alr I'm here. Townreading USer, Banana, Mikal, and Lunatic. I think there's two scum between Whiteflame, Pie, and Moozer. I'll be typing up those reads shortly
Jet Fighters Mafia - DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
213
-->
@Mikal
I have no idea why you would fake claim a character when no one would know the theme but this is my character lol
wait fr?
forgot Wylted. Townreading him as well
The CC changes things
So a few notes. I have 0 idea why he would fake claim a character. Either bullish fucked up or is doing bastard shit or pie actually ironically nailed the theme with stealth vs non stealth.
Yknow I had felt User's claim was just an effort to be extra helpful bc i felt there was no reason to offer that as scum. I townread Mikal behaviorally, so I'm inclined to believe him. It would be prudent of me to double check something though hold on
Caller her User feels weird. I'm sticking with That2
*Calling her
-->
@Mikal
@That2User
Ok so I double checked and there's no role that can edit flips in this game, plus it seems we're getting complete flips upon death
I don't think Mikal has an incentive to trade like this as scum
I'm still gonna type up my reads before voting
Could be voting shit at play I guess... still townreading MIkal tho
Mharm Actually checking that reads as hard town
Town block
Luna
Whiteflame
Me
Mharm
Scum
User
Remainder
Wylted
Pie
Banana
And moose profile pic
-->
@Mikal
And moose profile pic
We call him Moozer
short for Moozer325
I just read this back I am so baffled. Why fake claim a character unless the stealth vs non stealth is correct. But if it’s correct white flame is stealth and user was voting him
I am actually baffled at the logic to a fake character claim here.
-->
@Mikal
The split doesn't have to be stealth vs non-stealth, unless That2 unknowingly decided this game needed more comedy
-->
@Mharman
I agree that doesn’t have to be he split I just can’t work out the logic for a fake character claim. No one could likely guess the split so sayinf hit actual character has no downside unless you think someone can figure out the split and that has been the only theory thrown out.
The incentive to fake claim just makes 0 sense to me unless they thought it would give the game away theme wise.
-->
@Mikal
maybe that2 was trying to get townread off logic like this...
Yknow I had felt User's claim was just an effort to be extra helpful bc i felt there was no reason to offer that as scum
... not realizing exactly why only townies tend to do this, and is now paying the price
I think it's funny that we're not even reading whether that2 is town or scum anymore; we're just theory crafting why the hell she did this lol
-->
@Lunatic
Even then, there’s a ton of good roles even on the “both scum and town list” and JOAT is probably the scummiest thing he could have claimed, why would he do that over literally any of the other options?
Risk of CC. By claiming JOAT as scum, he doesn’t risk a CC because only one of the role can exist in the game per Bullish
-->
@Mikal
You are making it out like he could fake claim anything and have it be better than JOAT. I am disagreeing so hard with this. I’m agreeing it’s his role. Why risk a CC when you could claim your actual character and role for a lot of reasons. No one will know the theme so the character won’t appear scummy and JOAT can’t be dual sided so seeming a little scummy in a role claim is better than risking a cc
+1
-->
@Lunatic
Also he didn’t have to role claim in general. The pressure on him was for character claim, the fact that he in good faith full claimed looks even better for him. As mafia he just bides his time and full claims after he’s narrowed down more claims and reduced the risk of CC more. The move he made just doesn’t make sense from a scum Whiteflame perspective unless he is specifically banking on the wifom argument I’m making now to save him, and that’s a lot of risk to hedge his game on for no reason. Whiteflame isn’t beyond taking risks, but I don’t think he takes dumb risks that have a high probability of failure when he could easily just play this a million better ways.
This I would agree with. But then again he was fine shooting a claimed PGO, so you’re right, it’s WIFOM. The biggest thing to me right now is that he’s a stealth fighter and everyone else isn’t
-->
@Mikal
I am cc’ing this. I’m the mig 21
Lmfaoooo
VTL That2
-->
@Mikal
So a few notes. I have 0 idea why he would fake claim a character. Either bullish fucked up or is doing bastard shit or pie actually ironically nailed the theme with stealth vs non stealth.
That2 is atrocious at fake claiming. She’s scum. Nothing more there
-->
@Mharman
I think it's funny that we're not even reading whether that2 is town or scum anymore; we're just theory crafting why the hell she did this lol
To get towncred. She likes fake claiming. If she’s town, she just threw like the previous game basically
yall can I post my reads before the NP in case I die in the night?
But why fake claim lmao. I mean the flip will probably tell us the theme
But the fact she was willing to off whiteflame makes me read him as town unless they were trying to create a divide between them. Just so fucking odd and such a bad choice
1. ILikePie5: Non Stealth
2. whiteflame: J-36 - JOAT: 1x Commuter, 1x Manip, 1x..
3. Lunatic: Non Stealth
4. WyIted: ME262 - Miller
5. Moozer325: Non Stealth
6. That2User
7. iamanabanana: F-16 - ???
8. Mikal: MIG-21 - ???
9. Mharman: Non Stealth
-->
@Mikal
But why fake claim lmao. I mean the flip will probably tell us the themeBut the fact she was willing to off whiteflame makes me read him as town unless they were trying to create a divide between them. Just so fucking odd and such a bad choice
There’s no guarantee it truly is Stealth/Non Stealth. She was prob just trying to gain town cred. Or she’s just lying about her character again for no reason.
-->
@Mikal
But the fact she was willing to off whiteflame makes me read him as town unless they were trying to create a divide between them. Just so fucking odd and such a bad choice
noted
-->
@That2User
If you're doing some retarded gambit, out it please.