Fairy Tail Mafia DP1

We just need to put 6 votes on him. If he gets lynched and the DP ends he was scum. If it doesn’t then he’s role locked. 

I'm a day cop with a guilty on Earth. Supa just reported this info to me.

You know a guy named Wylted?

I am so sorry, I just understood his power. I thought his power was he had a vote that had double power as a 1x thing and it goes away if he's lynched (which implied to me there's a governor-type role that can stop a lynch otherwise how could he lose the power?)

Anyway, I now understand better what his power is, I agree to the confirming lynch.

Now that I understand Chris' power I actually harder townread him than before, that role is unbelievably unfair to give to scum, because in an endgame lylo it's autowin for scum.

I countercliam fourttrouble, I am a normal night-based cop. 

I counterclaim fourtrouble 100%

But not your role PM?

🤦‍♂️

I character claims Doranbalt

Supadudz used that even though that's the character's alias, that is who I was given as my character claim.

Post 185 is not a cc.

Doranbalt used magic powers to investigate the council and ended up helping, those are the overall reasons/reason I was given for him being the cop.

there would not be 2 cops in the same non-bastard setup of this size of just 10 players.

claim your character now fast

We lock his role in place and cover our flanks. Better safe than sorry. If he’s lying he dies. If he’s not lying then he gets role locked and we can move on. We also can walk and chew gum at the same time

Pie, his role is already locked. No need to test. This isn't something that scum lie about.

Pie's paranoia seems townish enough. Let's lynch Earth.

WE LYNCH FOURTROUBLE RIGHT NOW HE DIDN'T CHARACTER CLAIM!

tomorrow lynch coal and we win

Well this is going to complicate. 

I ONLY WILL HESITATE IF YOU AGREE FOURTROUBLE IS JESTER-TELLING!!!

then I will lynch coal instead no problem

Post 183. Pie believes I'm fake claiming. Potential evidence of informed perspective about Earth's alignment.

Claim your character 

Post 185. Believes I'm lying. Evidence of uninformed perspective (if Earth is scum) informed perspective (if Earth is town).

My character is Erza or something like that.

Response to Pie: what if scum have a role that allows them to negate MC's role? What if there's a hammerer who hasn't spoken (or isn't allowed to)? There's many possible reasons not to test MC's claim, from a purely theoretical pov. Being overly cautious (your approach) would recommend against putting likely townies at L-1 just so that we can test something that doesn't help us solve the game in at all, but certainly presents numerous risks.

Regarding FT, the fact that he’s claiming Erza means he’s most likely town. In this series, she’s one of the main 4 characters. She’d be a very risky fake claim to give this early. She’s almost definitely not the day cop (...seriously RM? I wasn’t buying that before the character claim), though I can think of a few fitting roles for her.

RM has me on edge. On the one hand, he claimed cop, which would be a ballsy fake claim for scum. On the other hand, his character claim stands out. Erza Scarlet and Mirajane Strauss are both the actual names of their characters. Doranbolt is an alias for a character actually named Mest Gryder. He’s not one of the more central characters of the guild, either, though he does do some important stuff. It doesn’t help that he’s the only claim that flies in the face of my interpretation of that first hint. I’m reticent in general about lynching in DP1, much less for a claimed cop, but so much about this claim seems fishy.

I’m not convinced that anyone else merits much attention so far. Pie’s behavior seems in line with his usual (if anything, I think he’d play tighter than this if he was scum), and I don’t buy Oro as scum based on anything he’s done (he’s normally rather neutral about the majority of us this early). Too little from Earth, nothing from Speed (likely at a debate tournament) or Luna (likely at work). Still trying to read Coal (usually have trouble there), already said I town read MC.

Why wouldn't he check his PM and how is ezra a day cop? Why did it take him so long to claim.the character? Why would a day cop want mass claim D1? Why isn't he lynching me?