Official Vote Count:
Bullish (3/5) - Cerulean, Lunatic, Whiteflame
“You look like hammered shit Mason.”
—Joseph Bowman
Call of Duty: Black Ops Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
209
-->
@Mharman
See above
-->
@ILikePie5
Thx
Yknow I’ve never played BO1 but this game makes me wanna try it at some point. Story is completely spoiled for me, but whatever. I’ve had 15 years at this point anyway
Been thinking about older games in general. Modern stuff just ain’t it
-->
@Mharman
Bo Burnham Mafia DP1Not a whole lot of defense of the claim itself, but rather a defense of him making the claim.
Honestly forgot about this one, though I'll note that even this was a special case: I literally just claimed my scum role verbatim. Definitely a poor approach, but I don't think there's a scum Strengthener in this game.
-->
@Mharman
Just skimmed some of your posts, I’ll got back and read them but for now I’m also inclined to get a bullish claim. I already said I sussed him before, and I’m not jumping on this wagon to save myself. I’d. VTL but then he’d be at L-1.
I’d also be willing to claim if the time comes. If possible though I’d like to only share my role. I don’t care if scum knows my role, and it’s semi-confirmable, but if I give them my character that’s just free information.
Since I posted my scumread, we just witnessed him parrot a much-stated sus on Bullish (almost feel like my take was copied and taken further) and then sus Wylted the second Whiteflame questions something Wylted did. And then there’s the whole “I think scum is inexperienc- oop, nvm” thing. I’m not inspired.
In case this ends up moving to a lynch, I’ll defend myself on these things. DP1 I almost never have strong reads at all, other players can attest to this. When I said that scum might be experienced, I was throwing out ideas, not providing hard reads. I didn’t parrot your stance on bullish, and also, how is that scummy? Two people can have similar ideas. I also sused WyIted a tiny bit from the beginning, though like I said, I don’t really sus people that much DP1.
Here’s my full reads
Town:
Lunatic: He’s active and making great points. I could see how he’s buddying me and drawing attention away from banana and me, but I find it unlikely so I have no reason to sus for now
Banana: I mostly agree with Luna’s reasoning
Slight town:
Earth: He’s always this inactive DP1
Casey Risk: I always have a hard time reading Casey but I’ll go town for now
Null:
WyIted: Playing normally. Maybe he’s lurking a little? But I’m probably just seeing shadows
Whiteflame: Not really understanding the reason some people have him as scummy
Slight scum?
Mharman: Same as Lunatic’s assesment, but that’s not to say I actually want to pursue a claim. These reads aren’t very strong
Bullish: I’ve explained my reasoning here. This time I do want to pursue a claim
Approximately 8.5 hours remaining.
My reads are something like
Town
Cerulean
WF
Mhar
Lunatic
Nullread
Wylted
banana
Moozer
Scum
Bullish
I'll admit I pretty much have no read on banana or Moozer, but I am fine with Bullish. I think its a little odd that Bullish is seemingly pushing away claiming and he didn't seem to address the pressure growing on him. Another thing to note, not necessarily a scummy thing, is that WF suggested we soft, Lunatic gives a reason why he doesn't want to and immediately relents. I thought that was weird.
Haven't had as much time as I'd like to write up a set of reads, but I can't let the DP end without them. I'll note that, with roughly 8 hours left in the DP at time of writing, we're still very short on options, particularly if Bullish is obstinate. I've already stated my thoughts on Moozer and Bullish, neither of which have shifted much. Could be a team, but I doubt it.
Casey - The response to my initial efforts for a softclaim and, in particular, the follow-up question make me townread Casey for the time being. It's a light behavioral read, but I'll take it.
Lunatic - We've been through plenty of arguments before and this seems less pointed than I'd expect if Luna was going for a mislynch opportunity. His analysis has been pretty good and his responses to me have made sense, even if it does seem like he's adding in small points that aren't entirely accurate. Null.
Mharman - I'm never all that surprised to see good analysis from Mharman. We mostly seem to be on the same wavelength and he's been coming out with many of the same thoughts I have before me, so he looks town to me.
WyIted - Slight townread, mainly a gutread on this one. The back-and-forth with me after my claim comes off as "I have a good idea to town confirm you" that I don't think scum would suggest they have at all.
Earth - His responses to Casey's questions look at least somewhat distinct so he's not just following someone's lead and his pushback on Bullish's sussing Mharman makes sense. Not a lot to grab onto given the limited posting, so he stays null for me.
Banana - Not enough posting to work with, since she's only posted 4 times including a check-in. I like her response to Casey, but other than that, it's just been a question about a post Casey incorrectly referenced and an issue with the type of pushing we're doing, and that last one makes me hesitant to put her in the town camp. The potential to reveal strong town PRs is a given from pushing anyone. She knows this by now. So those last two posts balance to null.
-->
@Earth
Another thing to note, not necessarily a scummy thing, is that WF suggested we soft, Lunatic gives a reason why he doesn't want to and immediately relents. I thought that was weird.
My issue here was, as I expressed in the post suggesting it, that I don't know enough about this game to make a call on what kind of softclaim would be sufficient to give us some insight without giving scum too much information. I'm relying heavily on others' knowledge of the game. My own research suggested this wouldn't narrow the window too much, but when I see multiple people stating that this would give too much information, I defer to that.
-->
@whiteflame
Hm. At any rate, I think Lunatic gave a pretty non rehearsed answer, so that interaction seemed to me that WF/Lunatic is unlikely.
Unless I have a good reason to town read bullish, I am okay being the hammer if it comes down to a no lynch.
I don't know that a no lynch is a terrible ideal currently especially since I am struggling to come up with any reads at all. Ultimately I feel useless this game.
I'll swing on by to help with the lynch. Unless Bullish gives a really good reason not to, we'll probably lunch him this evening.
Sorry I have been busy. Should be more active soon. I am around and available to vote. Seems we still have time so I will wait for bullish to post.
VTL iamabanan
-->
@WyIted
Any reason why?
Official Vote Count:
Bullish (3/5) - Cerulean, Lunatic, Whiteflame
Banana (1/5) - Wylted
“I have plans for you American.”
—Nikita Dragovich
Approximately 3 hours remaining
Alright... I think we waited long enough. VTL Bullish. I'll be around until the hammer, but I'm pretty sure Bullish is scum.
-->
@Bullish
Meant to tag you.
Official Vote Count:
Bullish (4/5) - Cerulean, Lunatic, Whiteflame, Earth
Banana (1/5) - Wylted
“YOU CAN’T KILL ME”
—Frank Woods
-->
@ILikePie5
Fine
Unvote VTL bullshit
He said bullshit not bullish so I'm still alive right?
Anyway I'm cop.
Both scum are among the veteran players.
-->
@Moozer325
gg. I believe in the power of moozer. Don't fail me lad.
STOP POSTING
Final Official Vote Count:
Bullish (5/5) - Cerulean, Lunatic, Whiteflame, Earth, Wylted
Bullish was lynched. He was…INNOCENT. You have 24 hours to submit night actions.
-->
@whiteflame
Lock please