I also think confirmable roles might deserve a town lean, since scum was given a fake role claim. Why bother with that when scum have confirmable roles? Also don't see what use popular really has aside from confirmability, so it's probably a town role more often than not. (Otherwise what would the point of it be?)
Game Show Mafia DP2
Posts
Read-only
Total:
791
-->
@Savant
I also think confirmable roles might deserve a town lean, since scum was given a fake role claim. Why bother with that when scum have confirmable roles? Also don't see what use popular really has aside from confirmability, so it's probably a town role more often than not. (Otherwise what would the point of it be?)
It could be multiple things. Maybe he’s lying and the DP ends or something
-->
@Moozer325
Does your power go away at MYLO/LYLO?
I mean maybe it helps scum at MYLO, but that's rare enough as to make it a pretty useless role for scum.
-->
@ILikePie5
Maybe he’s lying and the DP ends or something
Let's test it then. If he's lying, we lynch him tmrw.
-->
@ILikePie5
Also I feel like you have a tendency to hyperfocus on one point and lynch people because of that. Moozer's behavior overall has been towny (see my reads list). I've also been in the position of having information and really wanting to use it. We thought that the trivia answers were going to town confirm someone, and it sucks that they didn't, but sometimes you gotta give up on what you thought was a lead when it's leading you astray. There's likely some mechanical explanation for count not lining up. Scum could easily have a role that affords them two guesses, for example.
-->
@Savant
Oh HELL no. We don’t know if scum got the question right or wrong, you do realize if he’s telling the truth, scum could just commandeer someone’s vote if they got the question right, correct?
-->
@Mharman
if he’s telling the truth, scum could just commandeer someone’s vote if they got the question right, correct?
Then we lynch Earth tmrw for lying.
He’d be quicklynched.
Actually makes his role make sense too in the context of a politician that scum can get.
-->
@Savant
? Wdym
-->
@Mharman
Actually makes his role make sense too in the context of a politician that scum can get.
You realize if that happens we can just lynch Earth?
-->
@Savant
No. Explain the logic
-->
@Mharman
? Wdym
Earth said he got the cop, which would mean scum didn't get the politician vote.
-->
@Lunatic
@Savant
They can’t both get it right and get rewarded?
Lunatic, can you confirm or deny this?
I don’t think he’s lying. But pie is correct on this. Affiliation is not confirmation. Luna loves behavior games and likes to teach people lessons.
Popular mafioso was a meta at some point. Not saying he is but again why behavior is so important. I don’t think either of them are in the priority list atm but it’s a big mental note. I stand by Luna stepping in was to prevent something.
Don’t get to stuck on this today though.
Lynch is between wf Ana and Mharm
We also have to decide who to give the item to
-->
@Mikal
Popular mafioso was a meta at some point. Not saying he is but again why behavior is so important.
Behaviorally, Moozer is a strong town read for me. I think if you look through my reads list, there's a good chance you'll agree.
-->
@AustinL0926
Still awaiting your response after you check your past message with Lunatic
-->
@Mikal
Lynch is between wf Ana and Mharm
Agree
We also have to decide who to give the item to
Who do most people trust? Giving it to Moozer is hedging our bets, because if Moozer is scum, then the scum pair isn't exactly hidden (if Moozer is scum we know Earth is scum). But maybe people would feel safer with you or me or Pie.
Whoever it is, we gotta agree to go with the majority and all fall in line.
-->
@Mikal
Oh, or Austin
-->
@Savant
I’ll read through hopefully tonight but this is the last thing he we want to get bogged down on regardless. Make a mental note Luna stepped in and then focus on actual scum behavior.
-->
@Mikal
I’ll read through hopefully tonight but this is the last thing he we want to get bogged down on regardless...focus on actual scum behavior.
That's what I'm asking you to read through though. Behavior.
-->
@Savant
I’m agreeing with you. Sorry that was not directed at you in specific. Just a general statement
-->
@Savant
I think whiteflame
Ana , Mharm
Thoughts ?
-->
@whiteflame
@Mharman
@Moozer325
@iamanabanana
What are the exact justifications yall were provided. Paraphrase to the best of abilities your PM
-->
@Mikal
I think whiteflameAna , MharmThoughts ?
Yep, those are my top 3 scum reads. List has only shifted a few percentage points since I last posted.
-->
@Savant
No I mean order wise.
would you agree with that
-->
@Mikal
@Savant
I honestly wanna lynch Banana gun to my head right now
-->
@Mikal
From scummiest to least scummy:
Mharman (55% odds of being town)
iamanabanana (56.5% odds of being town)
whiteflame (57% odds of being town)
-->
@ILikePie5
I think there is a high chance of her I just think the other two are worse if I’m being honest.
Mharm is hard for me to read in general but I think it’s possible he scum slipped with the fake claim
And if he didn’t. I think wf is the next one who was likely to have the fake claim based on how he claimed.
Ana is right after that. Between those two I think wf also gives us info on Ana
So he’s my choice for now
-->
@ILikePie5
What are the exact justifications yall were provided. Paraphrase to the best of abilities your PM
There really isn’t much to paraphrase. Wheel of Fortune started airing in 1975, it’s about solving word puzzles, successful completion thereof resulting in the spin of a wheel and a random prize. Nothing specific to the three roles on the wheel, just the wheel itself.