South Park Mafia DP4

Your argument is WIFOM. Maybe they want you to think that’s what happened. However, he’s our only protective role so I’m inclined to believe him.

Problem is mislynch and lose tonight. Its very convenient we get results at this stage of the game. We have to evaluate this carefully, 50/50 shot of catching scum or losing the game.

Agreed. Only 1/3 last games by Supa had a Doctor. But one of the two just had goons and the other there were power roles for everyone except one person.

I’m kinda sus on Oro. He’s more of a lurker when he’s scum and he’s hasn’t posted the cumulative role and character sheet which he always does. Could be coincidence tho so

The only other thinking I can Wifom for in favor of singularity being town is that drafter has been suspicious of her since dp1 and I'm pretty darn sure drafter is scum. He could have been creating distance between her though, so it's not a particularly strong Wifom argument but something that will nag at me. Still, I think its more likely a scum gambit to get what they thought would be an easy win. On the bright side this makes the rest od the games POE pretty simple. Im considering speed confirmed town based on the BP thing. I suppose there is a chance that singularity blocked the kill on go np2 but I doubt that. If it was Between pie and bullish I am leaning pie is town, and if they are both town then its oro, drafter, and singularity/water whoever we find out it is after deliberating and hopefully choosing correctly this ohase.

My experience of oro has been that hes usually inactive post day phase 1. I was pretty frustrated with him in the office mafia for it. He posts just enough to not be replaced but not be considered inactive 

The only other power role we know of is Comedian, but it's even night so it doesn't matter. That means they had to have RBd Singularity. There's literally no one else to RB 

The only way you don't believe this is if you think I'm an ascetic and they don't have an RV   

Bullish confirmed Oro, so if Bullish is scum then Oro is scum and vice versa

Dude you can't just believe someone because they claim to be a protective role. You're usually the one who has correct reads but haven't given them at all and I'm suspicious

Bullish didn't confirm Oro. His role could be maf sided and he used Oro to narrow down his own results. Bullish being scum doesn't make Oro scum

Please explain your role function in the clearest way possible, then vote Singularity

Yeah I asked above

But if Oro has to be Vanilla, vig, or doc, doesn't that mean he's confirmed? Only thing is if the target "COULD BE" one of the roles he was given

Also vote Singularity

If Bullish doesn't die tomorrow, he's scum

I've been thinking about Bullish's claim, too. As written, the three roles you are provided are roles that are actually in the game, but no one has claimed vig or doctor.

But that could be an implementation issue.

It's mylo, inclination is to NL

If you're going to NL, please explain why Singularity wouldn't have been RBd

Roles

Me (1x bulletproof) (Vanilla now)

Bullish (Comedian)

Pie (1x Escort) (Vanilla now)

I'm leaning to the singularity side. I just need to get to work to review somethings.

Not lynching will change NOTHING. Specifically because we will still have Singularity v. Water, but ALSO if Bullish doesn't die then we know he's scum (assuming Singularity doesn't claim to doc him

That's one of the reasons why I want to lynch Singularity now is to not give him an excuse to claim to doctor Bullish, a possible scum buddy and the last remaining scum role

I think it's singularity and lunatic is one of HIS scum partners 

Also Singularity flipping scum pretty much confirms me

You know he's scum, vote him

Re-reading DP1 and it's painfully clear that Water is town.

If only press would have been fucking active so he could use that suicide bomber role and we wouldn't be at mylo.

I tend to not be one who over thinks things, but I'm gonna do that here.

Pls vote Singularity

once again, I named Oro, which is NOT a visit, and got that his role could be one of Vanilla, Vig, or Doctor.

I asked but got not definitive answer to these potential variations in the role:

1. Is vanilla townie and goon mafia distinguished?

2. Are all 3 roles necessarily in the game?