Cerulean (lean town)
Post #18 of DP1 was the first thing that got me intrigued. I felt there was no chance on hell Banana's claim could be confused for a miller claim, and yet, Cerulean was asking for it. To me, this seemed like a roundabout way of prying at the possibility of a cop. Tbh, I got a little tunneled on this, and attempted to bait more cop searching out of Cerulean in a few of my own posts this DP. It was lowkey a retarded way of going about things but I got paranoid. Also the reason why I was tagging him so much. Also the reason why I didn't posts any reads yesterday, I wanted to assess him more bc a read on him changes a few things with others.
Anyway, when Cerulean entered the DP, not only did he not take the bait, but he also revealed he was a protective role, with a possible CC on ADOL, not only is this a bit of a risky an unnecessary play if he's mafia, but it also means that even if he was searching for cops, he has a towny reason for it.
And then there's the analysis he's been giving. Unpairing Earth and Lunatic, the sus on Pie (even if not correct imo I can see the concern from his POV), post 161 of Dp1 and 194 of DP2 are standouts. I don't agree with the assessment that his takes are just parroting. Given how inactive he's been he's gonna lean on ideas others have pointed out, but I see a few original ideas he's put forth.
Vader (solid town)
I had some qualms bout his behavior DP1. His sus on Earth felt a bit OMGUSy and I did get the sense a good chunk of his points weren't too original. I was kinda following Earth's reasoning on him, which was also retarded of me. Then DP2 comes along and he's obviously the fruit vendor. No, he would not have asked Whiteflame this if he were scum and I am confident he and Whiteflame are not paired. He literally crumbed it DP1 and I ignored it during my DP1 read.
Banana (solid town)
I saw Banana's claim and my first thought was "there's no way she does this as scum after it backfired on her when she was town a few games ago, right?" I am reminded of when she over shared the detail about her PM having "like 14 messages" and how this would be an even crazier overshare. Now, Banana's reasoning on her own behavior kinda surprised me cause my mind went to the 14 messages thing instead of the CC from Diary Mafia (I didn't think the CC was all that bad). But her giving her own separate reason just reveals a genuine thought process for why she's doing what she's doing. I just don't buy her claiming "town executioner" as scum, not even with an aggressive teammate. Hell, if Tvellalott himself were her teammate, I doubt he'd tell her to go for it.
Also a bit of mod psych, but as someone who helped Casey design her previous setup, I can tell you she will go off the walls with the setup ideas.
Nothing this DP really sticks out to me. Apparently Lunatic said she's disappeared or whatever (something like that) but that don't mean shit to me cause Banana was never a consistent poster in any game I've seen her play.
library's closing so I'll need to find somewhere else to take my laptop. I might have to work on typing the rest from my mobile phone