Roses are red, violets are blue. In Soviet Russia, the game plays you!
IT'S A MAFIA + THIRD PARTY VICTORY!
Mafia: Cerulean, Lunatic
Third Party: whiteflame (Survivor)
Commentary:
"Dude is everyone just playing bad on purpose"
-- Vader, sent to me after his death, providing the realest quote of this game.
I will admit, I made a mistake in setting up this game. Ivan IV was indeed the first Tsar of All Russia, but wasn't necessarily the first person to be called 'tsar', which is where the town v town fight between Banana and Earth came from. Tsar of All Russia was a particular title that Ivan IV was the first to hold, while Ivan III was referred to as 'tsar', though Russia was not yet a true tsardom at the time and he was mostly referred to as 'tsar' by people outside Russia. Also, I'm not sure if he was actually the first person to be called 'tsar'. Yeah, I wasn't as familiar with Ivan the Great as most of the other characters in this game, and I should have been more careful about writing his role PM. I sincerely apologize for that.
That being said, the town really brought this loss upon itself. Even without PM issues, Earth may have gotten himself lynched regardless with how little he was posting and contributing. Earth, I know you are a low poster in general, and I'm not going to ask you to completely change up your playstyle or anything like that -- I think having players with different styles is overall a good thing. That being said, you have to do something to make sure you actually get townread.
Really, that's the lesson that needs to be taken away from this game. Not one, but two members of the town tried a gimmick to bait the night kill, and both ended up getting themselves lynched instead. The claims themselves weren't necessarily bad -- I actually think that Anastasia/Beloved Princess in particular was quite genius, but player behavior ended up putting an unnecessary spotlight on them. As Austin said to me over PM in the middle of the game, "It took me about 10 minutes into my first mafia game to realize that being towny, and having others listen to you, are as important as finding scum." And yeah, I think that pretty much sums it up.
I don't know if the right takeaway here is necessarily to never, ever, do gambits as town, but you have to realize that when you take a gambit, you are assuming the risks that come with it, and you have to be prepared to bare those risks. You can't lie about your character and role and then act righteously indignant when people call you out on it, because your indignance isn't righteous.
Also, ADOL, I know I already said this over PM, but waiving your night action on both nights was just a really terrible decision. The chances of you being alive and able to use your ability during NP4 were very low to begin with. You gotta use your abilities while you still can. I don't want to come off as being overly harsh here -- I think you have the potential to be a good player, but you need to learn how to actually play towards your wincon as town. Getting yourself scumread isn't going to help you. If you want to keep playing, though, I hope you will do so. Just be willing to learn and adapt your playstyle, okay?
I think the scum team did an overall decent job here. MVP goes to Luna, who was the most active player and gave himself a ton of towncred with that Dreamer claim. It was extremely risky, of course, since he had no way of knowing that he wasn't visited on the first night, but it paid off, and the claim itself was really good. I loved the justification, definitely something I would actually use.
WF, you played pretty well as well. You didn't have to do much to take the heat off of you given what else was going on in the town, but you were never a serious potential lynch, and neither were you a serious NK candidate, either. You definitely earned your win as a 3P.
Overall, in terms of balance... I do think this game leaned toward the town overall, but not extremely so. The mafia certainly got lucky, but in a different timeline, it may have been much harder for them to pull off a win.
Once again, congrats to the three winners, and I hope we can all learn something from this game to improve our future games.