I'm going to try to do deeper behavioral analysis on everyone. I'm busy as fuck with finalizing college apps, so this and next week are gonna be pain in the asses.
Riddle Mafia - Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
497
So in regards to Pie in this scenario I think we need to analyze the situation a lot more. I wasn't really thinking much yesterday because of obvious reasons that we know but will not discuss in a mafia game, but reconsidering it there is a lot of options to take.
1. We knew he was critical of town for not pressuring Lunatic for lynchproof last game and the way the role is utilized
2. If Greyparrot is telling the truth and he believes it was Danielle purposefully assigning the role to Grey, it would make sense for Danielle to give Pie a deathproof, as she was the one who was also criticizing Pie's analysis of Lunatic. If there is intent with these roles, I have no doubt that Pie is actually deathproof
Take this with a grain of salt, he could be lying as well, which is a possibility that I wouldn't rule out. Pie advocating himself for a lynch is usually somewhat of a scum tell for him in games I've played with him.
Furthermore I think Pie is still the best target to lynch. In a 9 person game, I HIGHLY doubt that he is a Jester.
Wait nvm this is an 11 person game. Shit
-->
@LikeMagic
Speed seems scummy to me. Mostly gut and I didn't like the reveal of the riddle so quickly since. It paints a target on Luna.
I was thinking about this and trying to decide if it was scummy, and decided no it wasn't. Because I picked up on the clue in the first post as well, and I suck at this type of thing normally. I think outing it was more pro town because mafia would have figured it out anyway.
-->
@Lunatic
@LikeMagic
I think outing it was more pro town because mafia would have figured it out anyway.
+1
skittlez would've said it if I didn't and even if no one said it, I'll bet everything that mafia would've figured it out anyway
Sorry I forgot this game existed and I'm kinda swamped today because I have an essay I didn't start but I'll be much more active tomorrow
also VTL Pie
-->
@SirAnonymous
Are you trying to look like a Jester?
If we have more evidence of that he is jester he would most likely not say this because it is revealing of his identity. I see no reason to have a jester in this game.
I think Magic is town tho, I don't see her instantly scum reading me if she was scum
-->
@SirAnonymous
Unless he is pulling a WIFOM over here...
2 possibilities:
- Pie is a jester
- Pie is town and he is honest
These 2 are the only 2 that are so far plausible.
Vote Count
SirAnon (Greyparrot) -- 1/6 votes
Pie (Intelligence, Supa, Speedrace) -- 3/6 votes
Magic (Pie) -- 1/6 votes
-->
@Intelligence_06
Are you saying you think Pie could be both deathproof and "honest"? Is Honest a flavor? I have not seen it in a game.
The analysis stands. If Pie is Deathproof then lynching is of no consequence. If Pie is not Deathproof, then we lynch scum. I can not see a townie lying about being Deathproof and expressing willingness to test it.
We need to know if a lynch of a deathproof would end the DP.
-->
@LikeMagic
Are you saying you think Pie could be both deathproof and "honest"? Is Honest a flavor? I have not seen it in a game.
No. "Honest" is not a flavour. I probably meant that he is honest about being deathproof, and that means he is town.
All equipped with ways to try and put up a good fight
Does this imply role madness
-->
@Intelligence_06
No. "Honest" is not a flavour. I probably meant that he is honest about being deathproof, and that means he is town
Bruh
-->
@Speedrace
At times I will be fussed. Wording could be subpar.
-->
@Intelligence_06
At times I will be fussed. Wording could be subpar.
Do you realize that she was being sarcastic
-->
@Speedrace
No. I am known for not noticing sarcasm.
-->
@Intelligence_06
I was not being sarcastic. I was asking about this post:
Unless he is pulling a WIFOM over here...2 possibilities:
- Pie is a jester
- Pie is town and he is honest
These 2 are the only 2 that are so far plausible.
[emphasis added] Your phrasing here made it sound like you were referring to some kind of flavor or role, where the player has to give truthful answers or something. But it seems you just weirdly worded the point that you think Pie is possibly legit deathproof?
-->
@LikeMagic
Yes
-->
@SirAnonymous
Does your PM say whether or not the DP would end if you were lynched?
Yup
-->
@Vader
Pie advocating himself for a lynch is usually somewhat of a scum tell for him in games I've played with him.
Ya but the different here is that I’m actively campaigning to be lynched.
-->
@LikeMagic
We need to know if a lynch of a deathproof would end the DP.
Post 113
-->
@Danielle
Unvote
VTL Mikal por actividad
-->
@LikeMagic
But it seems you just weirdly worded the point that you think Pie is possibly legit deathproof?
I think that’s what he meant. I’m pretty sure he has a historically of phrasing things weirdly
-->
@ILikePie5
Pie advocating himself for a lynch is usually somewhat of a scum tell for him in games I've played with him.Ya but the different here is that I’m actively campaigning to be lynched.
Nah. You are more like letting people to try to kill you so you can prove "Look, I am immortal, I am not dead, I am town!" or something.
C'mon, there must be someone awake in 6am. We are in 3 hours of no activity.
-->
@ILikePie5
Does your PM say whether or not the DP would end if you were lynched?Yup
Ok