I read the debate and i wanted to clarify some things that Pro seems to have not mentioned the historical info that Pro used do not come from the Quran they are narrations of what people who lived at that time saw and said including the Aisha herself and these narrations are the same source from which we know that this marriage happened and at what ages it occurred so doubting it's reliability makes the whole debate meaningless . so now about the marriage itself in Islam the conditions for a sexual relationship within a marriage being permissible is that both spouses are physically and mentally capable of doing it and that it happening causes no harm to either of them now from your point of view these are conditions made up by the prophet himself so why would he invent conditions that he intends to break which means that these conditions were met in that marriage unless you could provide any proof that they were not other than saying that 9 year olds at this current age arent capable of handling it because that makes no sense people at that time lived under extremely different conditions so it makes sense that they would mature at different rates than modern 9 year olds
yeah lol you misunderstood me at first
I read the debate and i wanted to clarify some things that Pro seems to have not mentioned the historical info that Pro used do not come from the Quran they are narrations of what people who lived at that time saw and said including the Aisha herself and these narrations are the same source from which we know that this marriage happened and at what ages it occurred so doubting it's reliability makes the whole debate meaningless . so now about the marriage itself in Islam the conditions for a sexual relationship within a marriage being permissible is that both spouses are physically and mentally capable of doing it and that it happening causes no harm to either of them now from your point of view these are conditions made up by the prophet himself so why would he invent conditions that he intends to break which means that these conditions were met in that marriage unless you could provide any proof that they were not other than saying that 9 year olds at this current age arent capable of handling it because that makes no sense people at that time lived under extremely different conditions so it makes sense that they would mature at different rates than modern 9 year olds