-->
@Earth
@Lunatic
@whiteflame
@badger
What are your reads so far in the game?
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood DP2
Posts
Total:
162
-->
@ILikePie5
I think it's in TUF, Polyglot, whiteflame, the latter's playing being entirely the most unconscionable, the two former just not having contributed enough. The problem in that for me then is that Polyglot's character claim would seem to prop up whiteflame's.
I want more from Polyglot.
The problem with reading around likely characters in this game is that the game was pruned btw. It was originally meant to be 13, right? Roles would have been picked for rather than characters and little rewriting of characters to fit roles, I think.
-->
@badger
The problem in that for me then is that Polyglot's character claim would seem to prop up whiteflame's.
Idk much about the show so can you please explain?
I want more from Polyglot.
I agree. He just comes in and leaves. Have you played with him in the past? Is this how he normally plays if so?
-->
@ILikePie5
Idk much about the show so can you please explain?
Polyglot's character is the assistant/bodyguard of whiteflame's character.
I agree. He just comes in and leaves. Have you played with him in the past? Is this how he normally plays if so?
I haven't played this game in 5 fucking years Pie lol.
Hey there ya'll. I Am Alex Louis Armstrong.
unvote
looks like everyone has claimed. I am going to do some theme research here see what seems sketch.
-->
@badger
The problem with reading around likely characters in this game is that the game was pruned btw. It was originally meant to be 13, right? Roles would have been picked for rather than characters and little rewriting of characters to fit roles, I think.
Very true. I think characters mean very little this game at least from my perspective of not knowing the theme. Only with roles can we get a legitimate gauge of scummy roles, along with behavior ofc.
With regards to behavior, I really suspect Wylted just cause he was the foremost promoter of mafia and he isn’t active. I just can’t believe it.
Polygot idk much about so can’t get a read on him
Earth only gets active when he’s gonna be lynched so he leans town to me unless the split is the brothers vs everyone else
Lunatic is just inactive though his aggression on me leans town. He does that a lot when he’s town because he always thinks imma fool him
Whiteflame is just hard to read for me but I’ll look at old games again
Badger is definitely town and my top town read
Unvote
I think Earth/Wytled are kinda clear tbh. They're the Elric brothers. Earth also kinda softed BG D1, or mention of vests by Chris was the only thing he perked up for anyway. Reading back, looks like he was playing off being BG himself.
TUF's claim is also a very solid one.
Which brings me back to Riza Hawkeye again. I would lynch Polyglot here.
-->
@ILikePie5
Lunatic is just inactive though his aggression on me leans town. He does that a lot when he’s town because he always thinks imma fool him
1. I am not inactive
2. I never said that so I think your giving yourself too much credit lol
I am researching these characters and none of them really seem "sus". I imagine the mafia were set up with some decent fake claims.
-->
@ILikePie5
Yeah you are relying to heavy on the -online message. You have to look at activity to see if somebody is on. I think mine always says online
-->
@Lunatic
They're all solid claims, mafia were definitely set up. Pie's and Polyglot's claims are the secondary or tertiary characters, but again, about Pie's, a miller might have chosen for where the game was being pruned.
I think getting Polyglot's full claim is sensible here.
I buy badgers reasoning here. Seems like solid logic. I could get on board to lunch poly
Also there appears to be a whole other arc of this show I didn't watch. I don't venture much outside Netflix. And at that most of the shows I watch these days are while "working from home" lol.
VTL Poly for full claim.
-->
@Polyglot
There is enough votes to lynch you. Please full claim. I'd rather lynch pie so looking for any reason to not vote you tight now
Unvote vtl poly
Unvote
I’m in China currently, so my time is way off.
Based on my role description I’m associated with Roy Mustang and can confirm that role is most likely in the game.
I am the messenger because I share information with various people in the game and can share information in the next night phase to prove that.
-->
@badger
I haven't played this game in 5 fucking years Pie lol.
It was worth a shot 🤷♂️
-->
@Lunatic
1. I am not inactive
Good, cause my activity gauge is off
2. I never said that so I think your giving yourself too much credit lol
You said you had found a way to read me and scumread me when I apparently did it, but I was town that game lol
-->
@Wylted
Yeah you are relying to heavy on the -online message. You have to look at activity to see if somebody is on. I think mine always says online
I don’t think that’s possible unless you always have a tab open with you logged in
-->
@Polyglot
I am the messenger because I share information with various people in the game and can share information in the next night phase to prove that.
So you didn’t send a Message to anyone last night? If so, why not?
And what’s your justification for Hawkeye being a Messenger?
Chris - Winry Rockbell - Giver: 1x Cop, 1x Vigilante, 1x Bulletproof
Pie - Maria Ross - Miller
Earth - Alphonse Elric - Bulletproof
Polygot - Riza Hawkeye - Messenger
Badger - Van Hohenheim - 1x Cop
Wylted - Edward Elric - ???
Lunatic - Alex Louis Armstrong - ???
Whiteflame - Roy Mustang - ???
-->
@ILikePie5
2. I never said that so I think your giving yourself too much credit lolYou said you had found a way to read me and scumread me when I apparently did it, but I was town that game lol
Yeah your scum tell is basically when you are really cocky and arrogant. You give the impression that you aren't scum hunting, and you are more prone to just argue for the sake of arguing or get defensive.
-->
@Polyglot
You are Roy Mustang or your are associated with him?
-->
@Lunatic
Yeah your scum tell is basically when you are really cocky and arrogant. You give the impression that you aren't scum hunting, and you are more prone to just argue for the sake of arguing or get defensive.
I was town that game lol
-->
@ILikePie5
I was town that game lol
I dont know what game you are referring to, I am referring to the times you are scum.
And what’s your justification for Hawkeye being a Messenger?
I share information from Roy to his soldiers and also information about the Ishvalan Civil War to the Elric brothers.
So you didn’t send a Message to anyone last night? If so, why not?
Last night I didn’t send any message. Honestly this is the first time I’ve ever played as a messenger so this role is kind of new for me. And I don’t think I had any vital information to share.
-->
@Lunatic
I’m associated with Roy Mustang’s character based on my role description. That’s why I can confirm he’s in the game. But my actual role as messenger has nothing to do with him.