I don't think I'll be voting [Casey, Mharman, Pie] today.
Leaving... [GP, WF, Earth, Luna, Wylted].
I'm clear on my policy in regards to inactives, so not Luna, and I have a slight TR on Wylted, at the very least more than several other players.
[GP, WF, Earth] is where I'm looking for now.
GP's claim reads as slightly towny, some of the specific aspects feel a bit too strange to be made up and seem like something that a mod not used to traditional DART roles might put in, rather than what a player used to traditional DART roles would fake. That doesn't entirely sound coherent, but what I'm trying to say is:
A Treestump that remains flipless is something that's very rarely seen on DART. I have made one, but GP wasn't playing in that game and I doubt he was spectating. But Treestump is a common role on MU and a lot of other site metas which I presume Cerulean is familiar with.
So I'm just not sure where GP would have gotten that idea from. (I mean, he could have gotten it from me if we're both scum, but I know that's not true)
His behavior bothers me though, it feels deliberately evasive.
I've given my thoughts on WF. It's a bit harsh to say he's in his scum meta, but he definitely hasn't left it. His passivity bothers me to an extent, as does his main push seemingly being a reaction to GP scumreading him, which at best is NAI.
It's also pingy, from a thread point of view, that there's been so little focus on him even when I brought him up several times.
Earth is... meh. I had a slight townlean but that's mostly disappeared. He could flip scum, he could flip town.