JoeBob

Wait why are you asking?

Yeah, it is very, very strange that Self-Watcher is the closest thing to a claimed investigative role that we have. I don't have a great feeling about JoeBob, largely because he has been mostly absent this DP. Between him and Earth, I'm leaning towards him. Of course, it's not up to me. 

Thinking about it rationally, I think Scum!Owen would be foolish to fake claim something like that when their target can go "lol I never got it." 

performed by or on that player

By or on, dude. Both. Not one specific direction

So the PM you received said Moozer performed a night action?

Glad you could join in Vader’s place. What are your results for your Motion Detector?

Trump: "Millions and millions of people … are pouring into our country monthly. Where it's, I believe 21 million people."

False. 

Politfact has not way to fact check this, the fact that they purported to proves they are not reliable.

I can reach out on Discord. He just vanished off the site for some reason.

Appreciate that. I considered just doing nothing, but figured Moozer was my strongest townread and might get some valuable results (he did, but no one believed him). Pie would probably have had your number if he'd survived, good choice for the first NK. He had Supa pegged before I did as well. 

the 'suspect fruit vendor' stands out, but claiming Jock in Middle School Mafia also brought a lot of suspicion on you).

we were actually told it before the game started

Makes sense. I figured scum were given at least some information and, absent fake claims, this seemed most likely.

GG everyone. That was a nice gambit on your part, JoeBob, though the big problem with your claim was that Vader's flip should have given a pretty solid basis for believing that scum had a limited pool of RBs. If I had survived into DP3, I would have sussed you pretty hard for saying you'd been RB'd, since scum would have been more likely to do that NP1 than to sit on it for NP2. Still, it wouldn't have been an easy choice, so well played.

you would have kept me alive I would have been mislynched. Really surprised you killed me

I have to know -- at what point did you figure out the theme split?

Okay, you have to explain your thinking in the whole watcher thing.

We have no way on confirming you to begin with at this moment.

Yes, but I never claimed to have a confirmable role. You did. That's the difference.

As for JoeBob, well, he never confirmed his role. That alone should be worthy of suspicion.

Alright, I think all that needs to be said has been said really, so I'm gonna take a look at the older DPs and then I'll make a decision. Can't promise it will be by the end of today, but I'll try.

 Fair enough. I am the year 53, the year the Roman emperor Trajan was born. I am a Vanilla. Moozer and JoeBob, what are you two?

I’m stuck on phone always so my typing is a bit slow

Fair enough, I'm a fast typist on a keyboard, but on mobile I am painfully slow

I am pretty pissed at Luna for that annoying play though. I see no good reason for lying other than just trolling us. We could definitely have won last round but that tripped us up.

More thoughts coming BTW

I disagree entirely. I know that Mharman has made several game with three Vanillas. Just look at this one:

https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/10675-indie-games-mafia-%5Bendgame%5D

Here's another point: I find it tough to believe that the only investigative role that Earth included in this game was a Motion Detector. While it is useful to an extent, MD is pretty weak. I'd say it's probably the weakest investigative role that I know of.

It would also explain why the NP was so incredibly quick. Luna was actually just a Vanilla, and Moozer's ability was a 1x, so Earth only had to wait for JoeBob and Vader to decide on what to do.