Vaarka

To clarify, the strongest point against Hammer is that nobody town reads him? Does anyone town read Earth? 

you don't get it. I have established the four possible mafia characters. there's no way sally is more mafia than those 4 and no way there's more than 4 mafia.

lunatic will replace me on d2 or i'll just post 0 content unless all agree to acknowledge me, I've notified him that I quit.

Earth hasn't done squat so he's just null. Supa early on was an FOS of mine, but don't want to lynch him yet b/c of his claim. Budda is right that it seems noob town and I know he doesn't have a ton of experience. 

Fair enough. I agree, but I do think TUF likely gave 1 fake claim so I could see a noob being eager to "confirm" themselves with it. 

Do you think it's weird that you find Earth null but me as a scum read despite my activity/analysis? (I do.) Is there any part of my analysis that you disagree with? How about drafterman's? 

sally is much more likely to be cc'd than jane by town if I'm mafia -RM

But I also wanna keep an FOS on him because then I lose any reason to have an FOS on you and my gut says to keep an FOS on you

You can FOS me at some other time. There's really no reason to now. I think Budda, drafter and myself have put forth the most analysis. Plus I breadcrumbed so I can always refer everyone back to that if/when I have to claim. I assume I'll be dead tomorrow though tbh. 

What do you think of Earth and Supa? I'd vote for GP today if we had no better options, but I think those two might be (especially Supa). Supa's behavior is weird/anti-town, but I can't tell if he's just generally a poor player. 

Also @Vaarka why are you still responding to RM? I thought we agreed for the sake of the game to ignore him. 

He thinks claiming an un-cc'd character somehow makes him town. Everything he says is virtually useless and/or wrong. Please don't derail the game by playing along. 

Lol why would I out my one town read (drafterman) if we were scum buddies? That means if one of us were found to be scum, it would automatically implicate (as in yield suspicion on) the other. Use your head. If anything, as scum I would "town read" someone innocent in order to #1 gain credibility and #2 put suspicion on them when I flip guilty. So this logic just sucks in general. You shouldn't believe we're both scum based on my town read of him. That's retarded. 

You're like a blind man asking how a colour confirms me as purplish.

Theme matters. I am uncc'd sally rayburn.

It's consistent with his suspicion of GP. It's not consistent with his posts that imply a willingness to bandwagon to accomplish a lynch. Trying to start ur own wagon with little time left isn't going to accomplish a lynch.

It seems

Are things always what they seem? What sort of corroborating evidence do you suppose could be used to determine if the way it seems, is the way it actually is? 

but I'm serious about that" here in post #189. 

 in that post he wasn't saying he was serious about it being suspicious. He was saying it reduces a person's credibility. He hasn't FOS'd me, by his own logic he can't. But it's interesting that I'm pushing Hammer, whom I haven't seen him give a disposition on. 

So you can't make a post that looks like a joke, then claim it's serious, then claim it's a joke again when it works against you. This is part of the FOS that is building up against you, it looks like you're trying to hedge your bets. No matter what anyone says, you have an "out

This is actually looking more and more like the case tbh. I'm moving Vaarka back to null fmpov.. it's still feasible he's town, but ur case is honestly showing i may have been a bit hasty in leaning town on him. 

Yeah, I'm not going to FOS for making a joke. But the thing is, you followed up that "joke" with a "yeah, but I'm serious about that" here in post #189. So you can't make a post that looks like a joke, then claim it's serious, then claim it's a joke again when it works against you. This is part of the FOS that is building up against you, it looks like you're trying to hedge your bets. No matter what anyone says, you have an "out."

Yeah, I'm not going to FOS for making a joke. But the thing is, you followed up that "joke" with a "yeah, but I'm serious about that" here in post #189. So you can't make a post that looks like a joke, then claim it's serious, then claim it's a joke again when it works against you. This is part of the FOS that is building up against you, it looks like you're trying to hedge your bets. No matter what anyone says, you have an "out."

How am I not being "aggressive" here? I just posted 6 paragraphs of analysis including a slew of insults toward RM lol. 

This is the kind of useless post that seems like (as drafterman said) you throwing out random comments and then seeing if any FOS' stick.

But yes, I am generally more aggressive when YYW plays. In Mafia and life in general, my harsh tone toward others is always in retaliation (not instigation). YYW is a scumbag when he plays, so I tend to respond in kind. RM is being douchey, but unlike YYW he seems genuinely dim so I do feel a little guilty by replying in kind. Oh well. I think it's best to just ignore him entirely for now. 

I also note that sometimes he starts off jokingly FOSing someone (Danielle is scum for watching TV, you're scum for using emojis) then develops that into a fullfledged FOS, as if he is testing the waters for an FOS on that person. But really, he's FOS'd 6 out of 9 people.

This is a good point. Did you see any town reads that i missed? Can't recall if he has TR'd anyone tbh

It just means he can't @ you or message you.  I have him blocked and can (unfortunately) read his posts just fine.

-drafter

To be clear, "gut feelings" are useless unless you have a history of your gut feelings being right. My guess is that you don't since I know you're wrong here (not sure about drafterman, but I thus far I haven't gotten scum vibes from him). 

I wasn't playing dumb. It wasn't clear that you made an INITIAL prediction, so a "next" prediction was confusing. Coupled with the fact that you've offered 0 analysis for drafterman or I potentially being scum, I wasn't sure what you were talking about. Settle down. 

On another note, I have drafterman as my most solid town read which is amusing given all the suspicion on him. Change my mind. 

Then you should also be finding Hammer and Earth sus as their activity is near equal to or less than the activity of Drafter/Danielle. In the case of Earth, far less than the activity of the latter pair.