Recycled Roles Mafia DP4

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

02.01.2020 07:54PM

3

6

9

02.01.2020 07:54PM

-->

@David

Before I vote anyone I want to understand why:

1. Virt investigated the miller claim

2. He got an inno on miller

Because if Virt is telling the truth then:

1. Ragnar is lying, meaning Ragnar is scum and Zaradi isn't.

-or-

2. Virt is insane and gets opposite results, meaning it isn't a clear CC of Zaradi.

But a flavored cop would be an odd choice since any flavors would be known.

I would like Virt to full claim.

#32

Debates: 92

Posts: 1,218

4

7

10

02.01.2020 07:59PM

4

7

10

02.01.2020 07:59PM

-->

@drafterman

I didn’t realize he claimed miller. Didn’t read the entire game yet.

#33

Debates: 92

Posts: 1,218

4

7

10

02.01.2020 08:00PM

4

7

10

02.01.2020 08:00PM

-->

@Zaradi

Full claim is vanilla town. It was clear that I was posting a cop cover.

#34

Debates: 92

Posts: 1,218

4

7

10

02.01.2020 08:00PM

4

7

10

02.01.2020 08:00PM

-->

@Zaradi

It wasn’t a CC

#35

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:05PM

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:05PM

-->

@David

you are permitted to cut & paste your entire PM from Lunatic in this game.

The only exception to that is "copy/pasting role PM" rule. I don't care if you do that, since every role in this game is a role that has been used before, there is no set structure to PM.

Please do so ASAP

#36

Debates: 92

Posts: 1,218

4

7

10

https://www.debate.org/forums/games/topic/62082/

02.01.2020 08:08PM

4

7

10

02.01.2020 08:08PM

-->

@oromagi

Sure thing.

You are 1harderthanyouthink’s role from TUF’s Bartimaeus mafia. Your role: “1harderthanyouthink-You are Jakob Hyrnek, a commoner, and once Kitty’s closest friend. When you were hit by a Black Tumbler, you lost many physical abilities and suffered permanent damage to your face. Your condition renders you almost useless, making you a vanilla townie. Use your voice and your vote to make a difference, even if that difference is messing with Julius Tallow’s spell book, which causes him to turn himself a horrible yellow color. You win with the town.”

#37

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:24PM

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:24PM

-->

@David

Cop cover? What do you mean?

#38

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:26PM

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:26PM

Man. I'd really like to know who Pie motivated, because no one seems to have multiple sets of results.

#39

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:28PM

3

6

9

02.01.2020 08:28PM

Okay, so Virt retracts cop claim meaning Zaradi is unccd.

With a miller, I think it's fairly certain that there is a cop in the game.

Which would make water the liar.

VTL Water.

Topic's author

#40

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,409

3

6

02.01.2020 08:33PM

3

6

02.01.2020 08:33PM

Official Vote Count

waterphoenix- 2/4 - Ragnar, drafterman

Zaradi- 1/4- Waterphoenix

#41

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:47PM

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:47PM

-->

@drafterman

I concur.

I predict that WP will end up being Maynard from socialpinko's Tarantino mafia.

VTL WaterPheonix

Topic's author

#42

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,409

3

6

02.01.2020 08:48PM

3

6

02.01.2020 08:48PM

Official Vote Count

waterphoenix- 3/4 - Ragnar, drafterman, oromagi

Zaradi- 1/4- Waterphoenix

#43

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:49PM

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:49PM

I predict theme will be TOWN=Games won by Mafia MAFIA=Games won by Town

#44

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:52PM

8

10

11

02.01.2020 08:52PM

Also:

I successfully DOC'd WP last night (oops)

and

I was MASON'd by Drafterman and confirm Bullish and Drafter are in a seperate PM with me.

#45

Barney

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,881

5

9

10

Barney

02.01.2020 09:10PM

5

9

10

02.01.2020 09:10PM

-->

@oromagi

Technically that breed of mason can get scum into their chats. Unlikely the case with the Water Zar dispute suggesting one of them, but still not the confirmed town.

#46

Debates: 4

Posts: 705

2

3

7

02.01.2020 09:32PM

2

3

7

02.01.2020 09:32PM

Gg scum

Vtl wp

#47

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

02.01.2020 09:33PM

8

10

11

02.01.2020 09:33PM

-->

@Barney

agreed. And drafter is giving me crap in the PM for not wanting to lynch GP quick last DP which is fairly scummy, I'd say.

Still- GP's guilt gives strength to Zaradi' s claim,

as scum, WP would have known to claim watch me because he knew I doc'd my own NK attempt. Zaradi's cop claims are reasonable.

As drafter points out, there's not point to a MILLER without a COP and we know everybody's claims now which means Zaradi's claim is much stronger

#48

Debates: 4

Posts: 705

2

3

7

02.01.2020 09:38PM

2

3

7

02.01.2020 09:38PM

I really dont like 47. Feels like something scum would say to try to set up a possible ml the next day

#49

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

02.01.2020 09:39PM

3

6

9

02.01.2020 09:39PM

-->

@oromagi

I think you misunderstood Zaradi, I can recruit scum not that I can *be* scum so it doesn't matter how scummy you think I am, you and bullish confirm my recruitment power.

Topic's author

#50

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,409

3

6