Inverse Reality Day Phase 1

I said i don’t know the thematical split. The theme is inverse reality right? My character does some shitty things but Lunatic justifies it in a perverted way. That’s the theme but scum could have the same stuff

but that's not inverted.  Inverse reality would be scum=protagonists, no?

I think Town are antagonists that are actually good, or at least had a point.

Therefore scum would be protagonists that were actually bad or wrong.

Please tell us any and all experience you’ve had with playing mafia whether online or in person

I just got here lol. I’m in for policy lynching millers if we don’t have an alternative target

I have obviously had no experience whatsoever.  

Explain your theory on why millers should be policy lynched, in sufficient detail.

I knew it as soon as soon as I saw Supa's post.  So did everybody else except Pie, apparently.

Therefore, Pie is scum

VTL ILikePie5

If you know the thematic split then who’s scum lol. I know what the fuckin theme is lol

--> @drafterman

I think Town are antagonists that are actually good, or at least had a point.

Therefore scum would be protagonists that were actually bad or wrong.

Nope, I don't fit this

It's literally just bad v good lol

Well, it sounds like we've made some headway on figuring out the theme and the potential split. While I won't reveal what it is, I am at least familiar with the show my character is from, even if I'm not familiar with the character. Seems to fit into the theme that's been discussed.

I can't say I'm aware of that, but I'll take you at your word. Not at all familiar with the theme.

Player - [Character] / [Role] (link to post)

1. oromagi
   
2. elminster
   
3. mistercrhis
   
4. supadudz - Neagan / Miller (https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5592/post-links/241170) 
   
5. greyparrot - Smeagol / Hider (https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5592/post-links/241213) 
   
6. drafterman - ("I'm from a movie. If I say the movie it'll be obvious who I am. But I am a "villain") / ? (https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5592/post-links/241242)
   
7. coal
   
8. speedrace
   
9. whiteflame - ("My character is from Game of Thrones") / ? (https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5592-inverse-reality-day-phase-1?page=2) 
   
10. warren42
    
11. ilikepie5 - Magneto / ? (https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5592/post-links/241345) 
    

Let me know if I've missed anything.  I don't think I did, but I'm kind of tired and I've been working all day. 

Before I do anything, I have a couple of questions:  

@elminster - Who are you on DDO?  Have I played live mafia with you?  Who are you? 

@all - wasn't pie the one who VTL'd the confirmed townie as town in a life mafia game recently?  I feel like that was him.  

I also have a couple of observations:

We are not lynching an un-counterclaimed miller DP1; now, tomorrow or ever.  

Grayparrot is likely town. 

Supa is town. 

I would like everyone's thoughts on elminster.  I am particurlarly interested in what whiteflame, drafter, speed and warren think of elminster. 

It’s a pretty safe claim for a scum to make. I don’t want a Miller at MYLO or LYLO with me. But like I said if we have have a better target that should take precedence.

Well, it sounds like we've made some headway on figuring out the theme and the potential split. While I won't reveal what it is, I am at least familiar with the show my character is from, even if I'm not familiar with the character. Seems to fit into the theme that's been discussed.