XMAS MAFIA - Day Phase 2

Debates: 3

Posts: 2,049

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

GRAVEYARD

SupaDudz: You are MORDECHAI, the HEBREW HAMMER. During your youth you were tormented by your fellow students for being the only Jew in a school predominantly attended by Christians, and for celebrating Hanukkah while everyone else celebrated Christmas. This torture allowed you to develop very thick skin, and you grew up spending your life defending Jews. While you don't care about Christmas necessarily, you do wish to preserve the peace and perhaps even recruit others to celebrate Hanukkah with you. Thus you are a JOAT CULT RECRUITER. During the night phase you may carry out one of the following actions: recruit another player to the Jews, protect yourself, or protect another player. If you recruit a mafia player, the entire cult will die. You win if the cult is the dominant party at the end of the game.

Fake character claim options: XX, XX

Fake role claim options: XX, XX, XX, XX or XX

Speedrace: You are RALPHIE PARKER. Sure you're excited about Christmas, but for you it's just a means to an end. What you're really concerned about is getting your hands on an official Red Ryder carbine action two-hundred-shot range model air rifle. Then you can take out the bad guys yourself one by one, and everybody will love you if you get it right. You are the VIGILANTE and can shoot at a player during the night phase. You win with the town.

LIVING

01 whiteflame

02 Lunatic

03 oromagi

04 drafterman

05 that1user

06 iLikePie5

07 LikeMagic

08 Bullish

09 WaterPhoenix

10 MisterChris

With 10 players alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch. Day Phase 2 will end tentatively on December 26th at 9 am EST.

Topic's author

#2

Debates: 3

Posts: 2,049

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

-->

@Lunatic

@drafterman

@whiteflame

@MisterChris

@WaterPhoenix

Day Phase 2 is up!

Topic's author

#3

Debates: 3

Posts: 2,049

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

3

4

12.22.2020 11:27PM

-->

@Bullish

@ILikePie5

@oromagi

@That1User

@LikeMagic

Day Phase 2 is up!

#4

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:31PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:31PM

I am guessing supa recruited scum? This is probably good. Balance wise I am guessing a cult recruiter and maybe a serial killer? 2 scum and a cult recruiter seems a bit unfair for the town, but maybe I am wrong.

#5

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:34PM

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:34PM

I've been watching Santa Clause

#6

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:36PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:36PM

VTL WHITEFLAME FOR DEATH

#7

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:37PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:37PM

Speedrace might have vigged supa, he was suspicious of supa and voted him near the end of the day phase. I feel like that is the most likely scenario.

Supa's most likely recruit probably would have been speedrace because speed is a good player, and also it would get the pressure off of him. oro and misterchris were on him, oro is innocent townie, and I don't see him recruiting misterchris either. The most likely scenario then, is speed vigged supa.

#8

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:37PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:37PM

I don't see him recruiting misterchris over speed that is, but I could be wrong.

#9

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:38PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:38PM

Well getting cult recruiter out of the way was huge. And we have one less fake claim to worry about. I bought the character claim myself.

#10

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:39PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:39PM

I was visited last night by the caroler. I was given three player names, at least one of which is scum. White was one of the names

#11

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:39PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:39PM

-->

@LikeMagic

I was visited last night by the caroler. I was given three player names, at least one of which is scum. White was one of the names

and the other two?

#12

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:40PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:40PM

-->

@Lunatic

see my post. we should lynch whiteflame, though wait for more info first.

#13

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:41PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:41PM

-->

@Lunatic

you and bullish

#14

Debates: 45

Posts: 2,897

5

10

11

12.22.2020 11:41PM

5

10

11

12.22.2020 11:41PM

-->

@Lunatic

@whiteflame

@oromagi

@LikeMagic

I apologize folks, we had a scum lynch in the BAG if I had just caught up to the rest of the DP earlier (unfortunately I only got to like page 10 before the DP ended)

Here Water claimed Tracker.

“i'm elf on the shelf and i'm a tracker, the justifcation is relatively self explanatory. elf on the shelf sees stuff and tells santa about them, making me a tracker. please don't be stupid and lynch me while i'm gone.”

Water is lying.

I am Yukon Cornelius. In the Rudolph movie, I spend my life looking for ”silver & gold” (in reality it was peppermint, but this isn't revealed until later in the movie). I’m a kind man, and I do not mind using my skills to help navigate others & save Christmas. I am a tracker & win with town.

It’s not the greatest justification, but it’s the one Danielle gave.

I promise if we lynch WP he will flip as being anything but a tracker. If he doesn’t, you can lynch me. Similarly, you can lynch me for counter-claiming so late. When I flip town, you’ll know to lynch WP.

As for my tracker results... well, DP1 results are not very helpful: Lunatic visited Magic. Lunatic, if you could confirm that you did indeed visit Magic, that confirms my identity.

#15

Debates: 27

Posts: 3,198

4

6

10

12.22.2020 11:41PM

4

6

10

12.22.2020 11:41PM

Well, I guess Supa either visited scum or was killed by Speed. Glad to see a Hanukkah (technically just Jewish, but I'll take it)-themed character in the mix. Called it.

And of course, there's the inevitable VTL from Magic. Yes, because I had every reason to kill Speed, right? Not like he was making the case for me in the last DP or anything. Clearly, no one else on your list could have any greater likelihood of being scum. If you're so sure, then give us the other names.

#16

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:41PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:41PM

Keep in mind that if we find one scum among the caroler results, it does NOT town confirm the other two. I have been toying with the idea of giving dreamer/carol results two scum and one town result just to get rid of that logic and cause people to read role pm's carefully.

#17

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:42PM

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:42PM

oromagi Cindy Lou Who INNOCENT CHILD

X.Speedrace Ralphie Parker ViGiLANTE

TOWN

WaterPhoenix Elf on a Shelf TRACKER

Lunatic Jack Skellington

whiteflame

LikeMagic (movie) HATED

that1user

drafterman

Bullish (movie)

Pie

MisterChris

SCUM

Supa Mordechai CULT RECRUITERorPRoTECTOR

#18

Debates: 3

Posts: 7,408

3

6

12.22.2020 11:43PM

3

6

12.22.2020 11:43PM

-->

@MisterChris

As for my tracker results... well, DP1 results are not very helpful: Lunatic visited Magic. Lunatic, if you could confirm that you did indeed visit Magic, that confirms my identity.

I did visit magic.

So last two scum are bullish and water, or magic and water, if water is lying about the carol results. Awesome.

GG

vtl water.

#19

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:44PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:44PM

-->

@whiteflame

lolz

#20

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

12.22.2020 11:44PM

3

6

9

12.22.2020 11:44PM

We have one of Lunatic, Bullish, and whiteflame as maf.

We have Water being CC'd

TBH, the CC is stronger in my eyes.

VTL Water

#21

Debates: 45

Posts: 2,897

5

10

11

12.22.2020 11:44PM

5

10

11

12.22.2020 11:44PM

-->

@Danielle

@Lunatic

VTL Water

Thx for confirming.

#22

Debates: 117

Posts: 8,689

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:45PM

8

10

11

12.22.2020 11:45PM

oromagi Cindy Lou Who INNOCENT CHILD

X.Speedrace Ralphie Parker ViGiLANTE

TOWN

MisterChris Yukon Cornelius TRACKER

WaterPhoenix Elf on a Shelf TRACKER (CC)

Lunatic Jack Skellington

whiteflame

LikeMagic (movie) HATED

that1user

drafterman

Bullish (movie)

Pie

SCUM

Supa Mordechai CULT RECRUITERorPRoTECTOR

#23

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:45PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:45PM

We have to kill me soon, whenever we do it, no matter what White must go. Luna has been very town behaviorally. Bullish I am unsure of, but like Luna said there can be more than one scum among my list

Topic's author

#24

Debates: 3

Posts: 2,049

3

4

12.22.2020 11:46PM

3

4

12.22.2020 11:46PM

Vote Count

WaterPhoenix (Lunatic, drafterman, MisterChris) -- 3/6 votes

whiteflame (Magic) -- 1/6 votes

#25

Debates: 0

Posts: 209

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:47PM

0

2

3

12.22.2020 11:47PM

-->

@drafterman

That is complete insanity. Water claimed first. Misterchris said nothing until this DP. You should wait for water to come on and explain first. You are so scummy.

#26

Debates: 27

Posts: 3,198

4

6

10

12.22.2020 11:47PM

4

6

10

12.22.2020 11:47PM

Making dinner, will catch up again when I'm done.

#27

Debates: 12

Posts: 2,094

3

10

12.22.2020 11:48PM

3

10

12.22.2020 11:48PM

i'd like to clarify the full claim i made last dp. i am not a tracker i am a WATCHER.

#28

Debates: 6

Posts: 5,653

3

6

9

12.22.2020 11:48PM

3

6

9

12.22.2020 11:48PM

-->

@LikeMagic

That is complete insanity. Water claimed first. Misterchris said nothing until this DP. You should wait for water to come on and explain first. You are so scummy.

Yeah, when there is a CC you get the person that claimed first.

#29

Debates: 12

Posts: 2,094

3

10