DebateArt should have an independent psychological group rate members on their behavior

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.26.2023 04:25AM

1

3

9

07.26.2023 04:25AM

Instead of a leaderboard, DebateArt should have an independent psychological group rate members on their behavior.

I have noticed a number of members who seem to be borderline irrational in their comments.

It may be better to drop the leaderboard, and replace it with an independent analysis of their comments.

#2

ADreamOfLiberty

Debates: 0

Posts: 2,890

3

2

ADreamOfLiberty

07.26.2023 05:03AM

3

2

07.26.2023 05:03AM

-->

@prefix

I have noticed a number of members who seem to be borderline irrational in their comments.

Borderline? If the border between rationality and irrationality was as the Mexico-USA border, then there are people snooping around the Canada-US border (insanity, delusions of persecution/grandeur/etc...).

...and it would be wonderful news if the few people on this website were the only ones. They appear less well adjusted than the average man or woman but no less irrational.

Given that...

an independent psychological group

Has very little likelihood of evaluating anyone or anything with any reliability.

#3

Debates: 22

Posts: 11,287

3

6

07.26.2023 06:01AM

3

6

07.26.2023 06:01AM

-->

@prefix

Certain age groups are well known to have a propensity for irrationality.

Especially Male.

Hormones are to blame.

Can I be the independent analyst?

#4

TWS1405_2

Debates: 4

Posts: 2,186

3

7

TWS1405_2

07.26.2023 09:03AM

3

7

07.26.2023 09:03AM

-->

@ADreamOfLiberty

Well said.

#5

Debates: 4

Posts: 1,327

3

2

07.26.2023 10:41AM

3

2

07.26.2023 10:41AM

This may be the dumbest idea I have ever heard of. Lol

#6

Debates: 269

Posts: 7,711

4

6

10

07.26.2023 11:01AM

4

6

10

07.26.2023 11:01AM

I have noticed a number of members who seem to be borderline irrational in their comments.

Hey, thats not a nice thing to say. You are mean.

#7

Debates: 167

Posts: 3,837

5

8

11

07.26.2023 12:03PM

5

8

11

07.26.2023 12:03PM

-->

@prefix

Instead of a leaderboard, DebateArt should have an independent psychological group rate members on their behavior.

I have noticed a number of members who seem to be borderline irrational in their comments.

It may be better to drop the leaderboard, and replace it with an independent analysis of their comments.

Maybe remove the forum post leaderboard. That means naught. But the debating leaderboard that catalogues everyone's wins and losses, nah.

#8

Debates: 269

Posts: 7,711

4

6

10

07.26.2023 12:12PM

4

6

10

07.26.2023 12:12PM

-->

@Intelligence_06

Maybe remove the forum post leaderboard.

But I like that leaderboard 🥺

#9

Debates: 167

Posts: 3,837

5

8

11

07.26.2023 01:01PM

5

8

11

07.26.2023 01:01PM

-->

@Best.Korea

What does that mean? The debating leaderboard means how experienced and how good you are, the forums leaderboard just means how much of a spammer you are over the time.

Unless there is a leaderboard for like/post ratio.

#10

Debates: 269

Posts: 7,711

4

6

10

07.26.2023 01:08PM

4

6

10

07.26.2023 01:08PM

-->

@Intelligence_06

how much of a spammer you are over the time.

I like good spam.

#11

Debates: 0

Posts: 5,135

3

4

8

07.26.2023 03:16PM

3

4

8

07.26.2023 03:16PM

-->

@prefix

DebateArt should have an independent psychological group rate members on their behavior.

Yes, I agree.

Topic's author

#12

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.26.2023 04:04PM

1

3

9

07.26.2023 04:04PM

-->

@zedvictor4

I don't blame "hormones".

I blame the failure of the US educational system.

Here is a good example:

A local news outlet reported on a story. The story did not make any sense. They missed reporting on the cause that was at the root of the story. So I contacted them and they "updated" their report.

How did the story get released without being complete?

#13

Debates: 565

Posts: 19,930

10

11

07.26.2023 04:40PM

10

11

07.26.2023 04:40PM

-->

@prefix

I think a report on your psyche would be predictable and narcissistic tendencies would be present.

If that is an insult, perhaps consider a fatal flaw of what you seek... what is positive in one context is negative in another.

You seek the only leaderboard you think would prove others inferior to you here as the current ones rank you low.

Feeling above the rest of us is a feeling, not a conclusion or fact. Ask yourself why the LB affects you at all and then ask a therapist. Let us know your psyche's evaluation. Did it come with a score to rank you?

#14

Debates: 22

Posts: 11,287

3

6

07.27.2023 06:59AM

3

6

07.27.2023 06:59AM

-->

@prefix

I wouldn't agree.

Some would seemingly fail the system and some would seemingly make a success of the system.

Which would suggest that failure or success relative to a system that undoubtedly provides opportunity, is down to the individual.

Which would further suggest that other influences outside the system play a greater role in educational success or failure.

Topic's author

#15

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.27.2023 03:18PM

1

3

9

07.27.2023 03:18PM

Maybe the rationality of the comments on DebateArt would improve if members were held to a higher psychological quotient ( PQ ) .

#16

Debates: 0

Posts: 5,135

3

4

8

07.27.2023 04:10PM

3

4

8

07.27.2023 04:10PM

-->

@prefix

When I was at MIT I took a Positive Intelligence Quotient test. My score was 100. How is that?

#17

Debates: 0

Posts: 5,135

3

4

8

07.27.2023 04:16PM

3

4

8

07.27.2023 04:16PM

I actually did work on the Manhattan Project. Well, it was actually the FlashDancers Gentlemen's Club in downtown Manhattan project.

#18

Debates: 565

Posts: 19,930

10

11

07.27.2023 04:54PM

10

11

07.27.2023 04:54PM

-->

@FLRW

Why don't you make a thread of it, link us to the URL of a free but still good one?

I personally think too much optimism is toxic, stupid and unhealthy so I am not expecting a very high score but I do have good mental self-reassurement.

#19

Debates: 565

Posts: 19,930

10

11

https://assessment.positiveintelligence.com/saboteur/overview

07.27.2023 05:07PM

10

11

07.27.2023 05:07PM

-->

@FLRW

I took a test that emails me and got different sabeteur scores across 9 types.

It didn't give an overall out of 100. I think this test is out of 90 as the scores were out of 10. Since the scores are so detailed, i'd rather keep the results to myself.

Here is the test, you need to give a name, age, gender and employment status but only the name is forced, and you can give a fake name.

Topic's author

#20

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.28.2023 03:08AM

1

3

9

07.28.2023 03:08AM

-->

@Vegasgiants

This may be the dumbest idea I have ever heard of. Lol

And why do you feel that way?

Topic's author

#21

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.28.2023 03:10AM

1

3

9

07.28.2023 03:10AM

-->

@Best.Korea

Hey, thats not a nice thing to say. You are mean.

Descriptive reality is not nice by its very nature.

And I am not mean....I am observational.

#22

Debates: 20

Posts: 38

0

7

07.28.2023 10:06AM

0

7

07.28.2023 10:06AM

-->

@prefix

DebateArt should have an independent psychological group rate members on their behavior.

What would be the goal of this? If ppl are acting up, wouldn't it obvious ?

#23

Debates: 4

Posts: 1,327

3

2

07.28.2023 11:34AM

3

2

07.28.2023 11:34AM

-->

@prefix

The idea that this forum could afford to pay independent psychological experts to perform psychological reviews here is utterly laughable

Topic's author

#24

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:37PM

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:37PM

-->

@Vegasgiants

The idea that this forum could afford to pay independent psychological experts to perform psychological reviews here is utterly laughable

Would that laugh be such that would require a psychological review?

Topic's author

#25

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:40PM

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:40PM

-->

@Average_Person

What would be the goal of this? If ppl are acting up, wouldn't it obvious ?

If it were obvious, the independent psychological group would not be needed.

It is obviously not obvious to the persons in need of the independent psychological group.

#26

Debates: 4

Posts: 1,327

3

2

07.28.2023 07:42PM

3

2

07.28.2023 07:42PM

-->

@prefix

No

And I say this as one who gave them for decades. Lol

#27

Debates: 20

Posts: 38

0

7

07.28.2023 07:43PM

0

7

07.28.2023 07:43PM

-->

@prefix

Ur answering the question by saying the question has an answer. This ain’t a debate where you can throw a fallacy.

Topic's author

#28

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:47PM

1

3

9

07.28.2023 07:47PM

-->

@Vegasgiants

Thus proving my point.

#29

Debates: 4

Posts: 1,327

3

2

07.28.2023 07:48PM

3

2

07.28.2023 07:48PM

-->

@prefix

Dismissed

Topic's author

#30

Debates: 7

Posts: 339

1

3

9