Wrong does not mean bad. If a cop gets a guilty on an unclaimed miller, the miller doesn't claim and only clams after, then we lynch and he turns inno, it isn't a bad read, but wrong. In this case, I said my read was wrong, I didn't say bad.
I challenged your case because you said that "Pie was challenging an opinion to test me." You said "it was something I said over a year ago as scum." I then said it doesn't matter if it was scum, you can say things you believe as town as scum to manipulate town. Yes? That's the logic.
If I told a person about something they said 2 years ago to question them, that would come off as weird? I just thought it was strange that Pie was bringing up information from a year ago and asking you thoughts about it is weird? It was a minor detail in a time where this argument wasn't much of an effect of the overall game. Therefore, why did he specifically target you versus asking others? To me, it felt scripted.
So I will stand by what I say. Pie's bringing up of your belief from a year ago could imply that you were on a scum team with Pie