Reads (I forget who replaced siranon and supa so will use original names in all these RFDs).
TOWN
Disc - Claimed a confirmable role. An unblockable confirmable role no less so he won't be able to use the "oh I can't confirm cuz I was blocked" excuse like last game. Oh wait, he was town that game too.
Oromagi - Scum knows that I am town and therefore knows that my role claim is real so oromagi had no reason to continue posting between the time I made my bluff and the time I revealed I was bluffing.
Bullish - Early advocation of popcorning (something I had not thought of) and willingness to claim early themselves despite not technically needing to. Also according to oros theory bullish might possibly have a confirmable role. There are holes in this theory that I won't go into but behavior still reads as town to me.
SirAnon - Early miller claim is a null tell in my experience. I have seen it from both town and scum. However his early distress at the anti-town fluff posting seems similar to his early distress at townies randomly revealing DP 1 last game. That distress made me town read him very strongly and I turned out to be right so I feel comfortable town reading him for similar reasons this game
Speedrace - Displayed a similar reaction to Singularities fluff as two of my other town reads.
drafterman - Clear support for the obvious town bloc could easily be scum trying to blend in but is at least enough to put him higher on the list than the others here.
ILikePie - Scum read on GP seems natural and u manufactured (whether I agree with it or not is irrelevant to my read on pie). Could be scum looking for an easy mislynch, could just be a townie saying whatever comes to mind.
Supadudz - gets a bit more credit for the fluffing incident than singu simply because singu started it. Still looks bad on him from my pov.
Singularity - Apparently this is wylted, which I can totally see now that it is pointed out. Coming from anyone else getting super worked up over the political sim thing would give a slight scum for the possibility that it was a ploy by scum for an excuse to fluff but knowing it comes from wylted makes it a bit worse in my book. Describing an action taken by a person on the internet as 'evil' is something wylted would do. Derailing a mafia game to do so as anything other than an overt scum strategy is not. I wasn't in the discord though, maybe there is a good reason for whatever happened to elicit such a strong emotional reaction. If so wylted would be the type to display such an action so, eh...
Waterphoenix - No significant contributions that I recall. I am usually down to lynch WP any time he is not confirmed just for the PoE. It is impossible to read someone that always stays on the periphery and never takes the lead on anything.
Greyparrot - Examples of GP full claiming early as scum in recent games have been offered as a response to the "GP always full claims as town" idea but all that means is that if GP did claim it would be a null tell not a town tell. In order to say that GP not claiming is a null tell rather than a scum tell we would need to see examples of GP not claiming as town in a recent game. Until then, scum read by meta.
