-->
@WyIted
For obvious scum slip the rest of you all missed
Care to elaborate?
Terraria Mafia #1 - DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
923
-->
@Mikal
Why am ai town for not jumping on supas lynch?
It implies she knows supa is town? Obviously if he was scum and I was scum I might have reason to heaitate
-->
@WyIted
It implies she knows supa is town? Obviously if he was scum and I was scum I might have reason to heaitate
Maybe, but I think you as scum would have gone for the bus anyway. It'd fit with your style.
Well for starters, I think that there is likely a scum between Savant and Vader. The fact that Savant CC’ed him, along with the points others have made about there unlikely being two vanilla. I also find Savants activity unusual, but he is working on the new site after all.
I put lunatic as lean scum. With all that was said before about him, I don’t think I’ll need to repeat myself.
Mikal/Castin is lock town, for obvious reasons.
Most others are null. I barely remember my behavior reads on anyone from when I last played, and those who have claimed already seem to check out.
There are some exceptions though
I put iron as tilt/lean(whatever is closer to null). Reason for this is as the fact that one of the abilities doesn’t match a pressure plate. If this was on purpose I’ll retract my thoughts on him.
This is all I can think of at the moment. If I get anything else I’ll post it.
Vote Count
Vader (4/8) - Mikal/Castin, Lunatic, Savant, Pie
Casey (4/8) - Casey, Ultra, Wylted
Lunatic (1/8) - Vader
Cerulean (1/8) - Resurget
VTNL (1/8) - Irontoaster
Joebob (1/8) - Cerulean
Mikal (1/8) Banana
Not Voting (2) Whiteflame, Joebob
An old classic right here.
-->
@JoeBob
The fact that Savant CC’ed him, along with the points others have made about there unlikely being two vanilla.
I’d like to understand this: you think a scum Savant would CC a Vanilla role? I find that very difficult to believe, especially since this would be far from the first game with two vanilla players and it’s significantly larger than most other games. Just seems like a very odd move to CC someone with a fake Vanilla claim.
-->
@JoeBob
Well for starters, I think that there is likely a scum between Savant and Vader. The fact that Savant CC’ed him, along with the points others have made about there unlikely being two vanilla. I also find Savants activity unusual, but he is working on the new site after all.
Why do you think there's only one vanilla at most? Put it in your own words.
-->
@WyIted
Don’t really get the decision to try to hide your double voter while voting, but that’s not how I think you’d play it as scum (seems like a weird way to give away your role regardless, but given the advantage it affords you as scum, it’s particularly confusing in that instance), so you’re in my town pile.
Time Check: 20 hours remaining
-->
@whiteflame
My vote counts for double. I was going to keep it in the bag a while but it's probably easy to figure out when every person invite for has an extra vote. I still thought people would just assume a hidden voter for a while and leave me alone lol
-->
@WyIted
Certainly a choice, but I’m townreading it.
-->
@whiteflame
@Casey_Risk
Why do you think there's only one vanilla at most? Put it in your own words.
I would like to retract what I said before as it was on the fly.
Now that I thought about it better, I checked mharmans past 6 ish games and it was around 2 games that has two vanilla, 1 game that had one, and 3 games that had three.
Using this alone, I feel like it would be more likely that their was either one vanilla or another vanilla that has yet to claim, and I find the three vanilla option more likely.
you think a scum Savant would CC a Vanilla role?
I find it odd that Savant CC Vader in the first place. Unless he thought that there was only one vanilla, like you said in this large of a game, which I find weird.
Unless he later explained it and I missed it.
-->
@JoeBob
I find it odd that Savant CC Vader in the first place. Unless he thought that there was only one vanilla, like you said in this large of a game, which I find weird.Unless he later explained it and I missed it.
He did explain already that he thought at first that there would probably only be one vanilla in this game, before realizing that there likely would be more than one.
-->
@Casey_Risk
See my post #661.
That doesn’t address my problem imo.
Mikal explicitly gave the example with the axe. It’s literally verbatim. His own PM contradicts the whole tier thing. Not to mention him asking Mharman something that was explicitly written in his PM.
-->
@WyIted
Why am ai town for not jumping on supas lynch?It implies she knows supa is town? Obviously if he was scum and I was scum I might have reason to hesitate
Honestly, you’re right. And I buy your claim. It makes sense from a balance POV especially if it’s a 10-3-1 game.
-->
@Casey_Risk
Maybe, but I think you as scum would have gone for the bus anyway. It'd fit with your style.
How so?
JoeBob reeks town
Town Pile:
Pie
Mikal/Castin
Wylted
Savant
JoeBob
Tilt Town:
REF
IronToaster
Null:
Cerulean
Ultra
Whiteflame
Banana
Tilt Scum:
Lunatic
Casey
Scum:
Vader
1. Lunatic - Loom - Strengthener (Soft: Crafting Station)
2. Mikal/Castin - Item Category
3. Ultra - Consumable Item
4. Whiteflame - Critter
5. Pie - NPC
6. Resurget - Tiered NPC
7. Casey - Individual Item
8. Savant - Vulture - Vanilla (Soft: NPC)
9. Vader - Shortsword - Vanilla (Soft: Item)
10. Irontoaster - Pressure Plate - JOAT: 3x Cop, 1x Poisoner, 1x Bomb (No Soft)
11. Joebob - Vital Item
12. Wylted - Chest - Doublevoter
13. Banana - Consumable Item
14. Cerulean - Item Spawned Naturally
-->
@Castin
^^^^
Actually I just realized something, but I need to ask Mharman first. Depending on the answer it will move someone in my list
-->
@Mikal
UnvoteFor Mikal. Revolt after Mharman
So... Vader did post, and this is what he posted. Mikal, do you know what this is about? Is this about the mod confirmation and has he just given up or is that just me?
-->
@Mharman
I unvoted
-->
@whiteflame
Meant revoting. Mikal asked me to unvote so I did
I was just in my car driving and autocorrected
-->
@Vader
Meant revoting. Mikal asked me to unvote so I did
That makes more sense. I had no context for a revolt. Anyway, looking for some responses dude. Pie's made a pretty convincing case that you've contradicted yourself.
-->
@whiteflame
Like I said my story is very clear
My item was listed as Short Sword, which is why I thought it was maybe a variation. I realized it wasn’t by looking at the item when I googled it and the wiki came up as one word which I why I said item. I was referencing my PM the whole time and literally had 0 clue it’s a category
I can’t do anything about it. It’s a matter of unconfirmability. I asked the mod and he gave me a direct response versus Mikal and according to Mikal he said they can give completely different responses. I don’t know how we even have a case at this point because it’s clear as day there is some form of miscommunication from a mod perspective that I literally have no control over. I’ve already accepted I’m going to be mislynches but going back and forth with the same point with Pie, someone who I all in honestly scum read does 0% for the town
It’s literally just a way to distract from actually trying to look for scum since he continuously brings it up and allows mafia to hide.
-->
@Vader
This is the post I'm referring to, and it doesn't involve whether you should have heard anything from Mharman or not. I'd like to know what changed between these two posts, and why you initially didn't think there were tiers to the item considering a tier is literally mentioned in the justification you gave.
-->
@whiteflame
No I asked him to vote to test the dbl vote