Total posts: 6,283
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
Why don't you just have people vote while signing up and choose the one with the most votes lol
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
It could also be speed and mafia have some crazy role Ive never heard of. lol But I can't lynch on that assumption.
Could go for Croc too honestly I was thinking about a role once where you can assume an identity and you always show up as that role/character and stuff and was thinking, what if mafia could just fake a role and that's what I get in my pm. Not likely but possible I guess
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
@Crocodile
croc if you are scum ima give you some props, you played better this game
+1 I noticed you being much more active, props
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
Speed, why do you doubt it's Croc?
It makes no sense to me that you would give mafia a ghoul
Created:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
me and ayyantu confirm each other
Wat? How do you confirm each other
out of all the roles on my list, avenger is the one that makes no sense as mafia. And mafia wouldn't get a list of all roles. So it's you or Ayyantu (or croc but I seriously doubt that)
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
It also doesn't tell me anything about his alignment.
Giving mafia two role cops would severely underpower scum
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
You're an Ascetic right
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
Croc's role counters town Avenger, in case that wasn't clear.
Didn't think of that. But mafia almost never gets protective roles, b/c if town is gonna nk a mafia and it fails then they'll just lynch them
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
This is the logic I use when bussing, I can see how powerful it is with statements like this lol. That said, not sure it makes a difference since we can afford to mislynches. We can just lynch both today and tomorrow and its a GG.
xD and yeah
Croc's role makes sense since it counters a night kill and my role.
Yep + it's on my list and I don't see why mafia would get that role. I think he's confirmed as well
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
Gives them a counter to the jailkeeper.
Exactly
Ascetic gives them a counter to tracker, by having ayya carry out kills.
Yep but less likely b/c of the bus
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
I think it makes more sense for it to be Water in this case. Ayy is possible but I'd rather lynch Water before him
That said by the way Ayy plays I agree that he's probably smart enough to pull that off but not as likely as a water scum
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
You're the only one I know is 100% town because I don't see Pie giving Avenger to scum. Scummy roles go in order of
Strengthener
Ascetic
Ghoul
I realized strengthener makes more sense as scum because it essentially turns any person into a strongman. Ascetic is an obv scum role tho as well so
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
To set you up with the claim you just made today.
But if he just didn't say anything that would've been better for me
Regardless, what are the chances scum would've role copped the only two unclaimed and alive players
I'm sticking with my theory that the ascetic is scum I think, if your Croc theory doesn't pan out. The only time I've seen an ascetic was when it was mafia
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
Oh gotcha. But why would he lie about Danielle and not you?
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
Sir said who he rolecopped?
We know they almost definitely RCd bear since there was no reason to NK him other than him being cop
Created:
-->
@Crocodile
I can't be scum, if mafia has a role cop then there's no reason to give them the list of all roles in the game
Created:
I am the Master Sword and I am the Seer. My role gives me the list of all roles in the game NP3. My justification is that the Master Sword is one of the most powerful items in the game but you only get it much later in the game.
The list I was given:
Tracker, Godfather, Dreaming God, Avenger, 2x Cop, Ghoul, Stalker, Ascetic, 2x Jailkeeper, Strengthener
Last mafia is either stalker, ascetic, or dreaming god depending on what Sir flips as
Everyone needs to claim
Created:
-->
@Danielle
I could say more but I won't in hopes the mafia keeps me alive tonight. Sus me, bitches!
LOL
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
Why Dani?
Also sorry but I missed the memo on why Ayyantu is town lol
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
A little defensive there, he didn't say you were a scum read, just asked you a question.
He said I'm a scum read like twice
Created:
-->
@SirAnonymous
Alrighty
VTL Intel
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
I'd especially like to know why Speed was so opposed to lynching Intelligence yesterday.
Please direct me to the post in which I was opposed to lynching him
Also didn't you just say I was town for lynching Supa over Intel? Why the sudden change of pace?
Created:
-->
@Danielle
There is at least 1 role we know of that allows players to post after death (tree stump). Why do you think it's fishy?
Because he keeps posting over and over again seemingly for no reason. Besides that, why give mafia the ability to talk when they can't contribute anything? I think there's more to it than just being tree stumped. Also tree stumping typically only works for NKs, not lynches
Created:
-->
@Danielle
Ok, it's cool just seemed like you were dodging the question which made me suspicious but I believe you
VTL Sir
Created:
-->
@Danielle
Gotcha. You deleted the post just because you said you weren't gonna post much?
Created:
-->
@Danielle
I've already answered your question! Why do you keep harping on me? Do you scum read me?
Where did you answer it? I keep harping on it because I have yet to get an answer
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
If danielle deleted a post shes probably allowed to the same way supa can talk post death. Holy sh1t
o.O
Created:
There's something fishy with the Supa thing. I think there's more to that than meets the eye
Created:
-->
@Danielle
VTL Danielle to get her to finally answer my question
Created:
-->
@Danielle
Last DP I was going to make a post about why I voted for Intel since people kept asking. He was my first choice for a claim for the following reasons:
Is that the post you deleted, and if so, why'd you delete it
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
I explained Water. Supa's #1 scum tell was claiming over & over that I was mislynching Water. Supa knew that Water was town.
Or Water is Supa's scum buddy that he didn't want to die?
Created:
I agree on pushing Intel
VTL Intel
Created:
-->
@Ayyantu
I'm never voting Water, not even if investigated guilty. Just so you know.
...?
Created:
-->
@SirAnonymous
That's valuable info. Since there was an NK, we know that BearMan can't be scum. However, I'm not sure it was a good idea to claim that, since it paints a target on his back, and yours as well (unless you're scum doing a gambit, which I guess is possible, though I don't think it's likely).
The other scum could've done the kill, 11 players means most likely 3 scum
Created:
It's possible for a dead player to still talk in the DP, although not sure why it would be for a confirmed mafia
Created:
-->
@Vader
Who are your scum buddies
Created:
Nice and not nice
Luna is clearly town imo
Created:
Posted in:
I may have polluted with my rolemadness only games ;-;
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@SirAnonymous
It's probably because most scumteams lack the sheer awesomeness that we had.
+1
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Even the two mafia wins though were very close. BAMF, supa survived by a miracle despite doc not making sense with a flipped jailkeeper, and me and sir won arrowverse on a lucky gambit that paid off, but could have easily backfired and killed both of us had intelligence not quick hammered.
Every mafia win is close lol
Created: