because Kanye’s new song told me to hate Jews. Also in town locked. Luna can confirm.
That's my point though, theres a list of roles that can "Only be town" "only be scum" and "Could be both". Why not just claim from the "can only be town" list? I mean you can say he is doing to for wifom reasoning, but he didn't have to purposely claim a scummy role from the non distinct list for literally no reason. Scum whiteflame could have made just about any of the town claims work, so why purposely shoot himself in the foot. If the only answer is wifom manipulation, I don't think that's a strong enough reason to suspect him when that same wifom reasoning is just as likely to work against him
I doubt I am stealth. It's a WW2 era plane so no, and since the game is so small I think it's smart from me to deviate from my normal meta and go ahead and claim miller.I am miller and I soft claimed my her here.
Would abilities that are part of the JOAT be the same for both scum and town?
The answer is probability. In a role madness game, you have 5 time.
Let’s say 2 of those have pure town roles, that’s 2/9 possible roles. He has 7 town roles he could claim, but odds are bad. Compare that to the town/mafia list. Advantage of that list is that if scum have it, town don’t have it, so he could be truly a scum JOAT. Plus the list is far bigger so easier to fake claim
I said I was not a stealth jet.
Also I am not mentioning the mistake until it’s relevant. Will detract from behavioral reads and want to to use it as additive confirmation in late game
What does 5 time mean
Bigger list, means less chance of him getting caught on a more "townie" sounding role though. Again he didn't have to claim, I dont think anyone was pushing for his role, just character. There's a ton of more townie sounding roles on that list than JOAT, and I don't think chances are super high he would get CC'ed by most of them. Maybe with cop or doctor, assuming you don't think bullish randomized it like he said.
Thats true, my working theory is that if he’s scum, he told the truth about his role being JOAT. Probably told the truth about his abilities too. Anyways, more consideration tomorrow
It's possible I just don't see it as being extremely likely knowing whiteflame, also having played scum succesfully with him a few times recently and witnessing different behavior from him. Small chance I am wrong here, but for now he's not someone I'd consider lynching unless his behavior started standing out.
Theme wise he’s also an outlier so far; we’ll see where that goes though. I’ll defer to you on the behavior. I can never read is behavior one way or the other anyways.
