Argument:You “The confederate flag is a literal racist hate symbol of white supremacy [
2]. But I argue it is more than just that, it is a symbol of treason itself. The Confederacy were traitors who betrayed the United States. Given that it is a symbol of betrayal of the country, there is absolutely no reason it should be made legal.”
You again: “The Confederate flag should not be legally sold or displayed on public property because it is a symbol of racial hate and white supremacy. “
I have already said, no matter how racist is a symbol is it should still be legal to show it because of the 1st amendment rights. I have already answered that in my first argument.
As for wether it’s hate speech, well most don’t actually view the flag that way and racist groups only later adopted the flag as their symbol.
You: “By saying this himself CON is admitting that if the confederate flag was a symbol of hatred that would justify making it illegal as this is the main point he builds his case around.”
Me: this argument is brainless, I did not admit that the flag was a hate symbol as I don’t believe it was a hate symbol. I just stated that even if it was a hate symbol it should still be a legal symbol to be bought and sold because of free speech.
You: “However as shown in source two, the Anti Defamation League itself says that the confederate flag is a racist hate symbol in its identification list of hate symbols. The flag is also carried in rallies of other white supremacists, hate, and racist groups like neo Nazis, the KKK, white nationalists, and the alt-right as the ADL shows. People frequently use it to salute Hitler. “
ADL also admits that non racists also use the flag by saying: “Organizations such as the Sons of Confederate Veterans adopted the flag as a symbol of Southern heritage”. Regardless ADL is nowadays a far left propaganda site rather than an organization that fights Antisemitism.
You: “Actually, CON's own supported region disagrees with him. According to Forbes "Majority Of Southerners Now View The Confederate Flag As A Racist Symbol, Poll Finds" [
5]. Most of the south itself sees it for the racist, white supremacist, neo nazi symbol it is. “
Me: There are many problems with this argument. First of all this is a bandwagon fallacy, if other people disagree with me, I shouldn’t have to agree with them. Second of all, I can’t truly trust the study(without more similar studies) because it disagrees with many other studies such as:
https://www.ajc.com/news/many-americans-view-confederate-flag-symbol-pride-not-racism-poll-finds/bF3SjgmwXf4QGF0B1kRhqL/?outputType=ampAnd once again, even if it was a hate symbol, it is protected by the first amendment as free speech.
vote
According to the Anti-Defamation League, the Confederate flag is a hate symbol. They say: In 1860-61, eleven southern states seceded from the United States to protect the institution of slavery, forming the Confederate States of America and precipitating the Civil War. During the war, the Confederacy and its military forces used a variety of flags, but the flag that became most associated with the Confederacy was the so-called "battle flag." Organizations such as the Sons of Confederate Veterans adopted the flag as a symbol of Southern heritage but the flag also served as a potent symbol of slavery and white supremacy, which has caused it to be very popular among white supremacists in the 20th and 21st centuries. This popularity extends to white supremacists beyond the borders of the United States.
I will bet that Payton Gendron had one in his room.
You get some, you don't get some is the unfortunate nature of operating under a schedul;e that does not permit a bulk of activity
Everything is fair enough, I suppose
Just not able to have posted what I wanted this time
I had Covid, I didn't have enough time.
I’m not a racist or neonazi but racists and neonazis have a right to free speech as long as they are doing physical harm to anyone or destroying property.
I’ve seen countless Pakistani flags lol. I’m not offended by them
Let's hang the flag of Pakistan up in your household okay?
Only people who want to get offended by a flag get offended. It’s just a flag dude. Deal with it
I am not a fan of people who take to long to make rebuttals.
As a proud southerner I would proudly hang a confederate flag(or any conservative or American flag for that manner) if I could on my room.
If I am a proud mississippian(if that is how it is spelt), then flying the mississippi flag, which contains the confederate flag actually, shouldn't be illegal.
Sure, I mean, I don't see anything wrong with flying the confederate flag. It has a nice design as well.
It's protected freedom of speech, further it's one of the best ways to advertise your front window as brick donation drop off center.