What debate style format should I use?

Author: DynamicSquid ,

Posts

Total: 4
DynamicSquid
DynamicSquid's avatar
Debates: 29
Posts: 182
1
3
11
DynamicSquid's avatar
DynamicSquid
1
3
11
So growing up, I was participated in debate related activities, and through my 5 plus years of debate tournament experience, I've used one and only one style. But I'm wondering, does this apply to online debate, or more specifically, this website? Here's how I was taught debate format (adjusted for online debate).

- 3 rounds (6 speeches)
- each speaker goes once per round

Round 1:

Proposition introduces the topic, defines any necessary terms, and if needed, creates a fair and balanced model
Proposition will then move on into presenting his/her 2 contentions supporting the topic
Proposition then concludes/summarizes his/her speech

Opposition "clashes" with Proposition, pointing out all the mistakes or inaccuracies found in Proposition's speech
Opposition then states his/her 2 contentions going up against the topic
Opposition then concludes/summarizes his'her speech

Round 2:

Proposition clashes with Opposition, pointing out all the mistakes or inaccuracies found in Opposition's Speech (he/she could also reinforce what was previously stated)
Proposition will then move on into his/her final argument(s) supporting the topic
Proposition then concludes/summarizes his/her speech

Opposition clashes with Proposition, pointing out all the mistakes or inaccuracies found in Proposition's Speech (he/she could also reinforce what was previously stated)
Opposition will then move on into his/her final argument(s) supporting the topic
Opposition then concludes/summarizes his/her speech

Round 3:

Proposition clashes with Opposition, pointing out all the mistakes or inaccuracies found in Opposition's Speech (he/she could also reinforce what was previously stated)
Proposition summarizes his/her speech in total
No new information can be brought up

Opposition clashes with Proposition, pointing out all the mistakes or inaccuracies found in Proposition's Speech (he/she could also reinforce what was previously stated)
Opposition summarizes his/her speech in total
No new information can be brought up

END



So that's what a normal tournament debate is like for me. But what about this website? I can already see that some people follow this outline, but is that the preferred way, or is a more natural or restriction free style of debate preferred? Also, will there be any changes to the website in the future that requires a format to your speech (I'm not for or against a change, I'm just curious)?

In short, is there a preferred style to online debate, and if not, what are the possibilities that it could become a reality?

Thanks,
Dynamic Squid
David
David's avatar
Debates: 84
Posts: 1,206
4
7
10
David's avatar
David
4
7
10
--> @DynamicSquid
Hi, DynamicSquid! 

I want to begin by welcoming you to DebateArt.com! The format that I like to do on for online text debates as follows:

Round 1: Opening arguments only
Round 2: Rebuttals to opening arguments
Round 3: Defense of opening arguments
Round 4: Summary/Close

Another possibility:

Round 1: Opening arguments only
Round 2: Rebuttals to opening arguments
Round 3: Defense of opening arguments
Round 4: Rebuttals to Defense
Round 5: Summary/Close


RationalMadman
RationalMadman's avatar
Debates: 348
Posts: 10,628
10
10
11
RationalMadman's avatar
RationalMadman
10
10
11
You can structure your twisting of the truth any way you want, in the end it's about pleasure to the voters' eyes and minds.
Ramshutu
Ramshutu's avatar
Debates: 42
Posts: 1,826
6
9
10
Ramshutu's avatar
Ramshutu
6
9
10
--> @DynamicSquid
Structure imo doesn’t matter, I much prefer general flow and back and forth over structure; I find it especially hard to read when there is a disjoint order with rebuttals skipping a round like the more formal structures come with.