ILikePie5

I’d rather go after you. You say your a comfortable role. When will you be confirmed?

I think you'd have to believe that WyIted would give out a lynchproof role to scum, which they can activate at any point during the DP, for this to be true. I get the comparison to the Magistrate, but that role at least required some anticipation of a wagon forming since it was only usable during the NP, and couldn't be used on yourself (to my knowledge). 

Yes, that's what I said. Given that no one else has claimed to have results from the NP, I'd say the lack of a CC isn't proof positive, so the lean town pile makes sense to me.

Given that scum have already messed with roles and might do so again, I'm not sure we should be pushing for everyone and their mother to full claim. I think there are probably general questions we could ask about DD's role before we make them tell us everything.

Alright, fair enough. I am the Reporter. I can target someone at night to see if they visited anyone. Last night I targeted Savant, who did not visit anyone.

Alright, I'll say this much: I am an investigative role. I'd prefer to not give more detail just yet.

Also, please remember to tag me if you are going to vote for me.

What is with this confirmable role meme you keep spamming? Am I wrong in remembering that you said you couldn't confirm your affiliation with it?

You can try to lynch me. I don't really know what else I can do.

Okay so I'm Howard Dean. My ability is the Howard Dean scream, I can become immune to being lynched for one day period.

Hi everyone sorry for the inactivity. I still need to catch up on things, I've had a hectic day. I should be more active now. 

I

Owen not posting situation is something to note but with a silencer I wouldn't lynch just based on that.

As you point out joebob could be lying about not using it. It could also be that lunatic used it before the switch... you know, different timelines.

What did you dislike about what Casey said?

The response he gave in post 58 served to imply an attack on me asking in the first place and attempt to redirect the attention elsewhere. Compare this to an alternate response that doesn't involve claiming, which could look something like "I do not want to claim for x reason".

The response he gave implies defensiveness while the response he could have given implies conditional cooperation.

Further dialogue along the same line consistently kept that same tone.

Back to work my next break is in a few hours.

So is the idea to lynch Pie? Because I'm not down for that with a confirmable role, even if it doesn't confirm his affiliation. I don't love that he avoided answering your question, but that's not reason enough for me to pursue that lynch. I have other reasons to be against it based on what he has hinted at so far as well through his softclaim.

That being said, I have a similar PoE to you with the exception of Austin, who I'm townreading based on his saying that his role supports the existence of Barney's Hated. Maybe I'm just not in the same headspace as you and Pie, but Austin said his role is highly indicative of his being town and at least softclaimed something that suggests a Hated in the game. Savant says he's somewhat confirmable, and I agree that he's behaviorally above board.

So that puts my aim squarely at 3 people: Casey, Owen and you. We have character claims from the former two and nothing from you so far, but you're the least behaviorally sus of those three, so I'm open to getting a role claim from either Casey or Owen first.

Alright that's all the deflection I need to hear let's lynch the sucker.

Is it one of those roles that could be town or scum? If so I don't really care.

If you said that then I missed it. It isn't noted on the list.

What makes you so sure he is lying about being confirmed by MyLo?

Pie is the only one out of those four that hasn't already claimed so let's start by getting a claim from him.

vtl pie

I have a new role and character, not saying what it is.

My role and character from DP1, is what it says lunatics is.

I have a new role and character, not saying what it is.

My role and character from DP1, is what it says lunatics is.

what kind of sorcery is this

Can you explain your vote on Owen a bit more? I don't feel super strongly about him, but he's at least a better option than policy lynching Barney.

My experience with him has been that if he felt it was worthwhile, he'd argue for what he's seeking, and the lack of attention on it beyond asking DD a question about why he's not seeking it doesn't sit right with me.

If he is, it's not for the reasons you said.

And even though he's lynchable, I already said I'm hesitant to go after him in that same post.

I town read Owen right now, since they are putting more effort into posting than I would expect as scum.

That means viable lynches rn (based on votes) are Barney, Pie, and JoeBob. I don't love Barney being on there, and I think we have room to expand our scum hunt, but I see Pie's behavior as anti-town for reasons I've already stated.

I'd like whiteflame or Luna to take a look at his posts and see if they agree.

I think Barney is definitely safe, they're putting a lot of effort into organizing scum hunting

Because I town read him. Seems obvious.

I thought you were talking about he weird "what do you know" question. I didn't see the scum read one.

I don't scum read anyone so far. There isn't really anything to go off of.