Right but whoever he protected should still be alive and he dies in their stead, at least how I understand bodyguard
    Captain America: Civil War Mafia - DP2
Posts
           Read-only 
        
    
      Total:
182
    
  Wait I have never been in a game with a lynchproof that I can recall.
Speed does the DP end if we hypothetically lynch a hypothetical lynchproof or is it basically like a popular with +infinity votes needed instead of +1?
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Speedrace
            
          
      Above
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@drafterman
            
          
      That depends on whether the guarding works whenever the protected player dies or only if they're NKed.
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@SirAnonymous
            
          
      True
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@drafterman
            
          
      Bodyguard normally only protects from deaths that could be prevented by a doctor. He would not have been able to delay GPs suicide for example.
Obviously I am not the mod so speed may use the role differently. Feel free to ask them a hypothetical like the one I ask above.
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      The DP would end if a lynchproof were lynched
    Fucking goddamn communism.
Unvote
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      Communism has no honor.
    Testing SAs claim would bring us to mylo in a best case scenario then so we shouldn't do that unless he is for totes scum, which he honestly might be idk. Want to wait for the rest to come in and have a say.
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      It would be nice if there were more than just the three of us.
    Vote Count
SirAnonymous - drafterman
Not Voting: SirAnonymous, Ragnar, Bullish, warren42, oromagi, Lunatic, Discipulus_Didicit
“Pie is town confirmed.” Noted.
Lynching Sir might be the best play here anyway because if he’s mafia lynchproof we’re fucked if he’s MYLO/LYLO
    
My scum pile is warren oromagi and ragnar and warren just came in spouting a bunch of nonsense about mafia lynchproof so I'll go ahead and vtl warren for now.
Back to lurking.
  Back to lurking.
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      You're shitting me right?
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      You saying all three are scum or two of those three are scum because three scum remaining would be absurd.
    Also, I just don't like the idea of letting a lynchproof claim go on principle.
    Anyway, if Sir is both lynchproof and mafia and he gets to LYLO mafia wins, assuming there's no vig (and given the suicide bomber and suicidal I doubt it)
    Vote Count
SirAnonymous - drafterman
warren42 - Discipulus_Didicit
Not Voting: SirAnonymous, Ragnar, Bullish, warren42, oromagi, Lunatic
I still can't believe that Water targeted Grey. That was so dumb. I wonder how many pieces of silver the mafia paid him to do that? /s
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@SirAnonymous
            
          
      I still can't believe that Water targeted Grey. That was so dumb. I wonder how many pieces of silver the mafia paid him to do that? /s
50 blackberry pies 😋
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@ILikePie5
            
          
      A ghost! Go back to your grave, foul apparition! Roll the stone back over the grave, and stay forever buried!
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@SirAnonymous
            
          
      Not enough, they definitely got the better end of that deal
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@warren42
            
          
      Yeah, they did. There's no way to eat 50 pies before most of them go bad unless you eat nothing but pie for a week, and then you just get sick. Mafia, on the other hand, gets one DP closer to victory. Definitely a win for mafia. Doesn't work well for us townies, though.
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Discipulus_Didicit
            
          
      Oopsie Daisy
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@WaterPhoenix
            
          
      Quiet. No more outside interference. If one more dead person talks, we'll lynch them.
    While that was a joke, I am serious about not wanting any more dead people posting.
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Bullish
            
          
          
            
@Speedrace
            
          
      VTL Bullish
    
         --> 
          
    
            
@Barney
            
          
      What's your reason for voting Bullish?
    Pretty sure it’s Didi and Bullish. Technically we can test the lunch proof claim, but any mislynch and it’s game over.
     
       
       
       
       
       
       
       
      