-->
@fauxlaw
I didn't ask you "does socialism work?". I asked you "how does socialism result in hive-mind collectivism".
Either I'm misunderstanding you or you're not answering my question. Open to either.
The bit about ALL members of society... collectively.
Why shouldn't people just be taught to know their own worth and negotiate themselves? Socialism does not even allow such an individual act.
Socialism would never, ever do that. They want to keep people thinking the same. A hive mentality.
Haven't I said that enough?
But socialism does not care about individual success.
Obama, a socialist,
Artists, intellectuals, under socialism are strangled, unless they express the party line. Russia once had a brilliant cultural, artistic stamp of the society of Europe until Lenin and Stalin screwed it all with their "revolution" that crumbled within 70 years. Their artists, writers, intellectuals were tortured unless they played along. It will happen hear if the likes of Bernie, AOC and the Squid get their way. No, soc/com does NOT support individual freedom. That is, to soc/coms, a big joke.
one of the supporting ideas of the GND is an item called "participatory budgeting," by which the government would establish a commission in oversight of private industry to "assist" private industry in organizing their annual budgets. Government participation in private industry budgeting? Really???? What do you think that leads to? It is o longer private industry.
I'm not familiar with the practice of private industry budgeting
So communism is just capitalism with the collective action of all members of society setting capital in motion? lolAnd Marxists didn't believe in setting capital "in motion." they believed in abolishing it.Seems like you're more interested in arguing against socialism than establishing it as a system that advocates for hive-mind collectivism.
Marxists define capital as “a social, economic relation” between people (rather than between people and things). In this sense they seek to abolish capital.
they just use other peoples' money.
No, because hive-mind is soc/com. Look, when you convince society that they should all earn the same, work the same, think the same. and act the same, you have created a hive-mind with no individual earning, working. thinking, acting at all. Soc/com's greatest enemy is the individual who earns/works/thinks/acts by his own wits, his own experience, his own self-generated ambition and accomplishment.
No, and I will not describe it again. If yu don't get by now, it's never going to hit you over the head.
Read through your 6 key points, particularly the 1st [and note that while capitalism has endured in America for 400 years = before America was America], socilaism has neve succeed beyond 70 years. And the 6th, regarding revolution, and the4n read the definition of revolution under key terms, and then tell me why an economic system that begins with revolution [and recall I just said capitalism has thrived in America for 400 years, while our revolution was 156 years following the first settlements, and still thrives] and socialism always has begun and ends by revolution. Oops. Yes, I know what I'm talking about.
631 days later
I think it is beneficial. The entire society is rid of conflict because everyone is in harmony, does anyone oppose to this idea?
Atheists love the idea of everyone being like robots.
--> @ShilaA Zedku for Shila.Hive mind.Head downTap Tap Tap.What mind are you hiving?
--> @Polytheist-WitchAtheists love the idea of everyone being like robots.Unlike some religions who want people to submit and conform to what is perceived to be the word of God.
--> @ShilaPolytheist _Witch: No one cares about your spam posting, atheist