Rather, I think the correct move would be for town to use as many protective type roles as possible. If mafia gets two kills and two mis-lynches they win. I'd hope to see doctors and bulletproofs tonight.
What do you think about the set up? Whats the best actions to use?
Mafia can still get mislynches,This sounds like a good idea, but it might be considered gamebreaking if everyone is protected, because then the mafia would be unable to win.
I don't know. What do you think about a combination of cops and doctors?
Well that too. I would suggest people get creative with their roles, tracker, watcher results are probably more useful investigative roles if we don't mislynch today.I just realized that cops might be useless. Since the nightmare can also use a dream ability, he would just make himself a godfather every time.
Depends on if we get a mislynch today. If we mis-lynch we get an automatic LYLO the following phase, in which I am dis-inclined to believe any results. Might be worth considering a no lynch today unless there is really scummy behavior we just can't ignore.
Well that too. I would suggest people get creative with their roles, tracker, watcher results are probably more useful investigative roles if we don't mislynch today.
That sounds like a good idea. However, are there any roles the nightmare could choose to avoid all night actions? I've read the mafia rules and possible roles, but I can't remember off the top of my head.
Also, do you think we should do purely investigation with watchers and trackers, or try some protection with doctors as well?
If this were a conventional game I would say we should drag it out, but what real info are we going to get now? Also this is just a quickfire to fill time while warren gets his game up. I am okay with going to the night phase now, maybe we can get some useful information from people's night actions tonight.Should we vote for no lynch now, or wait in hopes of getting more info?
--> @Lunatic, @SupaDudz, @WaterPhoenix, @SirAnonymousSee above
Not that I know of but this isn't a conventional game. Sounds like mafia can make up whatever and see what the mod allows. There's a role called "Ninja" that makes it so mafia won't show up on tracker or watcher reports though. I imagine they would have to choose between that or godfather, not sure mod will allow both. But I have never seen a game like this.
Well now that I think about it... What's to stop mafia from using strong man ability? Strongman pierces through protective roles. Hmm...
Okay guys post your roles now
Agreed. VTNLIf this were a conventional game I would say we should drag it out, but what real info are we going to get now? Also this is just a quickfire to fill time while warren gets his game up. I am okay with going to the night phase now, maybe we can get some useful information from people's night actions tonight.
That depends entirely on his willingness to gamble. If he decides that cops, watchers, and trackers will likely target others and not him, he might try it. On the other hand, if he's conservative, he will protect himself rather than ensure a kill. If he does try to kill someone without being a strongman and that someone is protected, would we be told about it, and, if so, how much would we be told?
Were you asking what roles each of us would take tonight?
