-->
@AustinL0926
Pretty townie honestly. At least, not scummy.
My Favorite Anime Character's Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
208
If That2 doesn't claim Gandalf or some anime equivalent with that opening post, she's mafia.
I expect she will though.
I'm back!
And the other knight has yet to appear. I'll have to talk to the baron about this.
More seriously, popcorn claiming genre and sex seems like a good idea. However, since we are popcorning, let me just put this here.
DO. NOT. CLAIM. OUT. OF. ORDER.
Every single time, someone claims out of order for absolutely no reason. Don't be that guy.
A few reads.
I townread Pie due to his miller claim.
Badger feels pretty towny so far. He seems more active than last game, but that could also just be that his posts aren't getting drowned out in a flood of activity.
Wylted has yet to do anything interesting. That may or may not mean anything.
Earth, as in every other game I've played with him, hasn't said enough for me to get a read on him.
-->
@ILikePie5
Please list your characters Genre and Sex please
I don't support this In general so won't popcorn to anybody else. Whiteflame can choose if he wants but I am female And sci fi
-->
@AustinL0926
we could ask Pie, who is the towniest player right now
Jesus H. Christ
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
Why not?
That2 is bouncing from idea to idea, which seems like her normal town play.
-->
@SirAnonymous
I townread Pie due to his miller claim.
WTF is wrong with you people
-->
@SirAnonymous
Why not?
I guess gender and genre is probably harmless. I would rather information on the temperament of the character to test my theory which is possibly extremely premature
BestKorea does seem more subdued this game. More like McDonald's than BK.
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
I townread Pie due to his miller claim.WTF is wrong with you people
I've never seen a fake miller claim. It's such a common role that it makes no sense to fake claim it.
-->
@SirAnonymous
I wouldn't read too much into best Korea behaving differently since he was lynched DP1 as town both times he played the game. It probably has him second guessing everything he does
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
That is a valid point.
-->
@SirAnonymous
I've never seen a fake miller claim. It's such a common role that it makes no sense to fake claim it.
I have seen it several times and it is a pretty safe fake claim of there is no godfather or lawyer in the scum PM it can help you survive quite a few DPs without suspicion . FT claimed miller last time I played with him and he was scum
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
BK was modkilled DP1 last game, and was nowhere close to being lynched.
Why are you skeptical of Pie's miller claim? It seems quite unlikely for scum to fakeclaim it, considering the risks.
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
I suppose that if anyone were to use it as a fake claim, it would be Pie because of his opinions on millers. However, I don't think it's very likely.
BTW, why is everyone overlooking Earth? If he can get away with lurking and posting <5 posts every single day phase, then we'd be handing him the win every time he's scum.
-->
@AustinL0926
Wylted doesn't like Millers. He prefers Coor's.
-->
@AustinL0926
You're right about that, but it's a problem with no real solution. We can't make him post more. We could just lynch him and other inactive players every time, but that would be no fun for them, or for us, because we'd lose if the mafia were active players.
-->
@AustinL0926
Why are you skeptical of Pie's miller claim? It seems quite unlikely for scum to fakeclaim it, considering the risks.
It's only risky if there is a cop in the game. WTF . The only people who pretty much know if there is a cop would be possibly one town player and whoever is on the scum team probably has a good ideal. Let's not get the DP off track with this bullshit though. It is one thing for me to have experienced players believe that bullshit but now they are infecting new players with it as well.
There is no CC, I am happy not lynching pie since I am the only one who believes it should be a policy lynch anyway. Can we drop it or talk about it in a different thread
-->
@SirAnonymous
Yea, personally I'm just skeptical, since it seems that a large game like this would have a Cop (almost guaranteed) and Miller (likely). I went through a few archived games on this site with 10+ player setups, and most of them had them. Considering that no one has CC'd yet, there are three possibilities:
- There is no Cop or Miller, and Pie is going for an unnecessarily risky gambit
- The Miller is one of the two inactives
- Pie is telling the truth
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
"There is no CC, I am happy not lynching pie since I am the only one who believes it should be a policy lynch anyway."
This makes literally zero sense..?
-->
@PREZ-HILTON
@AustinL0926
Wylted is correct that there's no point in flooding the DP with posts about millers.
I forgot how stupid this site was for millers had I known that I would have given mafia that as a fake claim in my game just to teach everyone a lesson
Unvote
VTL Austin
-->
@AustinL0926
This makes literally zero sense..?
Which part makes no sense? The part where I said nobody has CCed (counter claimed) the miller claim or the part where I acknowledged my philosophy is different than everyone else's and I will have to concede to their philosophy for the time being?