Stormlight Archive Mafia Endgame

Town wins!

Night actions: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1hRGraJNKphzZ36fBf2OL68EjrqOPlFtl_x3g0v2aLVA/edit?usp=sharing

Role PMs: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gJWnIAPmIxlr0iolHZOlwHH7IvX_1a05Tl0mnbv86RI/edit?usp=sharing

GG's yall

Sweet

When Disc was killed and Croc killed, I very much assumed that the scum team was Cookie and Croc.

I didn’t like Press’s play at all in this game.

The bandwagon on me makes sense, and since the two users I had the most trouble with were scum, I refrain from my 3 page rant. 

As a lesson to new players though, please do not listen blindly to other veterans. Please form opinions about what you read. You can be wrong and you can learn, but piggybacking a mislynch is not only annoying, but rather enfuriating, especially when the user isn’t on

I’m shocked that Bullish didn’t have a slight FoS on Press and instantly piggy backed/town read them. I had a strong issue with that in game that I noted. Even if I thought Press was a town play, I’d definetly have an FoS that’d put him in null. It came obvious he was town after Press got flipped with Ragnar IMO. I didn’t like the play from Bullish (as I expressed). I think you were tunneling to hard on a very viable read

My read was extremely townie as well, yet you tunneled it as scummy

little cookie- You were a bit too reliant on town and not focusing on your own scripted reads. I had an FoS on DP2 as well, but rubberballing without coming to your own conclusions is scummy. Especially if you lurk, which you were doing

Y’all didn’t do bad though

When I started reading I was wondering why when scum knew Bullish was the cop, why kill Speed instead of him NP2? However, you wanted him to investigate LittleCookie but in trying to bait him he investigated WaterPheonix instead correct?

Wait I thought DART was already 2 years old like, a week ago?

Wait no. Wrong thread. Ignore this.

pretty much in retrospect it was hella stupid 

woulda been legendary if it worked tho so we went for it 

Bro I told you he was just being dumb town.

Could have just role blocked him.

It's the nature of gambits. Had you guessed right for who Bullish would investigate, it would have seemed to be a stroke of genius.

The important thing is that you had fun trying it.

I still don’t get why he town read. Press was inherently scummy

yah it was hellla funny especially when wp tried to salvage it with his cop claim 

What did Press/I do?

i thought we could've played better not gonna lie. dp 2 was basically a free dp and the level of inactivity was insane. but, we took a gamble and lawyered cookie instead of just outright roleblocking or killing bullish. though if the gamble paid off it would've been a super dope play, but eh, what happens happens.

Claimed miller right away then I asked for name/justification and he gave them, but I glossed over the part of his post where he said the name and only saw the justification so I asked for name again. Apparently asking for character name after it was already given because I didn't see the name was "scummy" of me so he tunneled the shit out of me with the rest of town and forced me to claim. Supa was the only one insisting I was town (there were some not 100% convinced I was scum but not as vocally defensive of me as Supa), but Supa was also the only one insisting press was scum (I scum read pie a bit at first but then realized his tunnel of me was more likely just dumb town not scum and had him in my town pile). 

I don't think what you did was necessarily dumb, I think it was just a way too unnecessarily risky gamble that didn't pay off. Got to take risks sometimes to keep things interesting though

So Press is a tunneling maniac? Good to know

Well the switched made me believe it. I believe a host would be much more hesitant to replace a mafia players than a town player. I also thought your play from the little I saw was town

Why did u kill croc when we had an even number of players and croc was obv town? you robbed us of a mislynch. 

Obv town to you lol. I was between him and Cookie tho so I'm mad I didn't kill cookie

I wasn’t gonna investigate cookie when I was sussing him the whole DP lmao. Investigating cookie would have been asking to get lawyered. Might as well investigate a miller at that point. 

Was still an even number of players, so U could have saved us an additional mislynch by doing nothing. 

So u guys see the quality and quantity of fake claims lunatic gave scum? At this point a scum fake claim appears more townie than a real claim from town. That’s why I said DP1 a doc claim is meaningless. 

Well until then his behavior was scummy and his claim was fishy. Sorry