Because saying you are a crafting station heavily implies you craft items and there is no way scum does not see that as a power role. So I can’t wrap my head around why just say it yolo when it makes you a target if you are town
You literally modded a game where I “scumslipped” and was town. This is genuinely pushing an agenda.
You are going to hate me for this but that makes you sus you even more. Loom is early game and yea it uses silk but that justification is almost right off the wiki and mine is much more simplistic and not near as much info it it and has a custom justification.
The Loom is a crafting station used to craft Silk, as well as some items that require Silk as an ingredient. It can sometimes be found in Underground Cabins.
I am the loom, a crafting station that can be crafter or found in underground cabins that crafts apparel primarily using silk that strengthens your character. Thus I am the strengthener and can choose a player each night to guarantee the effect of their night action.
Can you guys clarify the parent/category aspect of
Your roles.
Did any of you guys go by a different name on DDO
Not so much for the existence of a loom in game (again, I don't know enough about Terraria to speak on that), but on the Strengthener claim, specifically. Since similarity to the Wiki has been mentioned, I'll say straight up that there's not a lot on the Wiki about my character, so there's not much to copy. The details of my justification aren't obvious from reading it, so Mikal may be onto something there.
Thoughts on Vaders 226 and 229?
Going to redo this because I got a mod clarification. I have no identifier and appearantly I read this wrong. So my item does not have a category period. In the pm it was looked like 2 words when it really should’ve been 1. So no I have 0 sub category
That would be a confusing choice to make at this point. Maybe the aim was to avoid giving a character claim with a tier in it now that that's been flagged as potentially scummy, but he could have waited and seen if other people posted their own claims first and then tried to backtrack if no one had a tier. It could be a scum slip, but it's weird that he went about it this way and I can't say it reads as scummy to me.
Wow you too huh? This might be the first time I’ve been mislynched in longer than I can remember, not to mention it’s day phase 1. And not a shred of a case against me is based on behavior either. This is pretty unfortunate.
I think he originally planned to claim one thing and had to change his claim for some reason or another. I don’t buy that he just didn’t read his role pm correctly to see one word vs two. Makes no sense. And he literally lied about it in the next post and said he was reading it from the wiki. Why would he need to reference the wiki at all rather than his own role PM to begin with?
Normally I would 100% agree and back tracking would be 100% scummy. But please reference my original response where I claimed it did not have a category. I was clarifying simply that mine is a sole item rather than a category
axe which covers a broad category
Or if you are a type of axe
He meant like 'iron axe' vs. 'axe'
Or 'golden apple' vs. 'apple'
Do you have any reads that stick out for you at the moment?
...so I point out that the Strengthener seems a little sus (something that most anyone in here would say given that it's been used as a pretty safe fake claim in past games) and point to a disjoint between how your and my justification relates to the Wiki, and all I get is a "you too huh?" response? I've already said your behavior is NAI, I'm working with what I have that indicates something to me. For that matter, I haven't even voted for you, and I've said that several of the factors Mikal was considering don't seem to hold up. I get that you're frustrated, but the notion that there isn't a case against you at all just because few of us are scumreading you behaviorally doesn't hold up.
I'd be fine pursuing him for a character claim to see what this is all about. My impression from his responses was that it was listed as two words in his PM when it should have been one on the basis of how the Wiki portrays it. That may or may not be plausible based on his claim, but I don't think he lied about it. As for why he'd reference the Wiki at all, that's probably for the same reason I did: to get more insight into his character. I'd be surprised if he hadn't looked it up at all up to this point.
