I am going to give a cumulation of my reads and summarize what I am thinking
First off my strongest town read is Luna.
First thing is first, I think it safe to assume that scum knew that Pie's role was a Even Night role. I can't think of any reason for them to target Pie other than getting some info that Pie's role exists. The only way Luna could have known a 3p in the game if he asked the question. I don't think Luna as scum would do this and the best bet for him would probably to try and to find a town role that is in the game to fake claim and combine. It just makes no sense for them to use their 1 extra role asking to ask if there's a 3p role. If he did, well then wow GG, we are fucked
My second strongest town read is Wylted
Wylted usually likes to communicate the most in the forums in the DP and is arguably one of the strongest DP players that play on the site. He does it as town and does it at scum. Wylted basically loses a huge tool he has at his disposal. I know that Pie did something similiar, but Pie relies on his NP actions as scum and WIFOM rather than convincing town. That's wylted's strongsuit and I don't think he'd give it up. Not to mention he hasn't acted out of the ordinary besides taking a DART break, but he does that. His gamestyle and gameplay and thoughts allign with his town play
My third strongest town read is Greyparrot
While I will say that GP isn't as town as in normal games just due to the nature of his role, but when you look at his meta, playstyle, and beliefs as town, he is following what he normally does. Also in a game where scum aren't given fake claims (I'm assuming they aren't from the OP's and Casey's past game, quote if wrong), it seems like such a weird and vague claim. Granted this gives him some leverage as scum because there is no reason for him to be targetted for behavior, but I also think he would've claimed something a lot better.
So, with that in mind I am going to go to my biggest scum reads
Banana - scum = not aligned with town. No matter what way you look at it. Even if they are a 3P, they don't align with towns goal so they are scum by default. They MAY NOT be mafia
My biggest scum read in Whiteflame
Besides POE, and my behavior analysis on him that I stated with him, I am also thinking about the NK and what WF would do as scum. I could definetly see WF as scum being paranoid about Earth asking for conditions on Pie's PGO and asking if there are any roles that are a x Night in the game. I could definetly also see Whiteflame silencing Wylted to draw out some of his wild convincing. I've played a few games with WF, but killing Pie because of his town read and how he'd have to be alive to NP3 if they didn't kill him. Whiteflame is a great player but I've seen him as scum try to play cautiously versus taking risks and letting it out. I remember in TUF Mafia that when me and him were scum, it took a good amount of convincing from him to try and make a gambit in NP3.
If Banana DOES flip 3p, my second scum read would be Savant
I really just get a weird vibe from Savant. I do want to see what Austin has to say about his "Jailkeep" but if his action got prevented, it does give credit but behavioral his reads just feel very stiff. I asked him for more elaboration on his reads versus the short sentences and he kinda just doubled down on the shortness. When we put pressure on him for some of his DP1 behaviorals, he pointed out a key thing saying, so you wanna scum read me in the last game for one behavior but scum read me for doing the opposite. That would actually indicate he is scum.
Austin is in my POE but for now I'm null. I don't like how quickly he was to write off Savant as town despite believing Banana is a 3P.
