-->
@WyIted
1x cop? You know there is a question to answer every DP right?
I was under the impression that the prize would be different each time. It's what the OP seems to imply
Game Show Mafia DP1
Posts
Hot
Read-only
Total:
920
-->
@whiteflame
Dude, I already softed a strange aspect of my role way back at the start of this DP. I'll be happy to clarify that later when it matters. Yours still stands out.
If you are town and claiming an odd variant than why does the fact this is an odd variant bother you?
-->
@Savant
It's a 1x cop though. Is a miller really needed to balance that? And why would town be punished with that role for solving the trivia challenge correctly?
Yeah, I have no idea. It doesn't make sense. My vote stays.
-->
@WyIted
1x cop? You know there is a question to answer every DP right?
Ok that's true, but I still don't think town would be punished with a miller for getting trivia right. Kind of goes against the spirit of the challenge. And the cop is not even guaranteed, not powerful enough to need a counter balance.
-->
@Casey_Risk
I was under the impression that the prize would be different each time. It's what the OP seems to imply
Who knows maybe next time it's 2x
He did say town would be underpowered this game sorry I have a shitty role, pretty sure most of us do
-->
@WyIted
If you are town and claiming an odd variant than why does the fact this is an odd variant bother you?
Look back through my posts. Where do I mention the odd variant? It's odd that your Miller role would somehow only be active half the DPs, but that's not among the problems I keep coming back to.
-->
@Savant
Ok that's true, but I still don't think town would be punished with a miller for getting trivia right. Kind of goes against the spirit of the challenge. And the cop is not even guaranteed, not powerful enough to need a counter balance.
It's almost guaranteed with so many people answering
-->
@ILikePie5
SOPed
Sry, what does this mean?
-->
@WyIted
If mafia win, they will receive a 1x politician vote.If a town member wins, they will recieve a 1x cop ability.
If mafia gets it first, I don't think any town member gets the 1x cop.
-->
@Savant
Standard Operating Practice. It's used for negative utility roles that are typically automatically claimed, like Miller and Hated.
-->
@Earth
@Mikal
@Moozer325
@iamanabanana
Please hammer Wylted. He has claimed to be an Even Night Miller and his justification makes zero sense
-->
@ILikePie5
Yup, easy hammer. It’s almost so bad of a claim that it’s a little townie, but that’s too WIFOM for me.
VTL WyIted
Already don't lynch me until I can give full reads
-->
@WyIted
Already don't lynch me until I can give full reads
You're at L-1 I think. If you're somehow town, then be quick about it.
if that's hammer lemme post my notes
i dont buy the claim either
but if it is fake (ie Wylted guilty) keep in mind it indicates scum likely used their fake role claim already... which could point to Whiteflame or Moozer cause they both hinted their role
Banana
7- asking how we all want to kick things off, reluctant to take any initiative
33- soft claim thing, voluntarily, chose pre/post 2000
199 joining moozer pressure for reasons ig
399 thinks mikal is going for easy mislynches and scumreads him, omgus-y, but his logic on Banana is eh given her explanations for what she did earlier
421 thoughts on Earth. Fair, seem geniuine
606 big read list alert holy cow
Mikal
13-30 Pressuring Whiteflame hard, perhaps a little excessively
38 Trying to get under people’s skin, does get reactions but im not sure what he’s looking for
57 theory debate w Pie
73 insight
177 the most natural reads ive ever seen holy
209 mafia can win by coasting idea
259 the dumbest read ive seen all game
262 another reaction test, trs savant off it
275 wants input from wf, unwilling to plan himself
288 what he wants to do
303 so unsure of me, wants earth to fullclaim in alignment with his keyboard droolers idea from last game
309 wants stuff from Moozer
315 downplays how original my reads are
346 looks like genuine frustration
399 (Banana) honestly it feels like a lot of his reads are hunches more than anything else
401 (Casey) alleged township of Mikal’s
408 looks more honest
465 real shit
480
484 more analysis on earth
537 cooking, feel like im on a similar wavelength to him
548 (casey) tough between he and casey
612 I wouldnt say Earth has played scummy… didn’t he also say Earth town play is mirrored earlier? Hm.
622 saying i am more towny with my reads
Forgot post number, seems to be the only person townread wylted
626 “mostly NAI but scum tend to do it”... what?
630 (Casey) Mikal’s epiphany… noted
Whiteflame
17- Doesn’t want to deal with full claiming, but was willing to give a piece of info
75 frustration
234 reads look kinda natural but no real scumreads
325 unvotes me after i post reads
564
627 more reads, not super impressed
Pie
55 directing traffic, wants to avoid instant pressure
56 wants something from earth
100ish pressure for the sake of pressure is useless, not against pressure
419 TMI?
469 slight misunderstanding of fake claims
449 just in agreement with others’ scumreads
477 original thought
494 defense of earth. Seems normal, but i notice the “where there’s smoke there’s fire” attitude from him
546 no i dont pie, but this is a good look for you
Wylted
66 Opportunistic
80s-90s meaningless theorizing, still no behavioral reads
319 Moozer to claim for same reasons others have echoed
579 wants full claims from Moozer and Austin, the inactives… opportunism i swear. Still no behavioral reads outside of what he gave me… i had the expectation he would give more behavioral thoughts periodically, even after i asked, but it seems he can only think about behavior when asked to this game
Savant
56, taking a page out of my book, for the sake of his format
I didnt note the post but inconsistent logic on WF and Banana- before 100 i think
160 asks Lunatic a question publicly
356 sus over dumb technicality
360s argument w earth
Casey
80 defense of Banana
91 tr savant
Back and forth with Wylted and Mikal at points
401 402 “mikal could be town, but eh also fakeable” fencesitting?
450 defense of Banana that has already been explained by Banana
450s thoughts on others thoughts
511 thoughts on pie. Finally something original
528 push on Mikal
548 also cooking? This is difficult between her and Mikal
630 can see what Mikal is talking about
Earth
157 wants to do a few timed claims
235 some reads, semi omgus, others weak, wants an inactive lynch
240 his thoughts on wf
350 the soldier claim- incentives to claim like this are low imo cause it looks super fake… incentives to claim his real role are also low as scum, but really? Claim heavily incetivizes keeping him alive which is normally the prob i have w whiteflame’s claims. Strentghtener was his not Whiteflames, i forgot about that (Ace Attorney) justification tracks. Big question is if Lunatic would put this in his game… incentives for claiming it out of the gate are low but makes sense under pressure. Frustration is NAI cause earth is bruce banner and his secret is he’s always angry lol
362 comes across as honest
360s argument w savant
452 dumb argument cause scum has a free character- that means they dont have to worry about being CCd
Moozer
331 says he’s confimable
438 reads
520 his thoughts. Seems normal cause they’re low level basic shit, but the fact that he indiciated it is a good sign
530 more of his thoughts. Finally putting those brain cells to work
Austin
577 shows up says role in confirmable
583 1x gladiator… claim fits game mechanics… i buy it
631 some initial reads… dopesnt seem out of the ordinary for Austin
-->
@Mharman
which could point to Whiteflame or Moozer cause they both hinted their role
Or Earth, who full climed
also if we caught scum here Imma be super confident next dp- im very much not worried about dying in the night ill say that. not even a lil bit
Official Vote Count:
Whitelfame- 1/6- banana
Earth- 2/6- Mikal, wylted
Wylted- 5/6- savant, casey, Whiteflame, pie, moozer
-->
@Mharman
if that's hammer lemme post my notes
Not hammer yet, WyIted should be at L-1
-->
@Mharman
56, taking a page out of my book, for the sake of his format
Post 56 was Pie
-->
@Savant
zero chance soldier is scum's fake role claim... that'd be some bait shit from Lunatic and it'd be too obvious for them to claim anyway... if he's guilty off his claim it point at the same thing that a guilty flip from wylted would
if he used a fake claim it was the character one, see notes
I'm not entirely sure the character and role claim are meant to be used together... after reading the OP more closely i dont think so
ok that wasnt hammer. fyi i got to 631 and no further on my notes
We can still post after the hammer, right? Until Luna posts final votes?
honestly i might hammer hold on a sec
i wanna do some stuff first tho
-->
@Savant
i would be careful about that
-->
@Savant
36 then i think idr
-->
@Mharman
Do you mean the long one, i.e. my first read set?
-->
@Mharman
but if it is fake (ie Wylted guilty) keep in mind it indicates scum likely used their fake role claim already... which could point to Whiteflame or Moozer cause they both hinted their role
Don't really get how this hints at us, but fine, we'll cross that bridge next DP.