Here’s an honest question for you: why do you think the Whitehouse included Fox News, the pro GOP outlier, in the memo? I don’t actually have a good working theory on that decision…
I don't either. To take a shot in the dark... I'd guess it was a PR move to avoid people like yourself using it to claim this memo proves the MSM and the democrats are working together.
Also, why wouldn’t you issue such a memo?
Because the White House shouldn't be dictating to media outlets what they cover, so the letter is a lose lose. If they cover it because of the letter they've crossed the line, if they cover it regardless of their programming preferences then it didn't make a difference.
the Whitehouse went out of its lane in the memo, and CNN reporter Oliver Darcy not only failed to point this out, he basically spent his entire article validating the memo. Whether media is “in alignment” or not with the Whitehouse should be purely incidental to its central job of reporting “without passion or prejudice.” If the Whitehouse doesn’t stay within its role, the media response should be pushback, not compliance!
If I tell you to tie your shoes before you leave the house tomorrow and you do, is that compliance?
You call it compliance because you seem to disregard the fact that Darcy didn't say anything he nor the network hasn't been saying repeatedly for weeks... because it's true, and reporting the truth is exactly what the media is supposed to do.
I do get what you're saying, and it's true it would have looked better if Darcy included the disclaimer that the Biden WH should not telling media networks what to cover, but again, that's only a concern here and if you already believe there's something nefarious going on in the first place. Without that, your entire gripe is nothing more than a process criticism, which I sincerely doubt you would have found worthy of a whole thread.
I’m finding myself just repeating or rewording what I have already said at length. If you truly don’t get… or align with what I’m saying, then we will have to agree to disagree.
I get what you're saying completely. Again, it all begins with the underlying facts of the story the memo pointed to, if we disagree on that the rest we're going to disagree on.
if you can, cite the stats that show Fox has greater influence than CNN, MSNBC, NYT, ABC, CBS, NBC, and AP combined.
I didn't say Fox alone had higher viewership, I'm talking about right wing media which includes the other networks, podcasts and talk radio.
But to this point, not about to go crazy with Google but here is something I found rather quickly...
"According to Comscore TV Essentials® data, viewership decreased for CNN and MSNBC but increased for Fox News in 2022. The average audience (defined as the average number of TVs tuned to a program throughout a time period) for the prime news time slot (8 to 11 p.m.) decreased by 25% for CNN, from 1.1 million in 2021 to 828,000 in 2022. MSNBC’s audience declined by 6% over this period, from about 881,000 to 827,000. On the other hand, Fox News’ audience increased from 1.9 million in 2021 to 2.1 million in 2022, a 10% increase."
So in the prime time slot on Fox news they had 2.1 million viewers vs 1.6 million viewers on CNN and MSNBC combined.
Point out one of many reasons for the public’s growing mistrust in our institutions, and you get “But Trump tho!” It never seems to occur to them that part (or much) of Trump’s popularity is precisely because of that mistrust.
But that mistrust is not based on facts, that's the point. It's all propaganda, which is a large part of my point here. The fact that the republicans are trying to paint Biden as some crime family mob boss with absolutely no evidence and yet CNN's pointing to this fact is twisted as evidence of media compliance is a perfect illustration of it.
Trump's popularity was a product of Fox News's old "truth teller" strategy; tell it's viewers what they wanted to hear rather than what was true and then tell their audience that they are the only ones willing to tell the truth. It's quite a lucrative deal. You gain a faithful following because no one else is feeding it's audience what they want, and then you lock them in by isolating them by getting them to distrust everyone else. We've seen this strategy play out many times over from Alex Jones to Andrew Tate.
Trump is Frankenstein, Fox news and the republican party are what created him. They made their money and gained their power by manipulating their audience/constituency and now it's outgown them. Mitt Romney said not a single republican talks about Trump any differently behind the scenes than he does publicly. They all understand full well what a jackass he is along with the people who actually think he's some hero fighting for them.