Meh, now that I've read the OP I'm not all that thrilled about this game. A game with mostly vanilla townies is lame to me. It doesn't give the town much to go on. I know people think they can read behavior to an extent and perhaps these set ups have become the norm, but I prefer games with more roles so you can catch people lying in role claims, or lying about the action they took during the night. I guess we'll see what happens.
But TUF's note that people would just claim Vanilla (true) can almost read like a noted utility than the hindrance it obviously is. I'm curious why he voted for me to start. I wasn't active and I honestly have no clue what he meant by me playing Mafia recently (I haven't played since DDO, like, three years ago).
I didn't read coal's long posts with analysis at all because it's going to be well thought and make some sense whether he's scum or not, so it'll be more helpful to review later than to get distracted by now. I'll say he leans town. I'll say Zaradi leans town for aforementioned reasons. Sui seems townish too. There's only so much stock you can put in DP1 with no real possible role claims.
Airmax's post felt forced, though not necessarily scummy. Objectivity's posts were so neutral (even about my absence) that they lacked substance and can read being too careful. Ragnar's been meh. Not voting for me felt a bit contrived since I don't think I was that close to being lynched (not positive) but other than that, his few contributions have been fluffy. Orogami is not familiar to me and needs to post more for me to dissect I guess. And TUF is always tuf for me to read. At this very moment I feel comfortable saying scum is probs among these five.
I'm voting for Ragnar but could probably be swayed to cast a vote for TUF or Orogami if people agree lynching is in town's best interest today. I don't think it always is but it might be in this game with so many vanillas - not sure. Thoughts on possibly no lynching today just to avoid a (very likely) mislynch?
