I mean I don’t disagree that it would cause a lot of suffering but I disagree about moral culpability.
Culpability is irrelevant to the children involved (most of which are US citizens) as well as the friends and other family of those you would deport.
It's also crazy to me how immigration hardliners pretend these people just picked up and moved here because they had nothing better to do or figured they'd get free stuff or something to that effect. The overwhelming majority of these people came here fleeing violence and extreme poverty, so I get that they didn't do it the right way but the way folks like yourself hold that against them morally is quite insane. The backlog for processing applications is like 10 years, many of these people would be dead by the time they got an answer. It may not be our problem - we can't take in every refuge on earth, but if you're going to act as if you're not engaging in something that is horrible at least from one standpoint you're just divorced from reality.
Being sent back to your country of origin is not a rights violation in any way.
No one is claiming this.
I’m so confused. Finding people where they are including the entire country and work places IS the normal enforcement of laws???
So... What Trump is doing right now is perfectly normal then?
The point of the hypothetical is to see how you’d react if there was the mass illegal immigration of people from a culture YOU disliked. It seems that if that happened you are okay with deporting them you just disagree with some tactics.
Full circle - I've made this clear since the start of this thread. I never expressed or implied that I had any principal issue with deporting anyone here illegally. What I have always taken issue with is the prioritization of this as our national issue. It's not that your arguments are wrong, I just don't believe the reality is anywhere near what folks like yourself claim and to the extent any of them are right they are offset by so many things that should give serious pause to bany rational and decent person.
Fix our absurd asylum laws including more judges to process these claims and remove those with no justification, plug the border with more agents and better technology to stop illegal aliens and drugs from entering, deport anyone who commits crimes or lands on our radars for any legitimate reason, and move on.
For the farm workers, nannies, carpenters, etc. who are here working and contributing, leave them alone. We have better things to worry about.