Feminist Mafia Day 3

Btw I hope you know this is all POe based, you played a fine scum game  if it’s not ultra but yeah POE solves it here

Hammer Casey before you crash. We just solved the game. And if not you just got a free scum win but oh well

Hammer Casey game is solved. If she’s innocent then I hammer you next dp and town win no matter what

I would say Casey played an excellent scum game if true the only thing giving me pause here is that POE is the only reason to suspect her. 

It's one of those things though. When I used to obsess over pool playing it would piss me off if somebody told me I played well after losing. Like it's not my goal to fucking play well. I want to win. 

My shift is almost over. I've got a bit to say, just wait a bit for me to get home.

I don’t see how this isn’t a game solve unless you think the scum is exactly Vader.

I will be up for another hour or so I can wait but reluctantly so since I want the flip tonight and my delayed vote could ruin that

If it saves you time don't respond to my other post. It is meaningless. All we should be talking about is the game solve and why you would be opposed to it for any reason. 

Fair enough. Put simply, I agree that Vader is almost definitely town based on his role, and sure, the town could just auto-win by going along with your plan. Normally I wouldn't even be opposed to that, but in this situation, I feel like the mafia should at least be given a chance. I don't think what happened to Whiteflame was at all fair. This game should be focused on actual social deduction - looking for signs that people are lying, analyzing their interactions with others, etc. Focusing on out-of-game information like Mikal did is just a cheap way to win imo. It's also why I'm opposed to massclaiming. It's barely better than having everyone copy-paste their role PMs in my eyes.

If the majority agrees that I'm scum based on actual behavioral reasons, then fair enough. But just lynching me to get the guaranteed win by the end of DP4 doesn't feel right to me. I just think the mafia should be given a chance, y'know? 

lmao thats basically a confession.

I'm not confessing; I am town. I'm not saying, 'please don't lynch me at all', I'm just saying, 'lynch the person who you actually think has the strongest behavioral case against them instead of just going for the algorithmic solve'.

Okay that was the shittirst speech ever. I don't think Mikal is wrong for using his brain. You can't just shut off your brain and he came across outside information. He probably should have kept it to himself and not explained the read. I would like if I didn't say I have also found myself in the same situation before and when I have I usually just refuse to explain my read. That said he did nothing wrong by noticing. 

From the last post it seems earth is comfortable with this lynch so......

Well, it was worth a shot, anyway. Though I still stand by what I said tbh. I'm obviously not convincing you to change your vote however, and I seriously doubt I can get both Vader and Ultra to vote for Luna at this point, so I'm not going to prolong this any further.

I prefer to use behavior as well but if it can be solved mechanically then we might as well. 

Technically the scum team should win more often than town and I will explain that later but I think the mods try to do a 50/50 split here.

That should be the end of the dp

You can argue that Mikal was a dick for considering off site activity for the basis of his scum read, and I would agree, but it wasn't like Mikal was totally lost on scum reads, he scum read WF with or without Discord shenanigans. Even if Mikal suffered a heart attack and died when the DP opened, I would probably lynch WF regardless since his claim was weak.

Plz lock