-->
@Elminster
Role stealer maybe
Paranoia Mafia - Day 2
Posts
Read-only
Total:
596
-->
@Elminster
Also I don't see why it matters if mafia blocked PGO because they would've tried to kill her the same night
-->
@Speedrace
Actually true
-->
@Speedrace
Can't think of why they would just bypass and not kill. Was thinking of to many big brain plays.
So yeah it's either parrot or her very likely then. If they are both town we lose either way.
Does this all boil down to her claiming pgo thinking no one would call the bluff and parrot is parrot lol
-->
@Speedrace
@Elminster
Can't think of why they would just bypass and not kill. Was thinking of to many big brain plays.
If GP is Roleblocker mafia could kill Luna, roleblock Danielle's PGO, then have town lynch Danielle upon Danielle's gun not killing GP
Yeah I'm willing to lynch I think
Shes doubling down on pgo. Saying she lied would have at least salvaged her. No idea why she is doubling down on that. It bothers me. Because it makes no sense.
But would gp literally take a 50/50 trade. Only motivation would be because they can't kill her so this forced a lynch to get pgo out and to sac himself.
I can't shake the timeline thing though. All of that adds up.
Yeah I'm willing to vote her if we decide it as town.
She is likely scum. If she flips town gp had to have pulled a 50/50 trade. Lynch him next np in case I'm dead. If by some fucked up way they are both town, this is already over.
-->
@That1User
I don't think rb stops pgo
-->
@That1User
And re what supa said. There is no reason they would just block a role and not kill her. There would be 0 reason
Or GP is secretly drunk and roleblocked Danielle's PGO bc reason, town screwing town
-->
@Vader
Please for the love of God. Thank about how to confirm your role. It's very obvious
You will be alive
Do we just want to pull the trigger. Now that she said she is pgo. Not sure what point there is to wait. I was expecting to hear miller and some reason as to why she lied. Her saying pgo makes this go to a pretty linear path
Mafia really can't kill me since I'm under suspicion but if I die, it is DEFINITELY Whiteflame
-->
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
@Speedrace
Verdict
-->
@Elminster
Do we just want to pull the trigger. Now that she said she is pgo. Not sure what point there is to wait. I was expecting to hear miller and some reason as to why she lied. Her saying pgo makes this go to a pretty linear path
+1
Would like to get Whiteflame's claim before the DP ends if possible though
-->
@Speedrace
Unless I'm missing something it goes her and then gp if by some miracle she's inno
-->
@Elminster
Unless I'm missing something it goes her and then gp if by some miracle she's inno
Yep
-->
@Speedrace
I don't
-->
@Elminster
I know you don't -_-
-->
@Speedrace
Almost everything is out. Waiting doesn't change his claim even if he's faking it. What point is there to force a claim and that won't change as either town or mafia
-->
@Elminster
What if Pie is a popular TP
-->
@Speedrace
This honestly scares the fuck out of me. Except I'm thinking mafia vs to. He was really rushing danielle before she could talk. There is a easy way to figure that out though
Depending on Danielle's flip it will say a bit. If guilty mafia will have a hard time because it confirms a load of stuff
I keep trying to figure out a way she's town and I keep coming back to the fact that one of her and gp gas to be lying.
-->
@Elminster
This honestly scares the fuck out of me. Except I'm thinking mafia vs to. He was really rushing danielle before she could talk. There is a easy way to figure that out though
His behavior reads not scum to me heavily
-->
@Speedrace
I was unsure until he said "I'm taking a break"
That pegged me as towny because he felt invested in the game
-->
@Elminster
Well with the extension, do you wanna do some banter about why Danielle wants to go 1 for 1 with me by not explaining about why she lied about PGO?
I am absolutely town and I passed the potato to Danielle. We can talk about it for a while, but it's likely her scum mate is going to end up bussing her at some point.
Honestly, I was expecting a reason for why she lied about PGO, not this.
Unless there is a valid reason why I didn't die from giving her the hot potato, and I don't think any town is going to step up at this point, I guess we can just go ahead and Lynch Dani and then lynch me as a 1 for 1.
The real question I had not thought of is what happens to the potato if Dani dies? I have to go back and re read the role.
-->
@Elminster
Pie could have been bussing.
-->
@Greyparrot
I can't see why she would double down on pgo either and I can't see you as scum taking a random 1v1 trade.
Unless this is the greatest bus that I can recall
-->
@Greyparrot
Tbf you could be bussing
-->
@Greyparrot
Actually sad I checked those time stamps because it's going to affect my read on you all game now. I can't shake that regardless