Hello FishCasher, I apologies for how long it took for me to publish this first round's argument. Once again for this debate, I would like to make it clear that this is plainly for fun and not a major competition. And with that I will begin.
Throughout the progression of this debate, I will publishing my least influential arguments first. Or in other words, I will be saving the best for last.
Rey, as a character in the Star Wars sequel trilogy, suffers from severe narrative shortcomings that make her the weakest-written character in the franchise’s history. Her lack of internal struggles, inexplicable mastery of skills, and shallow character development contribute to an overall failure in compelling storytelling. For this first point, I will be looking into how Rey has no meaningful contribution to the Star Wars legacy.
Rey's character falls short in establishing a meaningful ideological or thematic impact within the Star Wars universe, unlike her predecessors who profoundly shaped the franchise’s moral, philosophical, and mythological depth.
1. Lack of Philosophical or Ideological Evolution
Throughout Star Wars history, key protagonists have introduced distinct philosophical dilemmas that shape the galaxy’s balance between light and dark:
- Luke Skywalker: His journey redefines the nature of heroism, showing that true strength lies in restraint and compassion. His decision to redeem Darth Vader challenges traditional notions of good versus evil.
- Anakin Skywalker: His tragic fall explores themes of fate, free will, and the dangerous allure of absolute power, enriching the narrative with cautionary elements about moral ambiguity.
- Obi-Wan Kenobi: His arc emphasizes duty, sacrifice, and emotional resilience in the face of loss, reinforcing themes of loyalty and the consequences of war.
Rey, however, does not introduce any new ideological conflicts. Her path is a straightforward struggle against evil that lacks the deeper philosophical questions her predecessors grappled with. Her ultimate victory does not challenge existing moral paradigms or push Star Wars into new intellectual territory.
2. Weak Influence on the Star Wars Legacy
Every major Star Wars protagonist leaves a lasting ideological footprint, shaping how future generations interact with the Force and the galaxy’s political landscape. However, Rey’s impact is minimal in comparison:
- Luke’s redemption arc and Jedi teachings inspire future Force users.
- Anakin’s fall and prophecy echo throughout the saga, shaping galactic history.
- Obi-Wan’s dedication influences the Rebellion and future Jedi philosophy.
Rey, despite claiming the Skywalker name, does not add depth to existing Jedi traditions or create a philosophy that future heroes can build upon. Her story concludes with a largely symbolic gesture—burying the Skywalker lightsabers—rather than offering a transformative lesson about the Force or the struggle between light and dark.
3. Repetitive Conflict Without Narrative Growth
Rather than introducing fresh themes, Rey’s story largely revisits familiar ground:
- The fight against Palpatine mirrors the original trilogy’s resolution, but without the emotional stakes tied to Vader’s redemption.
- Her “chosen one” narrative lacks complexity, as she is simply granted extreme Force powers rather than earning them through hardship.
- Instead of expanding on the Force’s mysteries, her powers seem limitless without explanation, removing the intrigue surrounding Jedi training and development.
Rey’s arc does not meaningfully expand Star Wars mythology or challenge core themes. Whereas Luke, Anakin, and Obi-Wan left philosophical and moral dilemmas to ponder, Rey’s legacy is primarily functional—she defeats evil—but does not redefine any aspect of the saga.
Conclusion
Rey’s character ultimately struggles to leave a meaningful imprint on Star Wars storytelling. While she is a central figure in the sequels, her narrative lacks the ideological weight, mythological expansion, and philosophical depth that made Luke, Anakin, and Obi-Wan so integral to Star Wars history.
Thank you.
You should have probably specified lead character. Compare her to say Jar-Jar, and she ain't all bad...
That said, I find defenses of her being the greatest star pilot who ever lived to be quite laughable.