Office Mafia Day 1

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:06PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:06PM

-->

@Lunatic

Would you please identify your contributions to the game thus far?
What can you tell us about your character and role?

Thats more meant to say I don't have much behavior on you to put you as a town or scum read, not necessarily trying to say you haven't done anything or that you are chopped liver. I acknowledge the game is in its early stages.

Would you please identify your contributions to the game thus far?

What can you tell us about your character and role?

#332

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:07PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:07PM

-->

@Wylted

Anything sir anonymous says is contrived and he is clearly scum. We have a lot of information this dp. Let's move on.

what do you have besides the unlikeness of the AJ claim?

#333

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:08PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:08PM

-->

@Wylted

Why is it not pro town? DO you have inside knowledge that AROSE is town?

It isn't pro-town because there was no reason for it. Vtl'ing people without reason isn't pro-town.

Something seems off about you, and it isn't your newness

unvote VTL Siranonymous

Hopefully this is more pro town in your eyes

Actually, yes. As you can see if you read the Lucid Dreamers mafia, I am quite willing to admit it when I am a prime suspect. Claiming vanilla with only pressure from oromagi was stupid and only helped the mafia. My behavior since then has varied between overly conservative to bizarre. Quite frankly, I don't know how to defend myself without any info.

#334

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:09PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:09PM

TOWN

6. Oromagi

4. PressF Dwight Shrute COP

8. Greyparrot Jim Halpert VANILLA

12. A-R-O-S-E Ryan Howard

11. Airmax1227 Toby Flenderson

7. Lunatic

9. Speedrace CC PressF?

5. Supa

13. Wylted not claiming VIGILANTE

3. drafterman

2. iLikePie5

10. WaterPhoenix

1. SirAnonymous A.J. VANILLA

SCUM

COUNT

SirAn - 5/7 - Supa, Oro, A-R-O-S-E, Speedrace, Wylted

Supa - 1/7 - grey

#335

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:14PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:14PM

-->

@oromagi

Would you please identify your contributions to the game thus far?

I've posted on every page of this game so far, your welcome to sift through my posts.

What can you tell us about your character and role?

Why?

#336

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:15PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:15PM

-->

@Lunatic

If your town then you would probably want to make a convincing argument for your innocence

So far as I know, there is no way to do that in DP1. There's just no information beyond what people say about themselves, and I've already said all I can say.

tell us who you think we should be lynching instead and why.

That's the problem. There has been some bizarre behavior by various people, but none of it seems scummy. The only thing that I see that seems scummy is Wylted un-voting and re-voting like a revolving door in a windstorm, but that type of behavior seems to be normal for him. I can't tell you who else to lynch because I don't have any convincing evidence against anyone else. That is in large part due to what you said yourself:

Any real number of reads this early would seem contrived to me.

#337

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:17PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:17PM

-->

@Lunatic

What can you tell us about your character and role?
Why?

Because he wants to know, of course! That way, you too can have a wagon against you because you made the mistake of revealing your role when the only pressure was from oromagi.

#338

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,826

5

8

11

10.27.2019 06:18PM

5

8

11

10.27.2019 06:18PM

-->

@oromagi

Diss me not my team those are fighting words

#339

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:20PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:20PM

-->

@SirAnonymous

So far as I know, there is no way to do that in DP1. There's just no information beyond what people say about themselves, and I've already said all I can say.

Well you've admitted your actions were wrong in claiming from one vote, so I guess that's really all you can say. TBH the whole read on you is weak, and because of how new you are, reading into your behavior and experience is kind of a stretch. I'm mostly caught up on how well you picked up on things and seemed familiar with certain mafia concepts in the last game we played together in, jsut to make a noob mistake here. Maybe I am looking too much into it. I am surprised you are at L-2 tbh considering the "evidence" on you is pretty weak.

#340

Debates: 34

Posts: 5,754

3

4

11

10.27.2019 06:22PM

3

4

11

10.27.2019 06:22PM

-->

@SirAnonymous

No need to defend yourself. Can read you like a book. Also I have reason to suspect AROSE. Assuming I don't have premises is odd

#341

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:24PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:24PM

-->

@airmax1227

I'd like to hear more from airmax and pie about the SA wagon. They are both great mafia players and I trust their judgements. Also would like to see if they have picked up any good leads. I respect drafters opinion too, but he seems like he also might be sold on the SA lynch.

#342

Debates: 34

Posts: 5,754

3

4

11

10.27.2019 06:25PM

3

4

11

10.27.2019 06:25PM

-->

@oromagi

Post 227 is where speed says press's cop claim is unbelievable because speeds role would make that unlikely

#343

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:26PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:26PM

-->

@drafterman

@ILikePie5

Thoughts on the SA wagon? You really think there is enough there to lynch him? He's at L-2 and its only been one day. Any other candidates for todays lynch?

#344

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:26PM

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:26PM

-->

@Vader

Drafter's play is inherently good, but inherently bad. Sometimes he's smart, sometimes he's very ehhh. Good player, but his strat is ehhh.
Speed is a knockoff Drafter

Let's talk when you aren't 0-2 v. Me.

#345

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:27PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:27PM

-->

@SirAnonymous

It is entirely possible you are town handed a suspiciously obscured character. Its just that that suspicion is the best data we have so far. Also, I notice some trending towards lynching noobies in DP1 perhaps just instinctual lessening of unknown qualities

#346

ILikePie5

Debates: 3

Posts: 13,315

3

7

10

ILikePie5

10.27.2019 06:32PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:32PM

-->

@Lunatic

Give me a sec I’m out

#347

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:34PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:34PM

-->

@Wylted

OK but that's speed. you said:

"press acts confused"

Is there actually a post where PressF acts confused as to why anybody would call him investigative after he claimed cop?

Did you mean Speed, not PressF?

#348

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:36PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:36PM

-->

@Wylted

Assuming I don't have premises is odd

It's not odd in the slightest because you haven't provided any. If you have evidence that Arose is scum, tell us what it is.

#349

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:39PM

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:39PM

Ugh, a lot to catch up on.

#350

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,693

8

10

11

https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/2867/toby-was-the-scranton-strangler

10.27.2019 06:43PM

8

10

11

10.27.2019 06:43PM

#351

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,826

5

8

11

10.27.2019 06:45PM

5

8

11

10.27.2019 06:45PM

-->

@drafterman

Nah I’m 1-1 hoe, you only won as scum bc GP saved ur ass

#352

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:47PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:47PM

-->

@Lunatic

I'm mostly caught up on how well you picked up on things and seemed familiar with certain mafia concepts in the last game we played together in, jsut to make a noob mistake here.

If you will notice, the things I have learned are things that can be learned by reading the rules and the descriptions of the roles, while the things that I haven't learned are things that can't be learned by reading the rules and the descriptions of the roles. I did know about roles in the Lucid Dreamers Mafia because I've played live mafia with cops and doctors and I had read a description of the most common online roles before playing the game. I didn't know not to claim vanilla because this is the first game I have ever played where claiming roles has been an issue (there was no claiming roles in the live mafia I played). There was one post warning against claiming vanilla early, but I figured there were exceptions, like being under pressure. However, since I have never played a game where pressure was an issue (there is pressure in live mafia, but you really can't defend yourself from it, so it doesn't count), I didn't know that only one vote from an assertive player wasn't enough pressure. That's why I made the mistake of claiming vanilla. I can learn how to use logic and understand concepts by reading, but I can't learn how to behave or read others' behavior by reading.

#353

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:49PM

3

7

10

10.27.2019 06:49PM

-->

@Vader

Nah I’m 1-1 hoe, you only won as scum bc GP saved ur ***

Doesn't count. He won because his team won. The quarterback doesn't lose when his team wins just because he played badly.

#354

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:49PM

3

6

9

10.27.2019 06:49PM

-->

@Vader

That's not how the game works.

#355

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:49PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:49PM

-->

@SirAnonymous

Fair enough.

#356

Debates: 4

Posts: 23,706

3

4

10

10.27.2019 06:50PM

3

4

10

10.27.2019 06:50PM

-->

@Vader

Don't be silly. Even lunatic can verify I play terrible as scum. The only way we won is simply because you lied.

#357

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,896

3

6

10.27.2019 06:51PM

3

6

10.27.2019 06:51PM

-->

@Vader

Well not to take anything away from GP, but in the mafia discord GP was asking for advice from Drafter. Drafter was dead the whole game and still stayed caught up and helped his team mate. I thought drafters play was overall really good, I think he just got unlucky DP1.

#358

Debates: 4

Posts: 23,706

3

4

10

10.27.2019 07:04PM

3

4

10

10.27.2019 07:04PM

-->

@Lunatic

This is correct. Drafter was the one making all the decisions.

#359

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

10.27.2019 07:14PM

3

6

9

10.27.2019 07:14PM

I think both press and speed are town.

I'm more interested in the response to SA than SA themselves. For example, I'd judged Oro to be more considerate in his lunch targets but he readily goes with the pressure on SA, more readily than I'd expect.

#360

Debates: 3

Posts: 4,140

3

7

10