-->
@Vader
Appreciate that. Honestly, haven’t had many opportunities to function in the capacity of someone who is widely townread trying to lead a lynch. Clearly still have work to do on that front.
Appreciate that. Honestly, haven’t had many opportunities to function in the capacity of someone who is widely townread trying to lead a lynch. Clearly still have work to do on that front.
The themesplit is way too difficult imo. With such a huge amount of thematic information (it's five books of lore, for god's sake), a themesplit shouldn't be that obscure. I actually considered the "survived Tartarus" themesplit, but dismissed it because Nico di Angelo also survives Tartarus. Making it "of the Seven" is kinda arbitrary
IMO, this fits well with Annabeth's decision to go to the quest alone.
Just some personal notes about theme and setup:-The themesplit is way too difficult imo. With such a huge amount of thematic information (it's five books of lore, for god's sake), a themesplit shouldn't be that obscure. I actually considered the "survived Tartarus" themesplit, but dismissed it because Nico di Angelo also survives Tartarus. Making it "of the Seven" is kinda arbitrary.
-Setup was slightly scumsided, but I don't really think the night actions ended up affecting the final result much. Great job on Pie for designing a role madness setup without an incredible amount of swing - I know from experience that it's not easy.
-Most of the justifications made sense. The only one I still don't get is Rachel - how does that have to do with her determining alignment?
-Random thought: Switching around Reyna and Rachel for the roles might have worked better.
-I'm going to defend my ascetic claim. The idea of claiming ascetic thematically is to emphasize that I can't be protected, I can't be given items, etc. IMO, this fits well with Annabeth's decision to go to the quest alone.
I agree. It was pretty hard to find, and on top of him surviving Tartarus in the third book, I would be very much suprised if anyone would have got that.
I disagree with this part. She didn’t chose to go alone, she HAD to go alone, only children of Athena could find it, and Percy is a son of Poseidon. But I can partly see where you are coming from.
The problem is Barney hard-slipping by missing BK's fullclaim
akin to what Barney as Town replacement did the game before hosted by Austin
Austin didn't towntell at all and wasn't brutally pressed for a claim for reasons I can't comprehend.