Yes. That's how raids work. You get breaks in between fights
That's how it is... normally. We all have real life, then play the game when we have breaks. If a raid is no different then there is no reason to call it out unless it is going to prevent you from playing. It clearly isn't preventing him from playing when it is convenient.
Furthermore, why are you making his case for him?
Your reading him off the fact he is checking in the game for a break. This is a bullshit reason to scum read someone
No, your premise is off your philosophy
No it isn't.
"Because I've been vocal about blindly accepting miller claims in the past, to the point of complaining that this acceptance has taken a role that is suppose to be negative utility and has turned it into a free confirmed townie."
You put him in town pile by saying "Elminster went quiet because Pie, Supa, and I are all town and it's in scums interest to let town bicker among themselves."
Why did you put Pie in town pile
This makes no sense. You said he wants to bait a reaction from you, and when you give a contrary opinion from what you state, I shouldn't take it as scum. All you are doing is tunneling Elm off a theory argument that does nothing for the DP to force a lynch
My vote on Elm has nothing to do with mafia theory.
Your reason for Elm has been
"Anyway Elminster won't rage this time, not because he promise, but because he's actually scum and he'll get reamed by his team mates if he throws again with the lead they've developed.
Eli is scum if only for this half assed attempt to rile me up for no reason. This fake indignation screams scum.
He didn't try to rile me up last game when he was town. He just caved and imploded. His behavior here is different."