thett3's avatar

thett3

A member since

3
2
7

Total posts: 2,178

Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
Sure let's do your math: approximately if you assign white people 87% of homicide (and this is being generous to you), then they caused 18,000 deaths. If you notice all of your leading deaths deal in the range of hundreds of thousands - 18,000 is not significant enough in order to actually affect any of these numbers.
I can’t tell if you simply don’t understand numbers at all or are intentionally being dishonest. We HAVE the numbers on who  perpetrated the ~20,000 reported homicides in 2019. ~50% of the perpetrators were black. White perpetrators were not 87%. This is a fact. Now, you are alleging that whites (literally) get away with murder to the point that the black portion of perps should be lower than their 13% of the population. The necessitates that there are many more murders than the official number and that most go unreported.

Furthermore, I never claimed that the rates of homicides were proportional to their population statistics, I am merely stating that they are generally overly represented.

White people are not over represented in violent crime. This is a fact. You are slandering an entire race of people for no reason, with no evidence whatsoever. Be self loathing all you want but leave me and my family the hell out of it 

I don't debate here anymore, you know that. Furthermore, you're actual reading of sources are so intellectually dishonest I'm not sure I would want to debate you if I did.
Ever noticed how every single one of your interactions on this site are negative? It’s because you treat people with an extreme disrespect, for no reason. A few weeks ago I sent you a PM asking if you wanted to pick our immigration debate, which I magnanimously decided to ask people to leave as a tie after you forfeited, back up after you had more free time and you enthusiastically told me that I would be your “debut” 

Here’s an idea…if you’re so great with sources how about you find a source showing that there are millions of violent crimes committed by whites people going unreported. Go ahead 
Created:
1
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
In about two weeks I’ll be out of the country until mid September, so I won’t be available for a debate until then but when I get back let’s debate the subject. Resolved: In the United States, White Americans have a violent crime rate higher than African Americans. You as Pro, me as Con 
Created:
1
Posted in:
Homosexuality
I simply cannot imagine hating a group of people so much that I would falsely accuse them of millions of acts of violence a year, and do it so casually. And I definitely can't imagine doing this to the group I'm a part of...white liberals make no sense to me
Created:
0
Posted in:
Hall of Fame III - Tiebreaker Runoff
-->
@Vader
can you link the debates/threads ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Greyparrot
It goes a long way to explain why bastions of power persist for decades and generations uncontested and with zero outrage in dystopias like California, Chicago, Detroit, Baltimore, DC, New York.
California in particular is just wild. Large parts of California allow people to steal, defecate publicly, openly do drugs...I really hope Newsom gets recalled, or that it is at least close. I have some optimism that the Dem coalition is on the verge of collapses because minorities hate the violence and social dysfunction that a lot of white libs enable
Created:
1
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
Eh.. those statistics are definitely being interpreted incorrectly on your part first of all
In what way am I misinterpreting? 

 Definitely, a lot of crime done by white dudes specifically is let go. And... the bodies? The increasing rate of missing cases reports isn't coming up at all to you is it?
And you have proof, of course? Black people commit around 50% of homicides, officially. There were around 20,000 homicides in 2020, officially, meaning that black perpetrators were responsible for about 10,000 of them. Lets do the math. If, as you allege, the official statistics are wrong and black people actually commit 13% of homicides, in line with their portion of the population that means there are actually 76,923 homicides in the USA (10,000/.13), of which 56,000 go unreported. If white people are more violent than black people, meaning that black people would actually be less than 13% of the total, the number would be even higher. That would make death by white guy the police don't bother to arrest in the top 10 causes of death in the United States: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm Where are the bodies?

Not to mention hundreds of thousands if not millions of assaults/muggings/robberies etc you allege are going unreported in rich suburban neighborhoods that people pay hundreds of thousands of dollars to live in. And your evidence for all of this is non existent. 

And because hispanic people weren't afforded nearly the same amount of discrimination that black people were - in the education, work, and healthcare bits, totally - but socially? They weren't slaves for hundreds of years, and there weren't jim crow laws on anywhere near the level of black people. False Equivalence.
This is an explanation for why the higher crime rates exist, not an argument that they do not exist. Again, if police are racist and let white guys off (for murder, lol) why would they let hispanics off, too?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Greyparrot
I still can't believe he projected without skipping a beat that ALL people project.

That's some really deep dysfunction.

This sweeping projection assumes there are zero people alive with nuance or perspective.
Ehh even though he annoyed me in this thread I still think he's a nice guy generally. I don't want to accuse him of more than I think he deserves. If he became dictator tomorrow I don't expect that my life would become significantly worse, can't say the same about far too many people (who unfortunately are concentrated in positions of power)
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
You shouldn’t expect to be that impressed by the answers from your political opponents or else they would cease to be your political opponents. We view the world differently. To me, it’s absolutely shocking that you DONT view the elites as having the amount of malice I think they have amply demonstrated time and time again. But that’s okay. We think differently. But you shouldn’t impugn my motives, and state that I’m the one who wants to hurt people for my own benefit and sadistic pleasure just because I think
many politicians do. That is way over the line. 


Created:
3
Posted in:
America should get rid of political parties
You can formally abolish and ban political parties but it doesn’t keep legislators from acting in a partisan way. Nebraska’s state legislature is nominally non partisan, but everyone knows that republicans hold the majority and they govern as you would expect republicans to.

Political parties exist for a reason: the goal of politicians is to get elected, and political parties craft broad coalitions that make getting elected more likely. 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
It's literally, the entire point of this thread. But ok bro.
Why make the thread asking the question if you don’t actually want answers? You asked why conservatives think what they do on this issue. I gave you an explanation (mostly extreme levels of distrust and disillusionment combined with a reflexive anti authoritarianism) and your response is “wow, projection much?” I mean okay…if you’re trying to get a dunk on someone whatever but that’s not the behavior of someone truly trying to understand the other side 
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
I mean no disrespect
Yeah, you do. You're saying "hmmm, you think politicians are greedy, power hungry sociopaths? Must be projection and YOU'RE the greedy power hungry sociopath!" Very disappointing because we have had productive conversations in the past, but this clearly isn't going to be one. I'm not going to hold it against you, but I'm dipping out.

Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Greyparrot
It takes a person truly partisan to the bone to declare "X" party "really cares about the people"

Stockholm syndrome politics is the rot of America.
I have my problems with supporters of both parties, but one thing I respect about normie Republicans is that they truly despise the Republican Party lol
Created:
1
Posted in:
Hall of Fame III - Voting
Users: 


fauxlaw
whiteflame
misterchris

Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Greyparrot
What the Democrat governors did in 2020 with the kids and the elderly to score political power proves without any reasonable doubt that politicians don't give a flying fuck about "protecting the people"

Offering Cuomo and Newsome up after the fact doesn't come close for restitution for the destruction and mayhem they caused in 2020.
The fact that he went down for frankly dubious sexual assault allegations really bothers me. The dude killed thousands of people!
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
So the entire medical industry is “in on it”. Is that correct?
No. Virtually all medical professionals recommended the vaccine, which is part of why I figured it was safe and effective. Not all medical professionals lied about masks, pressured quasi-state companies into suppressing the lab leak hypothesis, publicly lied about gain of function research, justified black lives matter protests, selectively attacked governors based on partisanship etc. Only the media darlings did. But when these people are the faces pushing the vaccination campaign...well, you can think that instructively distrusting repeated bold face liars is foolish or childish but I don't see it that way at all

Now you might not believe what they are fighting for is best overall for society, or will have the effects they think it will, but to go from that to them not only being unwilling to lift a finger for you but would rather hurt you? Where does that come from? That’s the kind of  thing that only makes sense if it’s something you can relate to personally. I sure can’t.
Don't make an accusation like this of me. "Takes one to know one" was always the dumbest grade school comeback and I'm surprised to see it make an appearance here. I have every right to point out the extreme levels of psychopathy and sadism among American elites without being accused of being a psychopath or a sadist myself. 

You literally stated that you regret getting vaccinated because politicians are pushing people to get vaccinated. If you don’t think basing your own health decisions on a disposition to rebel against politicians “telling you what to do” is childish, I don’t know what to tell you. I base my health decisions on what I believe to be best for me and my family, nothing else.
I literally explained my reasoning, about how the continual loss of liberty is a threat to my person greater than that of the virus, right before the portion you quoted, and you cut it out. You aren't having an honest conversation here
Created:
1
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@coal
I think you know my thoughts on that process, though.  I'm all for colonialism.  One need look no further than the current state of sub-Saharan Africa to understand why
Ultimately I’m an opponent of colonialism but I would agree that situation dependent it’s nowhere near as bad as the average person believes. People really have virtually no conception of what the pre 1945 world was like, either in their own countries or abroad. But the biggest reason colonialism isn’t coming back any time soon is that no developed country has a population surplus clamoring to leave 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@RationalMadman
First of all, this thread is a safe space for us all to expose our kooky beliefs. Second of all, my feelings on the second world war are very complex and I'm clearly doing a piss poor job explaining them, so I'll just assure you that I have no quarrel with Germany
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@coal
I don't know who Biden wanted, if anyone.  But he didn't pick her.  She was picked for him, likely by Pelosi and others in the DNC who are wholly out of touch with reality.  
They must be completely out of touch if they thought she was a remotely compelling candidate lol. Even many liberals hate her
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
How do you not find this to be incredibly childish?
The disease poses no threat to me whatsoever. The continuous loss of liberty as the state-corporate merger presses ever forward is an almost existential threat, and I now feel complicit in it. Power isn't just given up after it's seized. Once they normalize having to show your papers to enter a store, to hold a job, or to travel between states, that isn't gonna go away

If you're referring to my instincts I don't really think a reflexive anti authoritarianism is childish, it's just a disposition like any other.
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
Curious, what about the health experts who overwhelmingly agree with everything the “in group” is  doing? Is the proposition that they are doing what they’re doing to help society also equally absurd?
The "health experts" who bold face lied about the efficacy of masks early on, intentionally suppressed any discussion of the lab leak hypothesis, and justified mass black lives matter protests while telling everyone else to lock down? 

There’sa term for this instinctiveness, it’s called projection.
yea yea "left good right bad" 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@RationalMadman
The territory that we wanted to free from Hitler went to that literal demon, Stalin after the war. There are all kinds of unsavory governments out there, yet we don’t have world wars to stop them. The Second World War was just a continuation of the first, and occurred for the same reason as the first: to prevent German domination of continental Europe. The ideologies involved weren’t particularly relevant. Since Germany came to dominate continental Europe anyway, and Britain lost her empire, the war was pointless in terms of its *actual* purpose 

Please don’t mistake this as a defense of hitler or nazi Germany because it’s not. Im glad both of those things are gone. I’m just deeply cynical about the motIves of the leadership at the time (and now too of course) and really doubt that they actually cared all that much about fascism or the plight of the Jews, or anything like that. We can see how leadership of that era made excuses for the excesses of the Soviet Union so clearly they weren’t above cutting deals with monsters. There were some in the US state department who had ideologically favored communism but for the most part I believe the war was fought for material purposes, greed and power basically 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@RationalMadman
I don’t think anything was worth those wars and I don’t have a problem with Germany. I just mean it’s sad in a cosmic sense that all that bloodshed was basically for nothing 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Race Realism: Critical understandings
-->
@dfss9788
Yes. The claim is usually that black people (or whatever alleged inferior race) are, on average, genetically predisposed to being inferior. Usually the claim has to do with intelligence and/or a predisposition for criminality. Lets accept those alleged facts as true for purposes of discussing the policy implications. Now combine those alleged facts with the undisputed facts - the observed racial disparities and you then have the question - To what extent are the observed racial disparities caused by innate inferiority as opposed to adverse racial discrimination? It would be reasonable to assume that both factors were contributing. Yet, even if there is racial correlation to a predisposition to some innate inferiority, racial discrimination would still (in most cases) be an injustice that should be mitigated through policy.
It seems that you don't actually think race realism is false, but that you believe it's true and are afraid of where the implications might lead. You wish it wasn't true. I also wish it wasn't true, but the facts seem overwhelming to me that there are differences in group abilities. Unless you have an alternative explanation for why West Africans are so incredibly good at sprinting. Why tiny Jamaica does better at this sport than China. I see no reason to assume that adaptation spared the brain. 

"Inferiority" is your descriptor, not mine. My best friend is smarter than I am, by any reasonable metric. But I don't feel "inferior" to him. On that specific facet, I guess. But I'm defined as a person by so much more than just intelligence. Kindness, wisdom, courage, honesty etc. are all virtues besides simply raw intelligence. 

So, what's wrong with racial discrimination in the first place? Lets say that you're a sole proprietor and you desire intelligent workers without criminal propensity. To that end, you implement a racially discriminatory policy, that you will not hire black people. What's wrong with it? It's your business. It's your money. Perhaps you should be able to do what you want with your property, at least that's what the libertarians say. Nonetheless, even supposing it is your right, that does not make it right - And it is still wrong, even assuming the fact that being black is correlated with low intelligence and criminal propensity. And why is it wrong? It's wrong because people are worthy of better treatment than products where we may shop according to brand without any further investigation. With power comes responsibility, and it's wrong because it's an unnecessary unfairness that can be easily avoided by minimal inquiry on the employer's part in to the prospective employee's background. For example, filtering out the stupid and criminally inclined may be done simply by adequately interviewing prospective employees and conducting criminal background checks, etc.
On the contrary, it is the status quo that makes discrimination economically rational. There are those studies about how resumes with "black sounding" names get less call backs than "white sounding names." I've long thought this had more to do with class than race (and there is good evidence to suggest that) but someone pointed out to me the other day that this discrimination actually makes sense in light of affirmative action policies. The odds are that a black guy and an asian guy with Harvard on their resume are not the same. The asian man almost certainly had to work significantly harder to get where he is, and possesses more intelligence and skill. While black people get a 230 point bonus to their SAT scores (more than a standard deviation!) asian people are penalized: https://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-adv-asian-race-tutoring-20150222-story.html

In a world where the elites accept race realism and understand that elite universities can be expected to have an overrepresentation of asian people and an underrpresentation of black people, everyone would also know that the black people who made it there got there through merit. This doesn't stop at elite universities btw but continues down the university chain and well into career paths. 

In any case, the point I'm trying to get across is that public policy should favor fairness, which would generally be against racial discrimination despite the fact that there may be some innate inferiority that is correlated with race.
Let's talk about what's unfair. As a white person, I think it's unfair that my group is constantly blamed for holding black people down. If there is a disparity between white and black people on any metric, it's our fault for being racist and implementing racist policies. I think it's unfair that if you search "white people" or "white men" on any social media website all you get is a slew of racism. 

Yet deep down, almost everyone knows that some degree of racial realism is true. The cognitive dissonance is quite literally tearing this country apart. I don't think public figures talking about race realism is ever going to be a good idea, it's the type of knowledge that does have the potential to be truly toxic. But for God's sake, shut up about race and stop attributing all differences to racism.

I don't think most racial discrimination is even like that. It comes across more as some in-group favoritism thing to me rather than a racial hatred thing. Blacks especially are seen as different. Perhaps it is because they look the most different, and perhaps it is because the American population is bombarded with media indicating that blacks are a different and unique people, separate from the rest of the population. It's unfortunate that so much of that media was made with good intentions. Perhaps if the media presented blacks like Geordi La Forge rather than Will Smith there would be substantially less racial discrimination.
This is the inevitable consequence of living in a multi cultural/multi racial society. Empirically everyone (except for mentally ill white white liberals) has an in-group preference. At some point you have to play the cards you're dealt and acknowledge human nature for what it is. I don't understand what's so hard about that. There are always going to be stereotypes, true and false, positive and negative, and it is completely impossible to divorce yourself from this, but it’s important to treat everyone in your life as individual human beings. 

I am notoriously stupid about celebrities so maybe there is some context I'm missing but I don't see the problem with Will Smith? He seems clean cut, handsome, intelligent, etc. 
Created:
4
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@coal
She really is remarkably bad. I was shocked Biden chose her, especially given his age she is the heir apparent and is just a bottom tier politician 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@coal
If Biden and Trump don’t run I think he’s a slam dunk to be the next President. I think he could beat Biden but it would be a closer thing than against Harris, who would get thrashed. Even Trump would probably beat Harris 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@coal
Covid has really been a mask off moment. I hate living in interesting times lol 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
-->
@TheMorningsStar
This is barely even a conspiracy yea. I mean the people involved aren’t thinking in terms of a “4th reich” but Germany is definitely the dominant political power in the EU and this was almost a certainty from the very beginning. Extremely sad that all those men who on both sides who died in the World Wars, which were just attempts to prevent the German domination of continental Europe, died for literally nothing
Created:
0
Posted in:
Race Realism: Critical understandings
-->
@dfss9788
 Even if it is true, the policy implications are negligible and the factual inquiry is therefore moot.
are the policy implications negligible? How many tens of billions of dollars have been spent trying to bring about equity in the United States when if race realism is true, this simply isn’t possible? The social implications are greater still. Right now any racial inequality is assumed to be the result of racism. If race realism is true, we know that at least some of it is not due to racism.

I get why it is an extremely uncomfortable topic to talk about and I would also prefer to sweep it under the rug. But if we must have a “conversation about race” that requires a discussion of all of the facts. 
Created:
5
Posted in:
Race Realism: Critical understandings
-->
@Mesmer
I’ve never seen a convincing argument against race realism, because there isn’t one. I would like someone who denies any significant differences between human populations to explain, for example, why 79 of the last 80 100 meter dash finalists at the last ten Olympics were of African ancestry 
Created:
3
Posted in:
Conspiracy Theories you believe
Bump. Anyone have anything else interesting?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
I find this to be such a breathtaking violation of Occam’s razor. Why is it easier to assume such a large swath of our government is doing what they’re doing for sadistic purposes rather than cause they believe it will help protect people?
Like I said, we just disagree. Given the absolutely despicable and disgusting behavior that is endemic among American elites I find the proposition that they are doing what they do to help their political outgroups and enemies to be the breathtaking violation of Occam's razor. Now their behavior isn't 100% based in malice, elites do tend to implement policies that reward their in-groups (mainly other elites, but also enough to placate the masses that allow them to take/remain in power) and they don't make all of their decisions based on what hurts the outgroup. But they don't care if the outgroup is hurt either. And people of all stirpes often take a sadistic pleasure in hurting those they consider to be enemies, but sanctimonious elites most of all.

The idea that someone like Chuck Schumer would even lift a pinky finger to help someone like me is completely laughable--far more likely, someone like that would go out of their way to hurt someone like me. Pretty much everyone on the right recognizes this instinctively, which is why you see the behavior you do regarding stuff like masks and vaccinations. That and the fact that a lot of us have some reflexive anti authoritarian impulses (most white republicans are descended from the most disagreeable people in Europe after all.) For example, at this point the pressure campaign has been so heavy handed and oppressive that I actually regret getting vaccinated lol. My attitude is always "f*ck you" when ordered around lol,  definitely not alone in that either
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
That’s not relevant to my point. There will always be sick people out there who fit any description one can make up, it’s dishonest to base our entire political discourse around those extremes, which is kind of the point of this thread. The control for the sake of control narrative might have some truth on a very small scale, it’s stupid as a basis for opposing any mainstream position or action taken by the government.
I guess we just disagree, because I don't think the type of people describe are extremes at all but instead represent the median politician, fortune 500 executive, or law firm partner. There is an extremely high degree of sadism and psychopathy among American elites, you can see that simply by how they treat and talk about the people they rule, and their actions. How many people in public life were associated with Epstein, for example? An instinctive distrust of the system is in fact the most rational worldview an American citizen can have. 
Created:
2
Posted in:
you can't name one good reason not to get vaccinated
-->
@n8nrgmi
needle hurty
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Greyparrot
I actually meant to edit my post to add that when I thought of it but it was too late. Masking children is ridiculous/evil. Certainly seems like the type of thing people drunk on their own power and self righteousness would do

The CDC's statement about children not being a significant vector for the virus is routinely flagged as misinformation from state controlled media.
Remember when they were banning people for talking about the virus coming from a lab, something we now know is at least plausible? If we don't get social media companies under control we are so screwed. It's why I'm supporting Ron DeSantis over Trump if they both run...he has a record of standing up to big tech AND Covid hysteria, and if we want to make changes we need congress which would likely go the other way even if Trump scraped a narrow win. Trump becoming President again would literally be the funniest thing to ever happen though, so he definitely has that going for him
Created:
1
Posted in:
Government wants to control your life?
-->
@Double_R
And BTW, people are often too stupid to make their own decisions. That’s just a fact.
You answered half of your own question. There absolutely are people who seek power over others. I don't know if they are more concentrated in the political left or the right (probably the left right now just because it seems to have the upper hand). If you're lucky, they are trying to exercise power over you for your own good--if you're unlucky, yes, there 1000% are people who get sick pleasure out of exercising power over others just because they can. And when you add in an (un)healthy dose of the culture warring that has poisoned literally everything in the United States, well. People absolutely LOVE exercising control over their enemies. So yes there are people in high places on both sides who would absolutely implement policies just to immiserate the other side and would get joy out of doing so.  

The mask mandate is a great example because while medical masks such as N95's in indoor settings are effective, clothe masks do little, if anything at all and wearing masks outside has been completely unnecessary throughout the entire situation outside of extreme situations like a packed outdoor concert or something. Yet, many blue areas implemented outdoor mask mandates  and as far as I know nobody ever mandated N95 or other medical masks instead of clothe masks. This is just as unscientific as proclaiming that masks as a concept are universally worthless, but many of the same people that "trust the science" dutifully line up to wear their masks outside on a bike ride. Just as the rights bias leads many to believe masks are worthless, the lefts bias leads many to way over emphasize the importance with things like outdoor mask mandates or mask mandates for vaccinated people. At the end of the day so much is poisoned by the culture war, virtue signaling, etc that people can hardly even think straight.

It's perfectly rationale for people on the political right to be anxious about any actions taken by left wing political figures and immediately suspect that they want to hurt them--because they do!
Created:
3
Posted in:
Homosexuality
I’m still laughing at the idea that you can just flagrantly get away with crimes in rich suburbs. Drug crimes MAYBE. But violent crimes? Those wealthy McMansion neighborhoods are among the most boring places on earth, absolutely chock full of the type of housewives who will call the cops on teenagers playing pranks and police officers who are bored stupid and would love nothing more than to investigate a violent crime. If someone think it’s even remotely possible that there is any significant number of violent crimes going unreported there they are out of their mind. 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
I don’t understand how you can feel comfortable falsely accusing an entire race of people of collectively committing millions of more crimes annually than they actually do.
Created:
2
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
Black on white crime is 5.3x the reverse according to the official statistics. Black people are 13% of the population but commit around 50% of the homicides. According to the official statistics. Your argument is that actually whites commit crimes at the same rate but the police just decline to prosecute them or don’t catch them because enforcement is lax in lily white towns (which is hilariously wrong btw). Where are the bodies? Do people get regularly mugged walking down the street in a white suburb but the police just don’t get there in time? Put up or shut up. 

Great point about Hispanics btw. If the police are so racist and just let whites get away with murder and only enforce laws against minorities how come once you adjust for age (and definitely once you adjust for poverty) the Hispanic crime rate is pretty close to the white crime rate? Why don’t Hispanic people also represent a wildly disproportionate percentage of homicides in the statistics that you allege without evidence are not accurate?  


Created:
2
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
You are alleging that the reason there is a difference in crime rates is due mostly to enforcement. Your allegation is that there are literally hundreds of thousands of white on black crimes annually along with the millions of white on white crimes required to make the rates close to equal that go totally unreported. Do you have even the slightest evidence to support that? 

Created:
0
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
I restate my case against Franklin, over-policing in poorer areas, where there are more black people, leads to increases in the stats. 
Bullshit it does. It’s high time you start treating black people as human beings capable of moral agency and stop blaming every bad thing in their community on whitey.

The difference in rates of violent crime are far, far too vast to be explainable by differences in enforcement. Homicide is the best way to disprove this because enforcement standards have to be absolutely garbage tier for them not to be investigated. And the homicide statistics are crystal clear—they aren’t correlated with wealth or whiteness at all. 

Also if you think it’s easier to get away with a crime in a cushy suburban white neighborhood or a small town than it is in the ghetto that only shows your own lack of life experience

Created:
2
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Mesmer
Firstly, this is based.
I’m tired of being lumped into a group and then having that group slandered. At this point I basically view this sort of racist rhetoric as both incitement to violence and intentionally devised to divide and demoralize the population. It’s so disgusting 

Created:
3
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Dr.Franklin
true, but they use those arms less frequently than any other race, in fact According to the FBI, African-Americans accounted for 55.9% of all homicide offenders in 2019, with whites 41.1%, and "Other" 3.0% in cases where the race was known. [1]
Agree with everything you said. Also want to point out that amazingly the FBI STILL doesn't disaggregate Hispanic people from White people in their statistics so a large chunk of that 41.1% is Hispanic. Once you adjust for age Hispanics don't have a much higher rate of violent crime than white people do so it isn't the majority of the 41%, perhaps a quarter, but still.

And the suggestion that white people are the most arrogant is just laughable. I've never seen a more self loathing group of people in my life. This kind of rhetoric scares me to death
Created:
0
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@SkepticalOne
Funny. My marriage license didn't come from a church. Did yours?

The fact is the government licenses marriages, so they should be available to everyone regardless of how dogmatic religious folks feel about it. 
Yes it is a lot harder to justify banning same sex marriage when the government gets involved and gives people so many economic advantages due to it. I'm a Catholic and pretty okay with the status quo where a church can refuse to marry a gay couple
Created:
1
Posted in:
Homosexuality
-->
@Theweakeredge
You see, me personally, I view white people as the most dangerous people
This is objectively wrong. Per the Bureau of Justice Statistics in 2019 "There were 5.3 times as many violent incidents committed by black offenders against white victims (472,570) as were committed by white offenders against black victims (89,980)." Since white people outnumber black people in the US around 6-1 this ratio should be reverse. If white people were the most dangerous people, as you allege, the ratio should actually be 7+ white on black crimes for every black on white crime, the reality is the exact opposite. 

Created:
2
Posted in:
INFORMATION PLEASE: POST-VAX BREAKTHROUGH CLUSTERS
-->
@oromagi
None of this refutes the conventional wisdom- that vaccines are not 100% effective; that breakthrough cases in the vaccinated are rare; that vaccinated people get less sick than unvaccinated.  
What I had heard was that they are close to 100% effective at preventing hospitalization and death, not at preventing infection. I would be curious how severe the cases are. They are probably pretty minor infections.  I’m hearing rumblings that some of the new variants are starting to beat the vaccines but I haven’t seen any hard data that supports that at all yet. It’s also possible that the delta variety is more transmissible but less severe. All in all I’m not very worried at this point 
Created:
1
Posted in:
Schools should teach children that lbtq+ exists and its ok to be LGBTQ+
What class should this be taught in?
Created:
1
Posted in:
CRT Breaks Everything
-->
@FLRW
Thanks, very interesting paper website although I don't think you accurately represented their findings which were very nuanced. I went to the findings tab and gave it a read. The paper didn't analyze bias in stop rates which is almost impossible unless we can somehow control for driving behavior. 

They did examine searches, and concluded:

In our data, the success rate of searches (or the hit rate) is generally lower for Hispanic drivers compared to white drivers; so the outcome test indicates Hispanic drivers face discrimination. For black drivers, search hit rates are typically in line with those of white drivers, indicating an absence of discrimination.
I would argue this is more likely to mean that the police are more heavy-handed in areas with large hispanic population than proof of bias, but who knows. The way they concluded there was discrimination was through the application of a "threshold test." I don't think it was explained how they found the thresholds very well at all on the site, so I went to the link they provided for their paper and found it here: https://5harad.com/papers/threshold-test.pdf. A lot of it is above my head. If we were debating instead of having a friendly discussion I would dig into this more, but I will just say that this isn't very compelling to me at all. If there really was widespread systemic discrimination I don't think you'd need to use statistical modeling with who knows how many assumptions to tease it out, the raw numbers would do the job for you. The fact that the police have a similar success rate in finding drugs/weapons/whatever when searching black people and white people suggests VERY strongly to me that the police on aggregate apply the same standards to search someone. 
Created:
3
Posted in:
CRT Breaks Everything
-->
@drlebronski
Yes white privilege exists if you are white your chances of getting pulled over without reason are significantly lower. I am white my chances of getting pulled over are significantly lower which is a fact if you would like the study ask.
Would you mind sending me that/linking it here?
Created:
1
Posted in:
CRT Breaks Everything
-->
@Fruit_Inspector
Don’t let him get to you. Being prickly in the forums is kinda his thing, just roll your eyes and let it slide 
Created:
3
Posted in:
CRT Breaks Everything
-->
@Fruit_Inspector
yeah the race essentialism is very, very bad and needs to be stopped. I think that no matter what it flames out soon because it’s just such a miserable way to live. But who knows, I don’t want to predict the future. Ten years ago I definitely wouldn’t have predicted that this was coming 

It always blows my mind to think back to when I was growing up how normal everything was. I couldn’t have even imagine what was to come. Feels like the memories of a different person 
Created:
1