so much worried about other people editing (I can just do view only), but I think it opens up a can of worms that can be avoided by just posting in the thread. I mean on DART there's a written record of what I said, everyone can easily look at the same versions, and people don't have to click on a link to see it.
-->
@ILikePie5
well im note taking rn
rn I'd say Wylted scum, Whiteflame torn/null
I mentioned what I had said about Wylted... his early game had none of his usual town tells, and for all his theorycrafting on theme and joining me on Moozer pressure (for whatever reason), it lacked behavioral reads which is something i notice wylted does early games as scum
for Wf i see somethings that look fine like his early game that looked good to me, but in the context of scum having a fake character and role claim, not sure
btw i didnt notice this earlier, but scum's fake character and role claim could be separate from each other... which invalidates a theory i had unpairing certain people and making whiteflame look townier... it still works to unpair Banana and Casey, since they both gave hints about character pretty early on
-->
@Savant
when did a google doc in ace attorney ppl were worried i could edit the doc after i posted the link
i think anyway... i was just told not the use the doc for "security purposes"... which was confirmed to be not related to cybersecurity
-->
@Lunatic
800 is crazy btw
and here you were saying rip mafia. dramatic lol
-->
@Mharman
800 is crazy btwand here you were saying rip mafia. dramatic lol
its cuz i brought mikal back
I'll post more when I get home. For now, suffice it to say that I'm questioning my longstanding town read on Banana. I still want to stick to my guns on Mharman, but I don't think that WF is an altogether terrible choice to push for a claim if we're going to do that.
-->
@whiteflame
I think that’s 4 counting Casey. Full claim plz
-->
@ILikePie5
@Casey_Risk
I think that’s 4 counting Casey. Full claim plz
I'll confirm with Casey that that's what they are actually doing because that last post only expresses a willingness to do so, not an actual a shift. We currently stand at 3 on me and 3 on Mharman.
-->
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
WF is right, I'm a bit reluctant to change my vote here. I'll think it over some more when I get off work.
-->
@whiteflame
Is there a reason you are being reticent?
-->
@Earth
Have you chosen in the 3?
-->
@ILikePie5
If you are asking who to pressure, I don't particularly mind. WF can be shifty as scum and since hes here, I'll have his claim.
Actually DART says Mhar is online.