townreads ofr mine rn are banana and austin for sure, i like moozer's behavior. I think Earth is behaviorally town but the role is so off
here's what I know: Lunatic loves to take obscure roles and see if he can make them work. In theory that means soldier should be reasonable, but it creates a situation where scum could get three mislynches and still lose... granted I think town should be able to survive as many mislynches as there are scum players (Vaarka's golden rule) but idk to what degree Lunatic agrees with that. I can see Lunatic arguing it's balanced bc of the numbers disadvantage town is at, and that the role will get sussed of being claimed eventually... although that would make the 8v3 even worse for town in practice. I do know it's swingy role and if there's one word to decrible Lunatic's games, it's: "Swingy" with a capital S
so i think there is plausibility in his claim