Paranoia Mafia - Day 1

Author: drafterman ,

Topic's posts

Read-only
Posts in total: 546
  • drafterman
    drafterman avatar
    Debates: 6
    Forum posts: 5,659
    3
    6
    9
    drafterman avatar
    drafterman
    (Please note the rules update: Day Phase time frame has been shortened to 48 hours from 72)


    Living Players
      1. Elminster
      2. Speedrace
      3. ILikePie5
      4. Whiteflame
      5. Lunatic
      6. That1User
      7. SupaDudz
      8. Crocodile
      9. Danielle
      10. GreyParrot
      With 10 players, it takes 6 votes to lynch. This DP will end by 9:00 am (Eastern) on 11/26/2020.
    1. drafterman
      drafterman avatar
      Debates: 6
      Forum posts: 5,659
      3
      6
      9
      drafterman avatar
      drafterman
      --> @Elminster @ILikePie5 @Lunatic @Speedrace @whiteflame
      You've been lynched
    2. drafterman
      drafterman avatar
      Debates: 6
      Forum posts: 5,659
      3
      6
      9
      drafterman avatar
      drafterman
      --> @Crocodile @Danielle @Greyparrot @SupaDudz @That1User
      j/k j/k
    3. That1User
      That1User avatar
      Debates: 12
      Forum posts: 587
      2
      3
      4
      That1User avatar
      That1User
      Remember the fallen
    4. Crocodile
      Crocodile avatar
      Debates: 21
      Forum posts: 1,123
      3
      4
      10
      Crocodile avatar
      Crocodile
      second ez
    5. That1User
      That1User avatar
      Debates: 12
      Forum posts: 587
      2
      3
      4
      That1User avatar
      That1User
      --> @Crocodile
      Why are you Croc and not Gator
    6. Crocodile
      Crocodile avatar
      Debates: 21
      Forum posts: 1,123
      3
      4
      10
      Crocodile avatar
      Crocodile
      my old user was gator
    7. Crocodile
      Crocodile avatar
      Debates: 21
      Forum posts: 1,123
      3
      4
      10
      Crocodile avatar
      Crocodile
      but not in alligator it was as in gatorade 
    8. Lunatic
      Lunatic avatar
      Debates: 3
      Forum posts: 5,496
      3
      3
      5
      Lunatic avatar
      Lunatic
      One limited speaking. Ones participation affected. One watching.
    9. SupaDudz
      SupaDudz avatar
      Debates: 30
      Forum posts: 12,459
      5
      8
      11
      SupaDudz avatar
      SupaDudz
      Everything is spinnin. Waaah paranoia
    10. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      I have only played this in person. Do I say what I am?
    11. whiteflame
      whiteflame avatar
      Debates: 18
      Forum posts: 1,207
      3
      4
      10
      whiteflame avatar
      whiteflame
      --> @Elminster
      Generally, unless you think it would be beneficial to publicly claim your role, you should probably refrain from revealing it immediately.
    12. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      --> @whiteflame
      How do you determine when it's beneficial?
    13. Crocodile
      Crocodile avatar
      Debates: 21
      Forum posts: 1,123
      3
      4
      10
      Crocodile avatar
      Crocodile
      --> @Elminster
      don't claim unless pressured

      unless u have miller
    14. Greyparrot
      Greyparrot avatar
      Debates: 2
      Forum posts: 10,176
      3
      3
      8
      Greyparrot avatar
      Greyparrot
      --> @Crocodile
      I'm town mason. Hi!
    15. Crocodile
      Crocodile avatar
      Debates: 21
      Forum posts: 1,123
      3
      4
      10
      Crocodile avatar
      Crocodile
      or unless you're greyparrot
    16. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      --> @Crocodile
      But he just claimed and it wasn't useful?
    17. whiteflame
      whiteflame avatar
      Debates: 18
      Forum posts: 1,207
      3
      4
      10
      whiteflame avatar
      whiteflame
      --> @Elminster
      Depends on the role, though with a few exceptions, it’s usually not a good idea to claim in DP1 unless you have to do so.
    18. That1User
      That1User avatar
      Debates: 12
      Forum posts: 587
      2
      3
      4
      That1User avatar
      That1User
      --> @Elminster
      But he just claimed and it wasn't useful?
      That's Grey's meta, when he's town he claims early
    19. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      --> @whiteflame
      Is mason the exception?
    20. whiteflame
      whiteflame avatar
      Debates: 18
      Forum posts: 1,207
      3
      4
      10
      whiteflame avatar
      whiteflame
      --> @Elminster
      It doesn’t really net anything to claim mason, but that’s Grey’s MO.
    21. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      --> @whiteflame
      Mo?
    22. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      Sorry had to google meta and mo. 

      So you are saying that he is doing something that is suboptimal but we need to excuse it because he's prone to playing in a suboptimal way?
    23. whiteflame
      whiteflame avatar
      Debates: 18
      Forum posts: 1,207
      3
      4
      10
      whiteflame avatar
      whiteflame
      --> @Elminster
      There are all different kinds of ways to play this that are meant to elicit certain responses from the other players. Grey is making a play that suits his style. My impression is that most people wouldn’t do this, but saying that it’s suboptimal play assumes that everyone plays by the same standards. It’s your call to make, but generally, keeping useful information to yourself is a good call early on.

    24. Elminster
      Elminster avatar
      Debates: 0
      Forum posts: 1,180
      2
      3
      5
      Elminster avatar
      Elminster
      --> @whiteflame
      I'm not entirely sure what is suboptimal. I'm just repeating what has been said

      From what you and croc said, ideally you would not claim dp1 unless you are pressured or have a reason to claim. Grey claimed without either. If there is a way that most people play or are expected to play, doing the exact opposite would be suboptimal would it not?

      Is there a reason mafia would ignore his playstyle to the detriment of town?