-->
@Speedrace
What? They're PGO...?
who PGO? Did I miss that?
BHM Mafia - Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
172
-->
@Speedrace
I did miss that. Well you don't have to visit him, right? You just have to name him.
-->
@oromagi
I asked Dani, PM phrasing seems to mean that I don't visit
-->
@Speedrace
I asked her in the DP if it is a visit so we should get an answer publicly soon as well. Also why am I the only one suspect of chris?
-->
@Bringerofrain
I asked her in the DP if it is a visit so we should get an answer publicly soon as well.
She won't answer public questions
Also why am I the only one suspect of chris?
Why do you suspect him
-->
@Speedrace
He claimed his role had justification. He seems like the only person who is saying that, and then he seemed to change his story later hinting that it was a trap which also would be problematic because he wouldn't have enough information about role justifications prior to everyone discussing them anyway.
I am close to 100% certain Chris is scum.
We won't get a lynch tonight. Perhaps next DP I will hunt down the incriminating posts.
Post 59 chris insinuates he has justification
Post 102 he changes his story. Pretending it was a trap. I have no justification explicit or not.
Sorry, I just don't buy Chris's story
Vote Count
Bringerofrain (oromagi) -- 1/5 votes
Crocodile (Pie) -- 1/5 votes
SupaDudz (Speed) -- 1/5 votes
MisterChris (Bringer) -- 1/5 votes
Not voting: Supa, Chris, Crocodile, whiteflame
About ~2 hours left in the day phase.
Supa's inactivity has been going on for the past 2 weeks... I'm not super surprised he's dead this game.
-->
@Vader
1) We should not overlook Speed's claim. The activity in this game is LOW and his claim could slip by us if it is not pressured. We should not town read him at all because he claimed. However, I do think Danielle could have a role like this for town, but I still will not excuse Speed
Yes, Speed's claim is the scummiest thing we have to go on so far, but if he can be confirmed I see no harm in keeping him alive for one DP.
-->
@Vader
Now I am going to watch Attack on Titan S4 EP11 and then poop
How was the poop?
-->
@Bringerofrain
He claimed his role had justification. He seems like the only person who is saying that,
But I never claimed I had a justification. At least not an explicit one. It wasn't hard to connect the dots lol.
and then he seemed to change his story later hinting that it was a trap which also would be problematic because he wouldn't have enough information about role justifications prior to everyone discussing them anyway.
You're acting like this was some sort of super big brained strat... Not really. This is done pretty often in mafia dude.
I knew I didn't have a "because ___, you are ___" statement and was town, & I knew Speed didn't have one either. That's pretty obvious evidence that town wasn't required to have a justification this game. What we didn't know is if all of town didn't have justifications or if it was just a few, so asking everyone made sense to establish a pattern & find any inconsistent stories (i.e. scum).
-->
@MisterChris
Which is why I'm keeping him alive. Again, I do think Danielle would add a role like this in her mafia games. But at the same time for me, is his role really affiliation verified. I actually remember in live mafia Mikal claiming this role and him ending up being scum
-->
@MisterChris
8/10
-->
@oromagi
Recall, Mikal claimed Speed's exact role in a live mafia game and turned scum. His role is not affiliation verified
-->
@Vader
yeah. Let's just wait to see what goes down. Having used lawyer as a mafia role myself it's definitely sus.
Bringer makes an interesting post. #59 and #102 is the classic "I was pulling a gambit to see." In a game where justifications aren't present, you would look at your PM and then someone else claiming no justification and then make an attempt to say you have one? The logic doesn't add up
The Day Phase Has Ended - No Lynch
No more talking or posting in this thread.
The night phase will end in 24 hours.
Any night action not submitted within that time will be forfeited.
<<>><<>><<>><<>><<>><<>><<>>
Vote Count
Bringerofrain (oromagi) -- 1/5 votes
Crocodile (Pie) -- 1/5 votes
SupaDudz (Speed) -- 1/5 votes
MisterChris (Bringer) -- 1/5 votes
Not voting: Supa, Chris, Crocodile, whiteflame